Pros:

+Good lighting ( I use a mod that improves the lighting. The results are awesome!)
+Good amount of supplies
+Challenging, but fair 
+Detailed environments
+Custom sounds
+That event on the 3rd map escape or get blown up!
+The prison! Holy crap loved it! (But...)
+Goo hazard
+Those 2 boomers fighting each other at the end of the campaign, lol!

Cons:

-The prison event to shut off the alarm was a bit hard. Perhaps reduce the amount of zombies that spawn?
-Going from one place to another didn't really make any sense. (Not a con, just wanted to point that out. Doesn't really matter anyway.)

Conclusion:

This campaign was amazing! I don't normally play long campaigns, but this is one of the few that are actually worth playing through. I've seen people complain about the maps not giving enough directions or it's too dark, I say forget them. There's mods in this site that give you brighter and bigger flashlights. (Think outside the box.) I use it so the dark maps don't bother me. In fact it makes the campaign more atmospheric. I read an update is coming. I really hope you won't dumb the difficulty down for those players who need their hands to be held. Amazing campaign again.

Pros:

+ The atmosphere
+ Puzzles (But.....)
+ Silent Hill music
+ Special infected skins to match silent hill (A few RE skins as well. An odd choice, but they fit the atmosphere as well.)
+ Amazing visuals! (Specially the other world!)

Cons:

- A bit disappointed that the puzzles mostly consist of finding keys
- The last two levels completely killed the atmosphere
- Maybe put at least 2 med kits in each safe room (Not really a con just a suggestion.)

Conclusion:

Despite not being the biggest Silent Hill fan, this campaign was amazing! I always found the series not that scary and a bit boring, but I always loved the lore and atmosphere of it; and this campaign perfectly captures this. I look forward to the complete overhaul of the first Silent Hill campaign you created! Normally I avoid long campaigns. They tend to over stay there welcome, but not this one! It's a joy, even when replaying it!

Pros:

+ Custom Music
+ Good bot nav/ easy navigation
+ Environments look good (but.....)
+ Good amount of supplies

Cons:

- Everything starts to look the same
- It's seems that 3 special infected spawn at the same time, starting after map 3
- Lackluster finale, was hoping for something more exciting, it does the job I guess

Conclusion:

A great campaign. Just a few minor issues, but worth playing through.