Beautiful levels, but gameplay needs work

Pro:

-Nice, pretty environment design
-Decent length

Con:
-Bots frequently get separated and take ages to catch up
-No health in most safe rooms
-Absolutely no indicators of what the switches actually open which makes a lot of the levels rather confusing
-No indication during the finale over where you're meant to escape.

All told, not the worst campaign I've played, the level design was very nice but a couple of small but annoying design choices like leaving health from safe rooms and not hilighting what the levers open made playing the campaign a little bit of a drag, Left 4 Dead's gameplay just doesn't make "hunt for the locked door" fun, but a few small design tweaks and this would become a great campaign.

Great campaign, but needs imporovement

I found this to be a pretty interesting campaign, it looks great and handles well. The only reason I have gone with 4 stars rather than 5 is the messed up bot navigation and the fact that the campaign doesn't seem to track your stats properly. Given how much I enjoyed this campaign it's a shame it wasn't longer

Pro

-Interesting environments (loved the river)
-Good map design
-Visually interesting

Con

-Poor nav (bots dropping and getting stuck)
-No stat tracking

Reasonably Good

While this stopped a little short of being a great campaign, it was a relatively good one. The environments tended to feel a bit 'samey' though the fire animations were excellent.

Pros

-Good environment design
-Interesting concept

Pros

-Specials occasionally got stuck in clipping making them easy to kill
-Backtracking made the level feel a bit samey

Amazing

This was an amazing campaign. The mapping was very high quality, it had some high quality (and amusing) easter eggs, and a great finale. Among the best custom campaigns I've played!

Loved it

Unlike a lot of reviewers I had no trouble navigating the level. The mapping quality was good, the campaign was long with a fair difficulty curve, and the finale was really interesting. If I'm being overly critical the only nit I would pick would be that I found the sunlight on the first (beach) map to be a little over saturated. Still would peg this a "must play" though

Pros:

-Excellent original idea
-Lots of custom content
-Good Plot

Cons:

-The catacombs in the 4th level were boring, and confusingly laid out
-The finale was excessively difficult. -The tanks near the escape boat make it really difficult to get out of the level alive

Conclusion:

I loved the atmosphere, and the setting, and the custom skins. Very good bug free mapping as well. Like a lot of other reviewers I would say the only letdowns are the 4th map and the overly difficult escape. Still a 5/5 for me, but I would like to see some tweaks.

Pros:

Good level design
Interesting, original idea
Difficulty scales up per level

Cons:

Scripted tank spawns
The finale was way too easy. The long, wide corridor made it basically like being in a shooting gallery

Conclusion:

Overall a campaign I enjoyed. Level design was unique and interesting, no massive bugs (but one instance of missing texture). Only reason for not getting 5 out of 5 will be the fact that the finale was way too easy.

Pros:

Good map design
Interesting levels
Well balanced difficulty
Well paced

Cons:

Lack of proper illumination in some parts of levels
Lack of proper illumination in the finale

Conclusion:

Overall a pretty good campaign but the lack of illumination in the finale spoiled it for me. Still a worthwhile play though

Pros:

Excellent level design
Faithful reproduction of the original maps
Fun
Well paced

Cons:

Dismounting the ladder at the end of the cradle level without being left hanging from the beam was tough

Conclusion:

The only thing stopping this getting a 10 was the flaw with the ladder at the end of cradle. Either the platform needs to be widened or it made easier to dismount the ladder. Otherwise a first class campaign

Pros:

Excellent, and clever level design
Puzzle elements were well thought out and just the right level of difficulty
Original level design
Fun

Cons:

Very tough in single player mode
The moving targets puzzle in chapter 4 was very difficult to time in single player mode
The location with the pipes and falling cars wasn't the most fair place to spawn a tank
Having to keep picking up the grenade launcher spoiled the flow a bit, as it made me keep dropping weapons, which the other players then stole. Maybe have the glass breakable with shots as well?

Conclusion:

Just as good as the first campaign. Difficulty might be a bit steep for novice players, but I really enjoyed it overall. The only thing stopping me giving it a 10 was the difficulty in timing the puzzle in chapter 4

Pros:

Good level design
Reasonable level of accuracy
Plenty of supplies

Cons:

Hard Finale
No ammo piles in safe rooms

Conclusion:

My only major complaint would be the lack of ammo piles in the saferooms, having to pick up new weapons, annoyingly, negated the advantage of picking up addons like laser sights. Otherwise an excellent campaign, finale was more difficult than average but still overall an excellent level pack

Pros:

Interesting character re-skins
Interesting and different

Cons:

Level design was far too confusing. It just felt like having to backtrack and hunt for the exit all the time.
Playing the game of hunt the key repeatedly just got frustrating too quickly.

Conclusion:

This has the potential to be a great map package but I would like to see it re-worked to have some pathway hints like you get in normal L4D maps, and the silly games of "find the key" removed. The annoying side distractions ruined the pace of the mod for me, and in the end I got lost and ended up quitting out of annoyance.