Pros:

+Great textures!
+Beautiful, really makes the environment of l4d2 look more realistic in my opinion.
+Lights up making the map more fun to play in.
+Managed to fix that Dark Carnival glitch now. Looks great!
+Looks like now there is one for every official campaign. Nice!

Cons:

-Really the only thing I can say about this is the Hard Rain skybox. In the first two maps there should be a lot more clouds considering it is about to rain down really hard. Same with the last three, there are more clouds, but it seems way too bright to be in a huge thunder storm. (-0.3) 

Conclusion:

Beautiful. This has got to be the greatest skybox mod so far. Absolutely love it! Maybe work on the Hard Rain one a bit more if you ask me.

Pros:

+Great Model!
+Love the textures.
+Scope looks great

Cons:

-Some pretty obvious clipping with both the first person and third person hands. (-1.5)
-Sounds really are not good. (-1)
-Clipping in the reload animation as well. (-0.5)
-Flashlight goes way out of the way when reloading. But that is mostly the animation's fault. (-0.1)

Conclusion:

The animation and sound is what really brought this weapon down. Maybe try a remake with arby's older hunting rifle animation or better yet, add a whole new one. I know how to remove a sound off of a weapon but still, it hurts other people who don't. Hoping this gets updated soon.

Pros:

+Um I guess I give you props for fulfilling someone's request.

Cons:

-It
Makes
Me
Want
To
Shoot
Him (-0)
-Looks NOTHING like him...(-8.9)

Conclusion:

Not only does it make me want to keep killing him and NEVER let him live just knowing that it is supposed to be Justin Bieber, it does not look like Justin at all. I'm sorry I can not put any higher score on this.

Pros:

+Makes Louis and Francis look a lot more professional.
+Fixes the clipping between Louis and Francis' arms and the rifle.

Cons:

-Makes a little less variety. I think this is why Valve made the two separate weird animations for rifles that way Louis, Francis, and Bill wouldn't all have the same animation. I'm not complaining too much about that though because I don't really care about variation TOO drastically much. (-0.2)

Conclusion:

I love this! I have been waiting for someone to do something like this for a long time. Now all we need is for Coach's pistol bug to be fixed and maybe a new animation for the military sniper rifle in third person (if that's possible.) Good work!

Pros:

+Great model!
+Textures look good.
+High resolution scope.
+Animation fits surprisingly well.

Cons:

-Some clipping in the l4d1 survivor hands when reloading but not too big of a deal. (-0.1)
-Biggest thing I have to say about this is the bad melee animation in first person. Doesn't really look like much but that isn't your fault. (-0)

Conclusion:

By far the best scout sniper mods I have seen! Keep up the really good work!

Pros:

+Uses the beta outfit for Zoey which makes her look SO much better.

Cons:

-Makes her look a little overweight if you ask me. (-0.2)
-First person hands are a little weird looking (-0.5)
-As you mentioned the eye and hair problem but since it was mentioned I won't take off for it. (-0)

Conclusion:

Love it! Biggest thing for me is the fact of how bigger she looked with the beta outfit than with the default one.

Pros:

+Good animation.
+Been looking for something like this.

Cons:

-I feel it would be better if this was a regular pistol replacement. Magnum doesn't seem to fit right with this in my opinion. (-1)
-Animation isn't very original. Been used in about 100 other mods but it is a good animation so nothing wrong with that. (-0)
-Hands seem to bug out for me when moving. (-0.5)
-Texture is way to shiny for the classic Tokarev. (-0.5)

Conclusion:

In most cases, good mod. If you could make it replace the pistols, it would be better.

Pros:

+Cool looking monster
+Horrifying to the point where it actually makes the game feel a little more like "survival horror"
+Love the face
+Great model

Cons:

-Low res textures at some points (-0.5)
-I feel like something like this should have a custom sound because the default charger sound just doesn't fit in my opinion (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Probably by far one of the best charger models I have seen! Textures could use some updating though and see if you can find a more fitting sound for it.

Pros:

+Replaces the AWP (Bit of a pro and con so I put in both)
+High resolution scope

Cons:

-Replaces the AWP (Bit of a pro and a con so I put in both see conclusion) (-2)
-Textures are a little too smooth. (-0.5)
-Only works in modded servers and cheat servers but even then it has no damage. (-1)

Conclusion:

Well let me explain why replacing the AWP is both a pro and con. One is obviously the fact it doesn't work on a lot of servers. Second is with the way L4D2 has it, it pretty much just looks like a grenade launcher with a scope on it. Enough said.

