Pros:

IT's ROBOCOP!
Looks great in game.
No errors with the model holding weapons.

Cons:

No sound pack. -1

Conclusion:

It is a cool model replacement. Kinda makes me want to design and Old Detroit map to make it fit in more. Great job overall. Just needs a sound pack to make it awesomesauce!

Pros:

Great Look
Great sounds
Animations very smooth

Cons:

The ADS is not toggle-able. 
It's in the scar slot.

Conclusion:

Overall best M16a2 mod for l4d2. A different but cool way to kill zombies.Should replace the m16 and not the scar, just my personal opinion.

Pros:

Great environments/ Environment changes.
Limited use of director hints, use light and environment instead.
Good use of wide open maps.

Cons:

Some brushes/ displacements dont line up right, you can see out of the world at some spots.

Conclusion:

Overall great maps, alot of places seem like the stock maps and panics, but nothing else bad to say.

Pros:

Great fit into the game
Looks great

Cons:

Looks funny when she elbows me to death

Conclusion:

Good job overall. I understand why she dont kill me with her hands but had to be said as it was the only con.

Pros:

One of the first and the best.
Inspired me to map way back when it first released.
Step up on difficulty.
Greater distance to travel yet still linear.

Cons:

When playing single, the bots cant hang.

Conclusion:

The difficulty may drive some people away, but i feel that custom mapping is about doing something thats not the same as the stock maps. Weather its more challenging or a new environment, it brings something different to the game, thus enhancing the possibilities.

Pros:

Creative
Original
Nastalgic
Just like being on the ride at Disneyland

Cons:

Very minor issues

Conclusion:

Hands down one of the coolest campaigns for l4d2. Shows skill and a butload of patience. Great job man!

Pros:

Level design is smooth and seems to be optimized well as i was getting 100+ FPS.
Tons of options for hold out.
Lots of eye candy for those who are familiar with Jedi Knights, and for those that are not.
Lots of paths for infected to spawn from making it a new challenge each time.

Cons:

No clues or identifiers for the survivors to know where to go to start it up.
Radio could use a glow to indicated the start of the event.
Maybe a director hint to indicate where the team needs to go to start it up.

Conclusion:

The pros were to many to list, making the cons very miniscule and easy to not even think about.
The layout is awesome as i am a fan of the JK series.
The unpredictibility of the infected flow makes it a must play and a constantly visited survival.
Add a scavenge to it and you have the makings of a top 5 map. Great job dude, look forward to what else you bring to the community.
On a side note, id love to do some work with you, your creativity is much like mine!
5 star map!!!!