Pros:

brilliant sounds!

Cons:

you should update sounds from newest cod game. :)

Conclusion:

awesome. simply awesome. Could use sounds from mw2 or mw3 though.

Pros:

- Very VERY accurate
- Scare effects
- Fun campaign
- Alien ending

Cons:

- Versus glitch when starting some levels
- Some glitches here and there like nav glitches
- Bots are kind of stupid sometimes
- Some spawning points

Conclusion:

This is by far one of the most accurate adaptations I have ever played. My 2 silent hill fans were just amazed watching me go through this map. You only missed one part towards the end (I'll update this later when I figure out wtf he was talking about... lol...).

The scare effects were funny, and the puzzles were wickedly accurate to the game. I was just like woah... you know.

The thing that bugs me when playing online is that some levels start in versus mode... I think it's mostly the church one and the sewers ones. There are some glitches here and there, mostly nav glitches. Also the bots fall pretty easy in some spots like towards the end during and a little after the lighthouse.

The alien ending surprised me the most. I know me and one of my Silent Hill friends watching me play this campaign again was like "what! NICE!" lol...

Pros:

- scenery
- paths that are rare to come by these days
- finale
- challenging
- 4th map

Cons:

- 4th map
- way too challenging
- can't play on advanced or above
- colors
- some things are still white like cars, doors, and etc.

Conclusion:

I give you a 100 because this map is by far the best one I have played. I liked it better when I put it to easy though... After big jump in 4th level, 2 tanks... omg.. it was just me.. I was hoping no hunter, and I was like "YES!" Thank goodness survivor closet was nearby and that the 2nd tank got stuck...

For the scenery & environment though.. just... *mwuah!* perfecto!

I can't tell you how far you could go with this if you made it for L4D2. You could have plenty more in it, for sure... but for another time.

Pros:

+ Elevator Part = Unique
+ Length
+ Footballs at stadium = priceless
+ Epic moments
+ Train at end of 4th map

Cons:

- Tank = beginning of last level
- Finale's not much
- Stadium was okay

Conclusion:

It had its moments for sure, the moment when you can get clobbered at the beginning of the last map by a tank is funny, but a fail. He should not be able to spawn there...

The length and detail was very good. I didn't see a reason for the extra space to go out the side of that one building though.. I think it was the 3rd or 4th level. The train scene at the end of the 4th map was cool, but would have been more fun if it were longer...

Pros:

+ one huge ship!
+ challenges
+ under water is cool
+ Literally Left 4 Dead sometimes
+ I shot witch and Zoey got thrown off 2 floors! It was epic!

Cons:

- Hard to navigate sometimes
- Easy to get lost at the beginning
- Beginning, no back up!?
- Easy to get lost
- Bot gets stuck at high tower at finale
- No way to get back up at the end
- Last fall in 2nd map = pointless
- Tank knocks off a survivor towards the top, survivor is alive for 1/2 a min.
- 10 continuous horde spawns in one of the last maps

Conclusion:

Pretty darn good for a beta, but needs some work still of course.

You are literally left 4 dead on the ship almost half the time, including the finale! Kinda annoyed me how you could not get back up at the finale.

Finale: Tank sound comes on.... no tank? Really? He dies real quick like too like he was on fire and got stuck. A scare tactic? Interesting. Also, can't get back up to where other survivors with rifles are.. usually... wtf...??

There's a place in 2nd map at the end... a drop that's really pointless. The zombies & special infected are gone by then. There's really no point. There's also a spot where we were climbing up the stairs. I shot witch, and I ran for it. I later found out teammates gunned her down, but the witch (as an act of desperation) knocked Zoey down about 2 stories... I was laughing my @$$ OFF!! HAHA! There's another spot towards the top before the electric walls. Thank showed up... Knocked survivor off into the water... He was alive for like a minute miraculously and game had to spoil it.. next 30 seconds and he was dead... either have him dead when he falls or keep him alive.. that was a dirty glitch mister... =-p Also, one of my teammates there had to shoot Zoey (who was still at the sniper point) and get her incapacitated for the heli to fly away... wtf...?

Lastly, there was a spot in map 3 where we had to activate a switch.. only 2 of us there... like 10 hordes in a row we had to fight through to rescue b4 we could get the other survivors... wtf...??

Pros:

- No lag
- 3rd map: Better safe than sorry
- Tank glitch during 3rd map

Cons:

- 1st map: WAY TOO SHORT
- Sounds in the beginning sounded glitchy
- In the first 2 levels there were glitchy movements
- Middle to end of 4th map - Glitchy bullet holes
- Can get stuck easily at the finale

Conclusion:

First off, that was clever with the 100x's written better safe than sorry. I lol'd at that. I also lol'd at the tank glitch I think it was towards the end of the 3rd map. He was stuck on the upper floor like a helpless baby whining all like "oh no, I can't get down.. and I'm on fire... hehe..."

Secondly, the 1st map is way too short... If I would've timed it, it probably would've shown anywhere between 2 and 5 minutes. It was just that short to me. The sounds in the beginning of the campaign sounded glitchy, like the first horde coming. Also in the first 2 levels, every time I moved or opened a door at most points, it glitched a little. Between the middle and the end of the 4th map, especially where the target symbols show you can tell the bullet holes are glitchy.

Finally, the finale. You gave enough space in the warehouse to fight for sure. The tank fights were okay too... but when the boat came.. that's when I lol'd. You had the zombies coming in to attack way too fast and way too many at once. Just after a few seconds, the tank came and pushed me in the water... Well... I couldn't find where to get up. He ended up coming down and killing me, even with me & my teammates unleashing bullets of fury on him. So it's easy to get stuck between the boat and the dock. Make the boat go over more and the dock to the boat a little longer.

Pros:

- Great environment
- Not a lot of lag
- Original escape route
- Lengthy

Cons:

- Bodies seem to disappear instead of staying towards the end and at the end.
- Soundtrack did mess up once or twice
- Finale environment is way too large.
- Issues with frame rate

Conclusion:

This is a really good, and original campaign in my opinion. I liked the environments and the way you set up everything. There weren't too many tanks, too. That could also be a con for some people, because I know some people just love fighting those tanks. At the very beginning and the very end of the campaign, I noticed some slight frame rate issues as well. Besides those I can't say much else. Very good campaign.