Pros:

Loved the full campaign, almost has a story feeling to it. Also loved the realistic placement of weapons, rather than having guns everywhere

Cons:

Only cons I can think of is that there are too many chargers and spitters at the beginning

Conclusion:

Probably THE best campaign I've ever played so far. Definitely recommend playing!!

Pros:

Incredible...EVERYTHING

Cons:

YOUR DAMN PLACEMENT OF THE WITCH AT THE VERY END HAHA!

Conclusion:

Everything in this campaign is awesome! the only bad things I can think of are that the AI sometimes fail at obstacles such as the lazers, but these don't alter the score in any way. Good job!

Definitely recommend this. I look forward to the L4D2 version.

Pros:

-Absolutely amazing
-Just like the ride at some stages
- Interesting writing on the walls adds humor
- Little differences, like the traps on the floor, make it more fun to play
-Each map is different and visually stunning

Cons:

-Can be too long, I didn't find it a problem, but If I died near the end, I might be tempted to quit
- The last level has issues. I keep crashing when I'm mid way on it, and when I load L4D2 back up, the console has something about not loading certain things in multi player or something. I've never finished this level because I got DC'ed mid finale wave

Conclusion:

Nothing needs work really. I think the problem on the finale is a fault with my computer / game. REALLY good campaign, definatly recommend downloading this!

Pros:

-This is an absolutely amazing map in its own terms
- A really good representation of the ride
- Amazing effects such as the music, sounds and stationary infected (playing roles / instruments) on the boat ride
-Layout of 'Left 4 Dead' way with zombies is really good as-well
-Nice to see a crescendo event

Cons:

- First time playing, the way the screen just suddenly goes black, I thought my computer had just died haha! This could do with being changed
- The 'Left 4 Dead' way could do with more hints on where to go; sometimes it was easy to get lost

Conclusion:

Even though I have stated a couple of cons, I'm rating this 100. This map is one of the best I have played, and while it's not the best for zombies, just the design and feel of it brings back memories because it looks so much like the original with a zombie twist! Such a good map, you've worked hard and it's obviously paid off!