Pros:

+Cool looking mask
+Good idea

Cons:

-Sadly when I tested it Zoey's voice is almost completely inaudible when you're not playing as her which can actually be really bad in certain situations. (-4)
-Third person hands are way off almost every gun. (-1)
-Textures look too plain. (-1)

Conclusion:

Eh I wouldn't use it but I guess I can see why others would...

Pros:

+Textures are great
+Realistic looking ammo inside the bag

Cons:

-In my opinion, ripped models are not as good as custom made models. Makes me feel like not enough effort was put into it. (-1)
-The bag itself is not really realistic unless the survivors were to carry it themselves if you ask me.  (-1)

Conclusion:

Overall it's pretty good but not perfect.

Pros:

+Cool textures for the most part.
+Seems more realistic apart from the flashlight.

Cons:

-Never really liked arby's ak-47 reanimation makes the hand look really weird when reloading and firing. (-1.5)
-What on earth is going on with that flashlight? Why is it red when everything else is black? Makes it look really out of place from the rest of the gun. (-1.5)
-Hand clips into the gun in third person and clips into the mag in first person when reloading. (-1)

Conclusion:

Eh not really a fan of this. I think it is the animation that is really making it look bad. Also the flashlight bugs me. I think I would have preferred to see no flashlight at all compared to a red one on a black gun...

Pros:

+Good idea.
+Nice textures.

Cons:

-Animations are moving around way to much when moving. (-1.5)
-Not a fan of fast shooting animations. (-1)
-Don't like the fact that you use two different pistols. (-1)
-Sounds aren't that great in my opinion. (-1)

Conclusion:

I don't know I think it is mostly the animations which make this mod look bad in my opinion. Could use with a different animation and some sound improvements

Pros:

+Great quality
+Tattoos are cool looking
+Folds on the shirt add realism
+Hair looks good
+Handsome devil from Far Cry :)

Cons:

-For some reason I'm missing a couple eye textures (-0.3) 
-Looks a little too skinny than in Far Cry. That may just be me though (-0.1)
-Uses Nick's animation for an Ellis replacement. Not a good idea if you ask me (-0.5)
-First aid kit hangs off his back quite a bit. Probably has something to do with the shirt plus the model. (-0.1)

Conclusion:

Overall great mod! Took off less due to it still being in beta. Looking forward to some updating :)

Pros:

+Very realistic!
+Very unique from other combat shotgun mods.

Cons:

- Ugly animation if you ask me. Makes the spas look WAY too small (-1)

Conclusion:

It is a good mod but not the greatest. Keep up the good work!

Pros:

+Much more realistic
+Sounds great
+Fun to use

Cons:

-Can be hard to hear sometimes in a fight or something (-1)

Conclusion:

Love it. Keep up the good work!

Pros:

+Good idea

Cons:

-All you really did was overpower the weapons :/ (-5)

Conclusion:

Makes the game way too easy. Should decrease it little bit

Pros:

+Good looking textures.
+Defiantly brings a feel of old time shooting into l4d2 :)

Cons:

-Reload and firing animations look weird for this specific rifle (-0.5)
-Hand seems a little funky (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Overall, fantastic mod. Should have used a different animation for it though.

Pros:

+Good looking HUD
+Love the details

Cons:

-I would like it more if you removed the custom character and weapon icons so I could use my own. (-1)
-Animation is not too great but it's not too bad either (-0.5)

Conclusion:

All is good except for the icons. I don't like them that much so if you could remove them it would be much appreciated.

Pros:

+Many options to use!
+Added lots of Sacrifice lines which is something I have been looking.
+For L4D1 for a change THANK YOU!
+Still has the original laugh, ready?, and let's go radial menus.

Cons:

-Some lines take a few tries to use as demonstrated in the video so I'm not going to take off too much for that (-0.2)
-Some lines repeat the same thing for the same person just adding a couple extra to it. Not a big deal (-0.1)

Conclusion:

LOVE IT! My favorite part is it being ACTUALLY for l4d1. Was getting tired of all the great radial menus going to l4d2. Many lines and nice to spam sometimes :3. Good work!

