Pros:

Very fun
Low gravity
Water = beautiful
Interesting architecture
Building

Cons:

Practically impossible to beat w/o cheats
Horde never stops after a while?
Too long to build

Conclusion:

VERY good map, just make it easier to beat. Would rate higher if these issues are fixed.

Pros:

Definite improvement over the SPAS-12
Appeals to bronies such as myself
Even the shells are colored :3

Cons:

No new animations

Conclusion:

Very nice, any brony fan would enjoy this.

Pros:

Great looking
new animation is smooth
Black finish = better

Cons:

Blocky looking (go back to COD2)
Animation seems a teeny bit slower
Flashlight looks... out of place

Conclusion:

Very good, just improve the blocky-ness