Pros:

Very fun 
Challenging 
Custom weapons
It's Helms Deep babee !
I'm a huge fan of LOTR 

Cons:

HOW DARE YOU TOOK OUT THE MUSIC !!??  
- 2.5 for this ! Booooooo !

Conclusion:

Honestly I don't like the changes u put on this version ! 17b was fine . Why u remove the Music !? No music = less fun .

Pros:

It's Legion mota!@#$a !
Great atmosphere
Building features are nice

Cons:

The Tanks whoop my ass everytimes . with a small space I can't run nowhere

Conclusion:

Overall it's a cool map ! good details ( feel like real life ) . I prefer the roof top , it's easy to defence . For the Legion fans ! definitely should try this out . And i would love to see a daylight version of this map , It would be so cool

Pros:

- Very Interesting story
- L4D2 survivors play along with the story , and TF2 doctor
- Great effects weather ! especially foggy !
- dialog is cool 
- And it's long ( dunno if this a pro )

Cons:

Long campaign might be ?
for me is none

Conclusion:

Very interesting map ! The Author must be  put a lots of effort ! Good job