Pros:

+Brings back the feel of l4d1 which is what I always want!

Cons:

-Med kit glitches into the survivor's backs sometimes but not too often to call it bad. (-0.3)

Conclusion:

It's a very simple and kind of pointless mod but I like changes like that. Good job!

Pros:

+Cute
+Defiantly more likely to find something like this in a carnival over a creepy looking garden gnome
+Makes me want to keep it more often :)

Cons:

-Not sure I like the fact of the thing being part of the Soviet Union but I'm not going to take off for that. (-0)
-With how light the texture is, it kind of looks like a metal teddy bear but not a big factor at all. (-0.1)

Conclusion:

Absolutely love this! Keep up the good work!

Pros:

+ NICE remake
+Makes Rochelle look so much better.

Cons:

-Brings the open finger gloves back :( (-1)

Conclusion:

This would be my permanent Rochelle mod but I miss the gloves.

Pros:

+Blood textures are fantastic!
+Looks great
+Very unique idea

Cons:

-I feel it would look better in third person with a one-handed blunt weapon such as the night stick or the frying pan. (-0.3)
-Not very realistic to find one of these lying around. (-0.2)

Conclusion:

Absolutely great bat mod! But if you could add one for the night stick or frying pan it would be great. 

Pros:

+Good idea

Cons:

- This mod has already been made...a couple of times so may want to get more original. (-5)

Conclusion:

Already been made. All I have to say.

Pros:

+Good detail on the bat
+Color is perfect

Cons:

-Fire effect is a little cheesy (-1)

Conclusion:

Up the graphics on the fire effect a little. It would look so much better :)

Pros:

+Great model
+Voice of Coach actually fits pretty good with Sam B
+I love Sam B
+Jigglebones
+First person arms
+Custom Lobby and in game icons 

Cons:

- Still says "Coach" for the character name in game and in lobby (-0.3)

Conclusion:

Absolutely in love with this mod. Very well done and I can probably fix the con myself but still acknowledge it.

Pros:

+Looks great
+Good sounds
+<3 table tennis

Cons:

-Kind of strange to find so many table tennis rackets on stoves but you can't do much about that (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Other than the fact that you find them on stoves (which you can't do much about) GREAT MOD!

Pros:

+Looks almost exactly like the original from WAW.
+Great mechanics!
+Mystery box is very helpful.
+Weapons are split up good.

Cons:

-Really small so you feel "squeezed in". Also this makes it really hard to fight tanks. (-1.5)
-Barricades are hard to rebuild because you need to be EXCATLY on the spot they were at. (-1)

Conclusion:

Overall the map design and textures are great. If you could make it a bit bigger and easier to get around that would be great.

Pros:

+Again love the blue.
+Still good quality.
+Not too bright or dark.

Cons:

-Hate Rochelle's grin >_< (-0)
-Nick's face still looks a little strange. (-0.2)

Conclusion:

Keep up the good work these are great! :)

Pros:

+Good quality in the icons.
+Love the blue

Cons:

-A little dark on Louis and Zoey. (-0.5)
-Francis looks a little TOO shocked to be him lol not a big deal though. (-0.1)

Conclusion:

Very good icons. If possible though increase the brightness on them, sometimes hard to see them.

Pros:

+Good ak-47 look

Cons:

-Replacing the M16? Bad idea (-2)
-Mag is off (-0.5)
-Textures are cheesy looking (-1.5)
-WRONG animation used! (-1.5)
-Hand looks like it is going into the gun when you are just holding it (-1)

Conclusion:

Why would you make this replace the m16, second of all why would you use arby26's worst animation so far? Not a good mod at all

Pros:

+Brings a lot more sadness into both you dying, and your team.

Cons:

-Sometimes a little hard to hear but that may just be me and my old age lol. (-0.2)

Conclusion:

Love it. One of your best sound mods yet :)

Pros:

+Makes even ROCHELLE look a little epic :)
+Good backround colors.

Cons:

-Nick looks a little weird (-1)
-Cuts off the heads of Nick and Ellis. Not as badly after the update though. (-0.2)
-No Left 4 Dead 1 Character Icons :( but as you said not part of the crossover (-0)

Conclusion:

Overall good icons, update really improved it quite a bit. Good work!

Pros:

+Animation is great!
+Good textures on the wood and metal.

