Pros:

Bright
Perfect blend of blue tint

Cons:

Zombies aren't blinded by the light

Conclusion:

I used to use the HID Flashlight and I loved it because it was super bright but the blue tint on the edge was always too much for me. This light mod is the perfect blend of the blue tint (barely there) and bright light. It works great!

Pros:

Every level is dark
Fps is the same as the normal campaign
The lighting makes the world look so mystical
My favorite campaign just got 10 times better
For the first time I saw the "different" pathing actually take effect besides in the first map.
Found 2 kits for laser sights

Cons:

Either the director hates me or there were hardly any supplies

Conclusion:

Every time I play The Parish there are certain areas that always have ammo or guns but this was not the case for this map. It really forced me to use my melee weapon more which was ok. I love the lighting in this map. Its really immersive and creepy. Gives me that feeling of when I played No Mercy for the first time.

Please look over the supplies issue and see if it can be sorted out. I would love to give this a 100/100 after the supplies are fixed.

Pros:

Looks cool
Shows the l4d team what they should have done with the loading bar

Cons:

Doesn't make the game load any faster

Conclusion:

Such a simple mod but it works!

Pros:

Dead Island Epic song in L4D2!
Song sounds unchanged

Cons:

Makes me want to sit in L4D2 menu all day

Conclusion:

I like this mod. Its a bit quiet in the beginning that you can barely hear it but that's ok because its how the song plays out. About 30 seconds in it gets louder.

Pros:

These things are massive and make me use pistols more
Very detailed

Cons:

Weapon spawns for this gun dont lay flat
Pistol is invisible in holsters when you look at your teammates
Ellis's hand doesn't fully fit the pistol

Conclusion:

I was expecting a different sound for the pistol shot but I will just find/make my own.

Pros:

Adds detail to the bland pills casing
Adds some realism to what the pills are

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

I barely notice this mod until I pick up pills.

Pros:

High quality texture
I could believe that this really is a medkit

Cons:

the "+" sign is quite small

Conclusion:

Great work on this!

Pros:

Really detailed

Cons:

Harder to spot than the normal orange colored defib

Conclusion:

I like realistic skin mods thus why I downloaded this. It is a bit harder to spot but the detail makes up for that.

Pros:

Easy to spot bile since it "glows"
Helps me see where my teammates are in dark places if they picked up bile

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

It would be pretty cool if the green mist the bile bomb explodes into was the same color but I think that's a valve limitation. Great work!

Pros:

Desert rifle looks a lot better than default

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

I like mods that change up the weapon skins to look realistic and this one does just that.

Pros:

Makes the pipebomb look better

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

The blinking light is tacky but a good addition! I barely notice I have this mod enabled until I pull out a pipebomb.

Pros:

Close quarters makes melee weapons a must
Easy to navigate map due to red flares
Decent variety of weapons
Good spots for ammo piles
Plenty of throwables
Scavenge finale was very fun and close quarters
Dark where it needs to be otherwise there is plenty bright lights

Cons:

Strange Tree shadows in all of the water.
Low fps throughout the campaign
Parking garage was confusing
Elevator had a huge push area
Top of parking garage things would render in as I walked (valve problem so no mark down for it)
Needs some more melee weapons
Vibrant red was distracting
Map 3 saferoom missing medkits, ammo, and guns (intended?)

Conclusion:

This was a really great map. I played on my server but no one joined but I still finished it on normal no retries. I had previously commented that the campaign was too dark which the dev fixed with brighter lighting. Some of the lights seemed a bit too bright and distracting but the flares were just right. In the parking garage I got lost and went to the very top only to find that wasn't the right way to go. I think it could use a little more variety of weapons and more melee weapons because there are so many zombies. Map 3 saferoom didn't have any medkits, ammo or guns though I am not sure if this was intended.

Overall I had a lot of fun in this map. The detail and placement of props was fantastic. Once this campaign is optimized some more is should be a really good one. 88/100

Pros:

Plenty of guns and ammo piles
Unique vehicle events
Record player at the boat event
"Hero" part was fun
You get to choose your path in some areas

Cons:

While riding the vehicles there is visual stutter which make it hard to play
Some ground textures were really low resolution (I run all settings high)
Finale needs a little more optimization as my fps dropped down to 30 when avg is 90+

Conclusion:

I edited my review since everyone had to jump on me for being honest. I will tried to go a bit more in-depth for the mapper so he can sort out these issues.

Truck ride was fun but the stutter made it hard to use the miniguns or your own hand guns accurately. I had the same issue with the boat though it wasn't as bad because the boat was slow. Also at the skylift why does it push everyone to one side?

The vehicle riding parts are unique they stutter really badly. Ping didn't help. With 80ms+ its almost unplayable and even when I played in SP I still had stutter issues. This may be a problem with source engine but unfortunately affects the overall score of this campaign.

I think with a bit more optimization and polish this will be a really good campaign. When a new update comes out I hope to rate this 85+

Pros:

- Lighting leads the way
- Plenty of pipe bombs and molotovs
- Very Fun campaign
- Used the finale rescue from Blood Harvest
- Cresendo in map 4 was awesome

Cons:

- Finale vehicle ran over 2 bots and killed them. Louis and I were glitched in the front.
- Map 4 sewer system was a bit confusing
- Finale rescue camera glitches through the rooftops
- Map 3 needs a few more ammo spawns

Conclusion:

Well done campaign. I enjoyed this quite a bit.

@lousaffire Even if the name is claimed I hope that doesn't stop you from making a campaign. Check this one out maybe you can get some ideas from it.