Pros:

Its Alyx! +4
looks great +3
looks like she came straight out of the game +3

Cons:

no fps arms -0.5
no avatar -0.5
rochelles voice  -0
rochelles name is still there -0.5

Conclusion:

Overall Alyx looks great. Although she has no fps arms, avatar and has rochelles voice & name it is still a good replacement skin if you like half-life 2.

7.5/10

Pros:

looks great! +2
good model  +2
great textures +2
animations are good +2
flashlight & laser sight fixed +2

Cons:

sounds weird -1
laser sight still looks weird -0.5
grip (cant fix)

Conclusion:

Overall good weapon, despite sound and laser. 

8.5/10