Cons:

-Hand looks way too big to be real (-1)
-The firing animation seems very "jumpy" if you know what I mean (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Great mod for the Ak-47! Definitly one I'm going to be using for quite a while.

Pros:

+Uh good idea to try to create a new animation?

Cons:

-The hand on firing, walking, reloading, and basically holding all look plain weird. (-3)
-With a low viewmodel like the default it is hard to see the reload at all. (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Uh I think I will just stick with the original Valve ak-47 animation thanks.

Pros:

+Cool sounds
+Model is pretty good

Cons:

-Reload and firing animations are awful (-2)
-No walking animation (-1)
-Textures don't look too much different from the original SMG (-1.5)

Conclusion:

I must say this is a real disappointment for Doctor Haus. I really would have expected a better gun from him.

Pros:

+Great Sound
+From tf2 (although I'm not a fan of the game so I'm putting in both pros and cons)

Cons:

-Only been uploaded about 50 times on tons of other mods but you can separate the mod and the sound from them. So basically not very original. (-2)
-From tf2(although I'm not a fan of the game so I'm putting in both pros and cons)

Conclusion:

I guess it is ok just not very original.

Pros:

+Melee when down, good idea

Cons:

-Some weapons seem a little too overpowered (-1)
-Spas shotgun is NOT that accurate (-1.5)
-Keeping some of the special infected itself seemed like the wrong choice (-1.5)
-Interflicts with way too many other mods (-2)

Conclusion:

Not very realistic if you ask me seems like many other realism mods...

Pros:

+Ok textures

Cons:

-Way to small to be real (-2)
-Wrong animation to use for the regular ak-47 (-1.5)
-Can't see the hands well without a really high viewmodel (-1)
-The smoke after fireing looks really cheesy (-1)
-The body of the gun looks too smooth in my opinion (-1)

Conclusion:

Really not a good mod for the ak. Shouldn't have used the ak-74 animation for it, makes it look WAY too small to be realistic.

Pros:

+Good model for the katana
+Gets blood on it
+Cool looking

Cons:

-In dark areas it looks just black...(-1.5)
-Hard to see the blood on it sometimes (-1)
-Some textures don't look that great (-1)

Conclusion:

It's an ok mod although I think you could do better.

Pros:

+Good texture
+Animation is ok

Cons:

-The first person running animation is a little um "overboard" (-1)
-Sometimes hard to hear the reload sounds (-1)
-When meleeing with dual pistols the hand glitches into the gun. (-1)

Conclusion:

It's an ok mod but not something I would use.

Pros:

+Great custom sounds!
+Animation fits perfectly!
+Textures well done
+Looks like something you would really see in the military
+Great flashlight placement

Cons:

-Third person hand glitches into the grip a little. (-0.5)
-Can't use the scope but nothing anyone can do about that (-0)

Conclusion:

This is a great m16 mod! Textures, realism, animation, and model are all great. All things I look for :) But still the finger glitches into the grip a little in third person.

Pros:

+Good detail on the hunter
+Lot of colors
+Looks like he was in a paint fight before he died (not sure if pro or con so I put in both)

Cons:

-Some of the colors really seem too bright in my opinion. Hurts my eyes. But not a big deal. (-0.5)
-Bad screenshots (nothing against the mod) (-0)
-Looks like he was in a paint fight before he died (not sure if pro or con so I put in both) (-0)

Conclusion:

Great mod for the hunter! I would dim down the brightness a little though if possible.

Pros:

+Eh good idea?

Cons:

-Textures are really bad even after the update... (-1.5)
-In first person it appears as if your holding the gun  with a grip but in third person it appears with no grip. In other words used the wrong animation. (-1.5)
-Scope looks out of place and is not that good. (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Not the greatest mod I have ever seen but it is ok I guess.

Pros:

+Cool replacement for the hunting rifle

Cons:

-First person model looks a little funny not sure how to explain it. (-1)
-Should have used arby26's more recent m14 animation not the old one. Would have looked a lot better on it. (-0.5)
-Hand clips into the mag a little bit when reloading. (-1)
-Textures are not that great. (-1)

Conclusion:

Overall good mod but I would suggest putting arby's most recent m14 animation on it and not the old one.

Pros:

+Great animation eh kinda
+Model is OK

Cons:

-Reload time seems a bit slow (-0.5)
-Hard to see the logo on the side (-0.5)
-Hands holding the shotgun looks kinda weird (-0.5)
-Textures are not that great. Can't tell if the gun is green or black... (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Great mod for the shotgun although could definatly use some updating.

