Pros:

-Brings back the dark nature of the  l4d1 atmosphere
-Detailed maps, invites exploration
-Wonderful challenge balance, even on expert level
-Great combination of narrow and wide variety of areas
-Maps allow a robust amount of common and special infected to fight
-Challenging Finally, but not too overwhelming

Cons:

-If you're not use to playing on expert level, this camp will definitely chew you up and spit you out. :P

Conclusion:

What can i say but praise this piece of work for giving me and my friends such enjoyment in playing through this.
I Hate Mountains is defiantly an all round winner along with Death Aboard.

The dynamic of this campaign sparks that immersible feeling i had when i first played left 4 dead 1.

I wish camps like Tour of Terror, Suicide Blitz 2 and a few others could possess such a great challenge balance this camp brought.

If you're reading this and are new to playing custom content, download these maps! It's a great way to introduce yourself to a well created custom content, before having the more unfortunate gameplay experiences other authors may provide.

Great job on this!

Pros:

-3 maps with good length and a robust amount of infected to kill.

-Achieves the highly desired middle ground of not too easy and not too difficult to play, even on expert.

-Finally is challenging via Parish style, but not too overwhelming to the point of forcing restart grinds.

Cons:

This campaign may feel a bit short for those who like to "rush" through. I'm not fond of that playing style anyway so i enjoyed it greatly. :)

Conclusion:

Now this is  Solid, great map staging and a fresh take on a death toll like setting. I highly recommend this camp, it's worth the play through.

People may complain it's length, but i personally feel it's extensive enough.

If only custom maps like DEAD BEFORE DAWN, WARCELONA, and URBAN FLIGHT could achieve a balanced challenge like this custom camp provided.

This may not be a colorful and flashy as the names I mentioned, but it has substance over style.

Great job! I hope to see Yanzl produce more in the future.

Pros:

-Game playpath style, had a nice flow you could say.
-Plenty of Weapons and ammo
-Despite the well stocked maps it didn't make thing too easy.
-Great added twist with the finally two part door release to reach the rescue vehicle.

Cons:

-Tank during the crescendo of the first map
-First map was the more difficult then the rest of the camp, a bit of a glaring issue to most player temperaments.
-Finally has too many random horde spawning before actual event. 

-The escape to the stairs toward the rescue vehicle  has ridiculous density of zombies. Nearly impossible to overcome unless on a much lower difficulty.

Conclusion:

For most of the body of this camp, it's pretty solid. Nice layout, i especially like the play path. Despite how straight forward it was, there was  nice density of enemy obstacles (the witches) that made a sort of forced cautious sense of navigation. It turned it into a thinking player's sort of map.

However the crescendo in the first map can be very testing. As short as it is, a half dozen witches and a tank spawning at time will tend to cause players to drop this, or force themselves to settle on a difficulty lower then expert. *Lowering standards to complete a game is a big no no in my book.*  This especially come in hand to the escape up the stairs toward the rescue helicopter.

 I've tried this online several times and it was common for people to rage over too many frustrating restarts. This becomes a problem of "level grinding" which in a way undermines all of effort of creating the camp. 

The best community maps have been the one to have a nice balanced challenge. Not too easy that everyone to run through it effortlessly on expert, but not too hard as a team that makes little to no mistakes still finding themselves repeating the same chapter 4-10 times.

Good camp, but the "level grinding" issue doesn't exactly temp players to wanna jump back in and play it all over again. Just tune out some of the more frustrating points and this camp will be golden! I hope you come back and revise this.

Pros:

-Awesome original aspects of the camp.

-Great poster, just had to mention that.

-Very crisp map layout, interesting as well.

-The finally has such a nice touch that one else has done before.

Cons:

-Feel like there need to be more defensible area's in the finally. Take advantage of the large map with real options of defense!

Conclusion:

No camp has ever stood out in my mind than this one, and sorry to mention names but not even Dead Before Dawn brought me back into the game like this did. I feel personally like this is the holy grail of community maps and should be a set standard that all others fallow.

That games mechanics make it challenging, causing good players who make bad mistakes to fail, but not nearly impossible to overcome. Good team work will make this intensely fun, especially on expert.

No matter how many times i play it, i still get into the great span of map types, the crescendo's and especially the map spanning inside the marooned and abandoned ship. You sir are a genius far mapping goes. Great great work!

Pros:

-Great custom sounds.

-Feels like the parish, and is better in my opinion.

-Great mix of spacious and confined areas.

Cons:

-No deagles! Or too well hidden.

-Invisible m4's, for shame....

-Invisible level props, at the pool side map, and top of stair in the 1st.

-Major exploit, fuel cans can be gathered right next to rescue vehicle before the finally is set off.

Conclusion:

Great map with crisp game play fundamentals, pathogen flaws irked me. Just a little fixing and i'd rate it much higher. Hope to see a revised version in the future.

Pros:

-Great environments! 

-Interesting play paths

Cons:

-Major Finally exploit with sitting inside the "safe truck", too easy even on expert.

-Some spawn closet didn't quite make much since in structure and look.

-Some parts are too bare, need more details and navigational obstacles.

Conclusion:

Even if it's deemed "complete", still feels like a beta and has alot of flawed game mechanics. Especially in the finally with the sorely obvious exploit.

Not to say it's a bad campaign, but it could use quite a bit of polishing and refining before this ranks it along side the more popular camps. Hope you come back to it and perfect it!

Pros:

-Interesting concept of game play style
-Suspenseful moments during the rides.
-Thrilling escape finally

Cons:

-Too short game play session
-Needs more infected stationary and wandering common infected.

Conclusion:

Although this really grabbed me from the get go, the game experience itself was much too short. Barely had any infected to fight except for the gas collection panic event. I played by myself on expert and beat it under 20 minutes. It need to be a bit more challenging.