Pros:

-Great LOTR music !
-Nice events, great scripting skills
-Helpful L4D1 survivors
-Not laggy
-Good item placement
-I love LOTR!!!

Cons:

-Infected dont know hot to run on the tower stairs, so they climbing slow :) but its easier to defent in it.

Conclusion:

I made longer than 1 hour in this map , inside castle, it was impossible to loose.... we stand 4 all together and defended doors. Two tanks came every few mins and we killed them easyly. Love this map ! Some dedicated servers already has it, and a lot of people has it, so you always find a mates to play online. Love this map !!! Must have !

Pros:

-Nice custom textures
-Very nice village, great architecture
-Nice cliffs
-Cool helicopter event at 5:30 and L4D1 survivors
-Good item placement
-Good triggers
-Fun to play
-Really big work and time dedicated for this map

Cons:

-Maybe a little bit big (almost fits a half campaign hehe)
-A little bit hard to understand a starting button, need to read info text. Starting button is a flares dropped on the ground. Press "E" and hold to start.
-Maybe a little darky :)

Conclusion:

Dont know many bugs. I enjoyed playing this. Waiting for more maps from you Lemmy. You could make this theme in campaign mode. Nice use of triggers. Good map !

Pros:

-Great remake of HL2 map
-Like storm and fire event
-Like panic events
-Music is great
-Navs are ok
-Like evacuation train
-Like HL outside suroundings, love it
-Images for all campaing

Cons:

-Some weapons placed not realistic (I mean flying in the air, also I always like when they are placed by the dead soldiers, ammo trucks, some boxes...)
-A little bit easy
-Tanks were easy
-Nav error at the 1st level beginning, smoker almost killed me before bots could help me.
-When storm came, some road tiles were very bright

Conclusion:

I loved to play this campaing. I felt like in real apokalypse. This HL2 campaign really fits for L4D. I like such a campaigns, maps which are outside, cities. Nice idea to destroy barricade on the street, but dont know how it can call horde in real life :) .I cannot rate it with a maximum points, because it's just a remake of other games campaing, but you did well, it took time, i enjoyed it, and like I see - others too. City17 fits for L4D !