Pros:

+Cool blue
+Blood comes out great on the guitar
+Realistic

Cons:

-Textures are not as good on this one as on the red one (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Another great guitar mod but textures could be improved a bit.

Pros:

+Great guitar look
+Good detail on the textures

Cons:

-Kinda hard to see the blood since it is red but that isn't a big deal. (-0.1)

Conclusion:

Great mod for the guitar! 

Pros:

+Good ideas
+Makes it look like they have turned. Eh kinda

Cons:

-You say in the description that nobody liked louis. I HIGHLY disagree. (-1)
-The bill model for the smoker is really cheesy. (-3)
-Bill looks to tall...(-2)
-Makes me want to get pounced :( (-0)
-Zoey's crawling and jumping animation looks weird on the hunter (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Needs some real improvements to actually be good...

Pros:

+GREAT animation! Looks just like the animation from Call of Duty :D
+Textures are fantastic
+Animation is very smooth

Cons:

-If you melee and shoot right after the shooting animation doesn't happen although it still fires but that is a known issue so not much of a problem. (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Other than the shooting and melee glitch in the animation (see con). Great mod! Worth a download!

Pros:

+Looks great in thirdperson
+Replaces the frying pan

Cons:

-Looks really bad in first person (-2)
-Textures are cheesy looking in my opinion (-1)
-No HUD Icon (-0.5)
-Not very realistic to find these things laying around the place especially on a stove... (-1)
-Sometimes they clips into tables, floor, ground, etc. when lying around. (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Needs some real improvements for me to download. But I guess some people would like these.

Pros:

+Great textures on the mod!
+Pretty smooth animation
+Great for the Ak-47!

Cons:

-Reload seems a little too fast in my opinion but not a big deal (-0.5)
-Unforintatly no custom sounds (-1)

Conclusion:

Good mod for the ak-47 definatly worth a download :D

Pros:

+He is a cop ya know
+Good model

Cons:

-Gloves look very bad (-2)
-In first person the gloves go over the fingertips (-1.5)
-Should have removed the rings. Doesn't make sense to have rings over gloves. (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Needs some updating on the gloves other than that good mod

Pros:

+Great detail in face
+Good choice of songs
+Model design is superb

Cons:

-The music is pretty loud even with my headphones low (-0.5)
-No facial expressions but that is hard to do (-1)
-Makes me want to startle the witch :( (-0)

Conclusion:

Great mod keep up the good work! :)

Pros:

+Very realistic
+Feels like the walking dead eh kinda

Cons:

-The specials are not very much slower
-Events make this almost impossible with the millions of headshot only common flying at you at once.
-Specials are still spawn :/
-Making survivors slower was not a good idea in my opinion
-Some gun damages seem too low

Conclusion:

My opinion to you is to make survivors and gun damage normal again. Also getting rid of hordes because they can kill you very fast. Also SI are still spawning for some reason also making this IMPOSSIBLE. Get some updates on this man.

Pros:

+Very nice previews
+Better than originals in my opinion

Cons:

-Unforinatly no previews for the l4d1 campaigns

Conclusion:

This is GREAT just make some for the l4d1 campaigns and it will be perfect!

Pros:

+Nice camo
+Great movement animations
+Good placement on the flashlight

Cons:

-Sometimes the hand is not fully synced with the weapon and it goes through the gun when reloading while moving or looking down or up. This hurts the gun tremedously in my opinion. (-3)
-Can't use the sight but nobody can do anything about that (-0)
-Sometimes when using in other servers, the fast reload can make it stop a second before the rounds appear which is a real pain in the butt (-1.5)

Conclusion:

Overall great mod! But need to fix the reload bug and maybe slow the reload down a little bit to make it sync with the normal scar.

Pros:

+Great scenery in the map
+Good length
+Fitting skybox

Cons:

-Unfrotinatly no offical l4d2 music added into the campaign but some of custom music added in makes up for some of that.
-Missing textures in some of the maps.
-Tier 2 right at the begining?
-Finale seems too easy

Conclusion:

Now before you start screaming at me that it is just beta, trust me I understand. Believe me I think this would turn into a great campaign after a little updating. Keep up the good work and I'll put up an updated review.