Pros:

Fun (in the name of science)
good ideas (in the name of science)
addicting (in the name of science)

Cons:

Far too hard alone
unsatisfying ending
bots die (in the name of science)

Conclusion:

after trying for about an hour to pass this alone, i gave up and started a game from the dev console with godmode. I must say, the ending was unsatisfying for all that trouble. You definately had some good ideas going here, but the fact that the bots cant pick up weapons or heal themselves or look after themselves makes this far too difficult too attempt alone perhaps add some basic supplies to spawn at the beginning at least? I liked unlocking stuff but in the end, and the barriers where fun, but it was too hard not to focus on the rocket. I'm sure if I had some friends who werent addon challenged (they still cant igure it out xD) Id enjoy this alot more.

Pros:

None

Cons:

poorly done 5 minute job

Conclusion:

You Literally just took part of the texture from the red teams bonk! atomic punch can and pasted it onto the bat textures, and then you covered the rough edges with pure red and yellow. this needs almost no effort;  could whip something like this up in five minutes.

And it dosent even look good ingame. the text is all stretched out. I've seen some of your other mods, you can do alot better than this.

Pros:

relatively glitchless
bots arent too dumb
train level was pretty cool

Cons:

finale was too quick and easy
too short
very bland and unoriginal
repetitive and got boring quick
too many witches
too many first aid kits, not enough ammo

Conclusion:

Overall, i didn't like this campaign. the crescendos where mostly unoriginal and recycled, the finale was boring and simple, and scenery was terribly repetitive. the train was kinda cool but it was a bit buggy. I also didn't fancy the saferooms too much, the truck ones didnt really feel like vehicles, more like a box that magically teleports. overall i see no reason to replay this map; i could get the same stuff from one of valves maps. custom campaigns where made for ingenuity, creativity, and to make something different from what you've already seen; This map just feels like a recycle of death toll. 

Pros:

First half has very beautiful textures
Very creative, I liked the shipping crate box saferoom :D
generous item spawning
lenghtly, but not to a ridiculous point
quite fun with nice scenery
custom campaign poster looks cool
looks of places to explore without getting lost

Cons:

It looks like you got a bit lazy with the textures at the second half. they're very low res
a bit of lag at very few parts
some parts a bit difficult to navigate
why couldn't they just climb into the well -.-

Conclusion:

Well done campaign, looks very nice and is one of my favorites. aside from a few very minor cons, This campaign is very satisfying. there is no reason why you shouldn't be hitting that download button right now :D also I can't stretch enough how much i enjoyed the creativity put into this. uncommon infected, wonderful scenery, the part where you can choose to go up the elevator or stairs, rigging the well with explosives, swimming through the sewers, shooting the propane(?) truck, the saferoom loaded with guns, I loved it all. definitely one of the best campaigns I've played in a long time.

p.s that multistory hotel (or whatever that building was before the church) in the final chapter reminded of the final chapter of gears of war 3 :D

Pros:

Interesting look
many options for exploration
well thought out events and use of materials(e.g M60 in         item crate)
beatiful finale
custom survivor textures (albeit, low res)

Cons:

textures lacked detail
hard to find your way around in the first map
invisible fire in the first map
severe lag when playing on high graphic settings
obviously unfinished areas that you can see, with a kill barrier as a cheap solution to keep you from escaping
Invisible tanks (although not sure if that was another campaign conflicting)
too short

Conclusion:

Overall, this map feels incomplete. It needs major tweaking. I think that this was a good idea overall but needs alot of fixes. this feels more like a beta than the real thing