Pros:

- Comic "sound effects" were a nice touch

- Nice length to the maps

- Solid events

- good amount of ammo all the way through

- Surprise ending

Cons:

- Some special effect mistakes (boomer trying to open an door blocked with boxes on 3rd map that can't be opened so was easy to kill, and charge trying to charge through some stairs in front of one cabin).

- Bots loved standing in front of turret in the finale.

- Too many healthkits, maybe switch a few with throwables since I didn't find many of those.

Conclusion:

A fun map with great atmosphere. had a lot of fun with this one and the "sound effect" that appear when you hit the alarm cars made it really hard to get past the level full of them, I wanted to shoot them all so badly. Very fun campaign and would play it again.

Pros:

- Makes Nick look like a BOSS!

- Works nicely

Cons:

- Non

Conclusion:

Nick in a brand new suit, it is a same to have to track through Swamp Fever with this sweet suit on.

Pros:

- Nice skin for bill that fits his character

- Looks great

Cons:

- Nope, nothing here

Conclusion:

Good skin, definitely gonna use this for a while.

Pros:

- It looks Great

- I could definitely see Francis steal a cop uniform just in case

Cons:

- I would try to figure out a con for this mod, but then Francis would arrest me for lying

Conclusion:

Great skin for Francis, though sadly he had one more day till retirement before that charger...

Pros:

- Nice detail

- It works nicely

- Hey, Coach finally has that body armor he always wanted

Cons:

It says "Police" on the back instead of "SWAT" if you wanna be picky...

Conclusion:

Great skin for Coach, now if I could only remove his line about body armor since he is now set.

Pros:

- Love the shirt choice

- Camo on ellis? Fits him well

- Tattoos look nice

Cons:

- Con? We don't like Cons in this mod. It is great.

Conclusion:

My new Ellis skin, nice job.

Pros:

- The quality of work improves throughout the maps

- Nice length

- Good amount of supplies for the size of the map

Cons:

- some textures on the first map could use some work (the pavement to grass with mountain over both of them look odd)

- Nav issues, esp on the first map (had a spitter get stuck in a mountain)

- Large empty feeling spots (The event hanger, after you start the event all you need to do it go forward, skipping pretty much all of the hanger, give em a little detour to make use of your whole map)

- Second map had some direction issues in certain parts, lack of arrows or direction lights.

- Could not finish the finale, after reaching the plane the bots would not enter. After killing the bots and entering the plane it would not allow me to escape.

Conclusion:

Score would by far be higher if the finale could be finished. A map not working and not being able to be completed is one of the worst things that could happen. Otherwise nice work, keep it up and keep getting better.

Pros:

- Atmosphere is insane

- So much detail in everything

- Custom zombies

- Good amount of challenge

- Never got lost even though it was a very complex looking map

The finale rush was amazing, I am almost speechless of how awesome that was.

Cons:

- First run through and my group lost the lamb leg, so really that is a con for us

Conclusion:

I cannot describe how much fun we had in this map. When that baby started crying and we began leaving that cathedral you could tell this would be interesting. This map never disappointed us at any point. So from the creepy beginning to the end were someone tried to be a hero but got charged to his death, this map was 100% fun.

Pros:

Amazing looks

Bright red color looks great

Cons:

The....neck belt?...looks a bit square in certain parts....I guess...

Conclusion:

With so many Zoey skins out there this one really stands out among the rest. Great work!

Pros:

Love the whole uniform and nametag is great

The dirt adds a nice touch

Cons:

S-mart does not exist in l4d universe, then again this Con is more for Valve ;D

Conclusion:

Wonderful skin for Louis. I will be using this one for quite some time.

Pros:

Long maps without being repetitive

Challenging map

Good events

From maps 3-5 it had the right amount of items

Good amount of witches without being too crazy with them

GNOMES!!! Everything is better with Gnomes!

Cons:

Lack of supplies and ammo in the first two maps

Lack of directions (little more arrows or lights shining in directions would be nice)

Doors that need a melee to break open, they are more of an annoyance then an interesting mechanic

Bit of problem with special infected trying to attack through walls (got a good laugh though)

Except for the boat whistle, no clear sigh of where to go for the rescue vehicle

No end credits

Conclusion:

Had a lot of fun with this map. Plenty of action and tough moments to keep you entertained. The length with the various locals kept the map interesting for the whole ride.

My group did have a few problems in certain areas with directions of where to go, and if I didn't hear the boat noise we would of stayed where we were looking for a copter. The first maps could also at least use one mid-point ammo pile, especially giving you had those on maps 3-5 to certain degrees. Of course would also love to see my kill totals at the end but the credits never came.

Overall I would play this map again since I had a blast. Good work you did their.

Pros:

Decent size
No shortage of zombies
Plenty of supplies to have fun with

Cons:

Bland textures
Bland map design
Overly long and Bland finale run

Conclusion:

The whole of the map looked very bland and the texture choice like with the grass for the first map and the hills in the finale were overall boring. Except for a few things in the city it seemed like no one lived in it before the zombies took over anyway.

The map works, just was a overall boring feel and was not much fun.

Pros:

Great looking map
maps 1 and 2 were exciting
Falling objects were nice though not unfair

Cons:

Finale was WAY too easy and anti-climatic

Conclusion:

A great map, with a sub-par finale (worked alright, but not even the bots got hurt in it). All the models during the map looked wonderful for the theme and overall was a fun map. My favorite part was when the other guy I was playing with almost got crushed by a falling truck. Just fix the Finale and this map would be perfect.

Pros:

Nice long maps
Great look
nice atmosphere

Cons:

Nav issues
loads of repeating texture

Conclusion:

A nice map with a nice china feel to it for the contest. A few issues with Nav but nothing too bad that can't be fixed. The textures are nice but you see the same texture a lot throughout the campaign. Also their is one empty spot between the path and the wall in the second map after the first buildings where someone can get stuck (got stuck their because of a tank hit). Could easily add water there and make it a kill spot instead since it is annoying to get stuck down there. Other then that had a good amount of fun on this map.

Pros:

Difficulty is nice
Gnome powers
lots of witches and hordes
nice size

Cons:

No finale
Getting the gnome to work can be buggy at times
not as many secret spots as you would think for a map with powerups

Conclusion:

The biggest problem is the finale. A campaign without one seems like less of a campaign. Also the gnome was a nice fun addition but sometimes he would not work after a bit in the map. Overall my group did have fun on this map, during the battle with 2 tanks we did not notice the second one till after the first one was already in the building with us, a great surprise and made us run off in a panic to kill em.

Pros:

Great map with a l4d feel
Not too difficult but it is not a cake walk either
Solid amount of distance you need to travel
Plenty of hidden areas to check out
Great finale
Foam Fingers and Football Tanks

Cons:

No obvious ones

Conclusion:

A great map. When playing it had so many good moments, from the early beginning going through the apartment, to watching my 3 teammates get incapped by one lucky tank hitting a car. Had so much fun with the finale. Everyone that played with me agreed it was great and saw nothing bad.

Pros:

Lots of different challenges
Different mechanics for each stage
a great last level final exam
great way to choose what you get with the gas

Cons:

none

Conclusion:

This has to be one of my favorite maps. A fun insane map without going too overboard with the difficulty. We truly need more maps in the spirit of this one.

Pros:

Clean looking campaign
A good l4d feel
Nice areas to explore

Cons:

Finale on the very easy side
Slightly too much supplies

Conclusion:

A great campaign up till the finale. If the finale had more movement around the area involved this campaign would be great, as it is now it is only great with a ok ending.