Mediocre at best

** PROS **
1) Great environment.
2) Love playing at any time other that night.
3) Good amount of supplies.
4) Long campaign.

** CONS **
1) AI navigation was at most times buggy and horrible.
2) Last level's turret is pretty much useless.
3) Last level can be designed much better.
4) The start of the second level is an overkill for no reason at all.

Overall Grade: C

It's a fun campaign, but not a balanced one. It's either too easy, or too hard, black and white, not something between (applies for both co-op and solo). I hate it when maps don't have good AI movement, but I guess that's Valve's responsibility as well, as in my opinion, L4D's AI is horrible in general. Good map, needs improvements.

Well made, with some flaws.

** PROS **
1) Well designed levels.
2) Great atmosphere.
3) It keeps you interested.
4) It's neither confusing, nor it is very easy to guide yourself through the maps.
5) Great, balanced campaign.
6) Very good rescue map.

** CONS **
1) Some bad AI movement.

Overall Grade: A-

That was fun to play. It's a balanced, well-made campaign. All areas seem unique and they're just the challenge someone needs. It's not too easy and not an overkill hard like some campaigns are. The creator clearly dedicated a lot of time to the creation of this campaign and I thank him/her for doing this. This could easily be an official campaign.

A mess

--PROS--
1) Lots of supplies.
2) Decent AI movement.
3) Matches the rural environment.

--CONS--
1) Bad level design.
2) Bad decorations.
3) All AI just randomly died at one point when climbing down some debris.
4) Lots of empty rooms and areas.
5) Bad final battle.
6) No indications as to where you must go for the rescue. The rescue is a garage door that opens behind a fallen truck. I randomly found it as I was running away from the tanks.
7) No ending scene. You just go to the rescue spot and credits immediately pop up.

Overall Grade: F. As the title says, it's a mess. The aesthetic and level design can be improved, but I just hate so many empty rooms...The rescue part must be improved, it's the first map I've found where there is no indication as to where the rescue spot is. I was lucky to find it. The AI is good, but when it just randomly died, I was at a tough spot. Lots of supplies help a lot.

Starts strong, gets extremely repetitive mid-way.

--PROS--
1) Interesting first 3 maps
2) I like the use of in-game tips on what to do next, I've never seen this before.
3) Liked the third map battle.

--CONS--
1) Bots wouldn't enter the safe house on the third map. I had to wait for them to die...
2) I like mazes, but man you made me hate them in your campaign.
3) The campaign started strong, but became repetitive on maps 4-6. It's the same thing over and over and over again. You exit the level, you go in the mini-maze to find an item and use it to go through. So it's like, FIND ITEM, USE IT, REPEAT, for like 3-4 times in a map. It becomes boring. I lost all interest in the fifth map. Shame, because it looked like it was going to be good.
4) Bots had a hard time moving in this campaign.
5) No ending scene.

Overall Grade: C-. It started strong, but the levels 4-6 were just copy-paste. Not a good work on maps 4-6.

So much potential, could be a lot better.

**Played on Advanced & Expert**

---PROS---
1) Excellent map design.
2) Exploration is something worth doing.
3) Nice terrain, no flat areas.
4) Nice rescue building.
5) No glitching/bugs.

---CONS---
1) Terrible bots. They're probably the worst bots I've ever played with and that takes A LOT out of a map. If you're playing this on multiplayer, then you're alright, but don't expect a fun solo gameplay with bots in this campaign. Absolutely terrible. Bad movements, when I get attacked by a special they just stand next to me and do nothing. I've seen this problem as a part of other reviews as well, so I guess it's not just me.
2) The lack of supplies in the safe rooms can add to the challenge but again, not when you're playing alone, bad move.
3) And after all the bot frustration, the helicopter comes and you have a tank coming in front of it, blocking your road to freedom. I know that could be random, but that's bad design right there.
4) No radio sounds.

Final Grade: C+. This has so much potential, but the execution is mediocre. The bot part is what hurts this map a lot, but you also can't ignore the lack of supplies in the first 2 maps. The design and overall aesthetic is incredible, but that's pretty much it. The rescue map is the easiest of all 4, but you need a bit of luck when the rescue helicopter arrives, ESPECIALLY on harder difficulties.

Exceptional

--PROS--
-Intro.
-Great environments.
-The creator cared about the details and that's a big deal.
-The story was good.
-Great bot navigation and play overall.
-Long campaign.
-Majestic rescue environment!
-Nice visual effect when rescue fight begins.
-Good weapon/item/ammo balance.
-Great rescue scene.

                  --CONS--
-Some standard tank spawn points would make it extremely hard, even impossible to complete on expert.
-What was the ending about? Didn't get that...

Poorly Made

-- PROS --
-Some visuals were nice.

        -- CONS--
-Poorly designed levels.
-Low level of detail.
-Many signs of copy-paste on design on a single level. Nothing different.
-A LOT of bugs!
-Invisible items?
-Poor AI navigation.
-Didn't keep me interested.

Overall a below the average campaign. Not well made, lots of bugs, nothing to keep the player interested. (And I see that's V3.0 final? Not even close...)

Great campaign

PROS
A great, educational campaign about witch killing.
Definitely learned a lot!
A very well-made campaign.
The first time I had a jumpscare!
Great animations, great little story.

CONS
You must watch the long cutscene if you die on the first one.
I was lucky to have the bots covering me while I was shooting the cores, although I think that other people won't have the same luck.


Overall, an exceptional campaign, very informative and had lots of fun! Really enjoyed playing.
Recommended!