Pros:

+ Great atmosphere
+ Better challenge
+ New paths are fun to explore
+ Finale had superb silhouetting.

Cons:

- On occasion areas will be too dark (minor issue)
- Tier two weapons only spawned after level 3 (possible Director issue)

Conclusion:

One of the biggest problems with any map, be it official or custom, is immersion. The competent level design of the Valve employees combined with the creepy feel of New Orleans at night makes for a great experience. Combined with realism mods such as lowered ammo and increased damage, this makes for a fun hour long play through on Advanced. Highly recommended!

Pros:

+ More realistic
+ The M16A2 is perfect

Cons:

- The SCAR model often switches to the M16A2 model
- There are sound glitches for all the SCAR audio clips
- With the SCAR, first person hands often disappear

Conclusion:

I hope for an updated version with fixed sound and graphical glitches!

Pros:

+ Scary!
+ Really good lost in the woods feel

Cons:

- Not recommended for realism unless you're really hardcore

Conclusion:

I really enjoyed this, and it's great fun with friends. Maybe the same thing but in a sprawling metropolis next time? :D