Pros:

+ Originality of voice acting
+ A variety of new "scenes" such as:
        The Bombing of the Runway
        The Monorail Track
+ Picturesque Landscape
+ A simplistic story line that is understandable
+ Creative level space (especially the accent to the chopper in Map 5)
+ 3D text that shows you what to do next.

Cons:

- Some minor navigational issues with the infected in Map 2 and Map 5, but these are hardly noticeable (-0.0)
- Despite the creative level space, I felt most areas were lacking detail. I'm one for realism and I felt as if most, if not all the rooms could have more decals/overlays, greater lighting effects, and not so repetitive model placement. (-1.2)
- In the finalle, the bots can die VERY easily. After playing twice by myself I could only save myself, and with my friend we could only save ourselves no matter how hard we tried to save them. (-0.4)
- While some panic events were exciting, most lacked reasoning (i.e. no explosions had gone off/doors had not been opened) which confused me slightly. (-0.3)
- Tank spawns could be hugely improved, as they could be taken out within seconds without laying a finger on the survivors. (-0.2)

Conclusion:

Potential. That's the key word here. This map could be up there with several other famous custom campaigns if updated and strenuously worked on. The idea is fantastic. The execution is good, but the result could be better. The voice acting was enthusiastic at some moments, but dull at others. I suggest overlooking some of those lines. All in all, I would love to see this reworked and turned into a master campaign with the likes of I Hate Mountains 3, Urban Flight or Vienna Calling 2!

Pros:

- Dead Center looks fantastic with the off-center spot light and ironic blood slash across the Poster
- Slightly differing light colors just like at a carnival, and the background details are just fantastic and look better than Valve's version.
- The sickly green color reflects the flu-stricken, dirty environment, as well as the darker lighting to reflect the early hours of the morning.
- I really like the bloom and ragged details of this poster. It's dripping, ripped, and again the little details of the running paint and grimy walls are just perfect.

Cons:

- Although the lighting is perfect I feel that the background lacks the detail and complexity of the other posters, and being my second favorite campaign I'm sorry to have to mark down this near-perfect pack. (-0.8)

Conclusion:

Brilliant. You sir have outdone yourself with this mod, and I applaud you for it! What if I'm not satisfied with The Parish? The other four make up for the way you have mirrored the campaigns in their design and the professional level in which you have executed them. Would you consider creating improved posters for The Sacrifice, The Parish, and more importantly the L4D1 Campaigns?

Pros:

- Fantastic concept, looks like our little friend has broken out of an asylum!
- Small details such as the scar on his leg and blacked out (or missing!) eye work really well with the deranged theme.

Cons:

- Shame about your normal maps, but I may have a solution for you to improve the lighting on the normal map (-0.2)
- Works well with only the Sacrifice, but this was intended so hardly any harm done there. (-0.1)
- I'm a bit of a blood freak, and a touch more blood would have been perfect (-0.1)

Conclusion:

I really like this skin! The concept is fantastic as I stated before, and it is executed near perfectly. For the lighting problem, do you find that when you test out the Jockey he is overly shiny/plastic looking? If so, make sure you save his normal map as a '.tga' with 'Alpha' enabled. But considering the professional quality of these re-skins you probably are aware of that! :P

Pros:

- Fantastic alternative to the original music.
- Each composition suits the action (e.g. Charger's music is pounding, Boomer's music is strained and disorienting)

Cons:

- A little too quiet perhaps? But I will hardly deduct any points for that seeing as you have acknowledged it (-0.1)

Conclusion:

I am all about immersing myself in the L4D world, and one thing that for me was a big issue was the music. I usually turn the game music to mute because I find it distracts and can ruin the scary world that surrounds us. What you have done here is bring back the tension and suspense for the SI with horror and finesse, and I thank-you greatly for that! Huge recommendation to anyone who comes across this. Any chance that you would take a look into altering the horde music to be either more cinematic, or scarier?