Pros:

OK, I'm typing this while I'm playing! Let's do this!

--[ALL MAPS]-- (+9)
1) Great map design layout, didn't get lost easily
2) Great custom GUI/HUD!
3) Interesting lighting effects
4) Pretty solid NAV
5) Creepy atmospheric mood
------------------

--[MAP 1]-- (+0.1)
1) Interesting find-the-items concept
--------------

--[MAP 3]-- (+0.1)
1) Great skybox!
2) Very nice sewer layout + Hidden room!
--------------

--[MAP 4]-- (+0.5)
1) Don't understand why people are disappointed with the finale, I thought it was great
--------------

TOTAL: 9.7

Cons:

--[ALL MAPS/OTHER]-- (-0)
a) Maybe it's just me, but weird water reflectance?
------------------

--[MAP 1]-- (-0.1)
a) Some of the long sentences cut off my screen, making me unable to read it
b) Saferoom to Map 2 has items floats in midair 
--------------

--[MAP 2]-- (-0.1)
a) Framerate drop if looking at a very busy-packed area (wasn't that terrible though, probably just dropped 7 FPS)
--------------

--[MAP 3]-- (-2)
a) Strange transition from Saferoom 2 to 3? (Why are we in that area in the first place? I'm starting to wonder if we got into the helicopter then crashed, which led us to be in that saferoom?)
b) Once in the sewers, BIG FRAMERATE DROP! (about 60 FPS - 25 FPS)
c) Saferoom to map 4 DID NOT WORK (no zombies were inside, thus we had to "improperly" switch to the next map)
--------------

--[MAP 4]-- (-0.2)
a) Weird saferoom transition again
b) Only about one weapon (the AK) for the whole finale, couldn't find any other varieties
--------------

FINAL: 7.3

Conclusion:

Been waiting for this campaign for over a year now, thought it had been abandoned. Though, now that I've gotten to experience it, I am happy to review it to make it better (if possible).

However, I believe this campaign is still a bit far from actual "completion". There are still many bugs and thinking to do (especially the weird saferoom transitions). I don't know about the other people but, the saferoom in map 3 to map 4 did not work for me, I even NO-CLIPED to see if there was any remaining zombies in the room. Nope. Didn't find any. So that heavily lowered your score.

I hope you can take our critics and improve upon them for the next update(s)! I will be looking forward to your improvements.

Pros:

1. Eye moves! (+3)
2. Tekken character (+1)
3. Nice FPS arms (+2)
4. Name Change + Jiggle Bones (+1)
5. High quality model (+3)

TOTAL: 10

Cons:

a) I don't see anyone complaining about this yet, but here it is: Specific melee weapons in Third Person mode (mostly two-handed melee wep), instead of holding it in her hands, the melee weapons seems to be located between her legs (ahem, i'm not going to get into details) (-0.7)

FINAL: 9.3

Conclusion:

I wanted to wait a bit before making a full-fledge review. So, here it is (after playing with it since release)

Overall, this mod is very good and is one of the main reasons I continued playing L4D2 again. However, if you fix the third person melee weapon bug, this mod is a WIN-WIN situation for everything and can easily beat any other mods out there (will and would had been a perfect 10 if that was the case). Though, not a biggie (considering that most people here play in FPS). I've tested with other skins, and this is probably the only skin mod I had with the melee issue.