Pros:

-Nice settings
-Dark lighting
-Fast paced

Cons:

-Very short (-0.5)
-Finale is too easy (-1)
-Not very complicated (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Good campaign, very easy, but that compensates with the lack of supplies in safe rooms. It is at the same level of some of the official campaigns. The campaign itself felt very easy to play with bots, so I guess with a team should be piece of cake. The two special events during the campaign are very simple and easy, and the finale is way too easy. 

It is extremely short, which leaves me a bit cold, but it is still an enjoyable campaign, even more so if you don't have the time to beat one of the normal campaigns.

It doesn't feel very special, nor it has anything original or innovative, but it's good and fast, so it should work. Not one of my MUST HAVE, but I'm still keeping it for those times when I can't play for too long but I still have free time. 

Congrats, Gurt. Good job. And thanks for your work!

Pros:

-Four original and interesting maps
-Different pathways and details
-Detailed maps
-Nice and diverse settings
-That pickaxe
-Versus special ambush
-Hard rain events
-Custom intro

Cons:

-Random pathways may get you a bit confused
-Finale is a bit easy (-0.2)
-Custom intro (-0.1)
-Impossible to accomplish w/ bots

Conclusion:

Excelent campaign. One of my MUST HAVE. The maps differs a bit (or a lot) each time you play, which is awesome, but if you're playing alone with the lazy bots because none of your friends have this map, it may become exhausting. 

The length is average, which is quite good, but with all those random tweaks you'll spend more time than you'd think.  The design is good and the scenery varied. You won't get bored.

The finale is a bit easy, maybe one more Tank spawning in the end would be better.

On the downside, you won't be able to beat it without human players. So, go call your friends and tell them to download this campaign so you can play it once and once again! 

NOTE: As an exception, I'm giving this campaing a completely different score for solo players. 4 for you, guys. It's still a wonderful campaing and you'll enjoy playing it a lot, but if you happen to get one of those special events in which you need another human player (or the finale itself) it will be very frustrating).

Edited: I forgot about the intro. Having to watch it every time I play seems like boring to me. But still, it's a  minor detail.

Pros:

-Three long maps
-Very well-designed (gameplay wise)
-Challenging
-Way finding
-Option to turn off way finding

Cons:

-Bad designed (aesthetical wise) (-0.5)
-A bit confusing (-0.2)
-Finale is way too easy (-1)

Conclusion:

It's a very good campaign, but with a few flaws that prevents it from being one of my MUST HAVE. While the campaign is pretty interesting and challenging, the setting and the design of the buildings seems very awkward to me. In the sense that I see a lot of weird mixtures of cliffs, walls, and different kinds of buildings which doesn't make me feel the immersion. 

Still, that is aesthetically only, gameplay wise, it makes for a lot of exploring and it becomes very challenging the first time you play. I also encourage to play with the way finding off. In fact, that's how I have always played it. The second map gets a bit confusing, imo, with a lot of doors, buttons and levels. I got to a point where I stood for half an hour without advancing till I found the right way (pretty obvious now, though). 

The finale, while it seems amazing, can be very easily accomplished by staying in one corner in the main building, where you can see infected coming through the doors and windows, and then the Tanks can be beaten more easily by jumping between the roofs of the main building and the building where the radio is.

Still, a very nice campaign, and if you get to play with friends you'll enjoy it. If you play versus more then you definitely want to have this. Not staying in my collection for the moment, though. Nonetheless, very good job doing this, cincinnati, congratulation!

Pros:

-Four long maps
-Challenging
-Very original
-Very well desgined
-Very nice settings
-Very detailed
-Scattered resources

Cons:

-Very long maps (-0.2)
-Few Tanks (-0.3)
-Tanks in the finale too easy (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Overall it's an excelent campaign, and it will stay in my collection as one of my favorites. Stil, there are a few issues that stands between this maps and perfection. While the long maps makes for interesting and intense playthroughs, these are very long maps and while it is still "easily" doable (all my reviews are done on advanced) it keeps me from completely enjoying the maps.

Also, the lack of Tanks is a bit disappointing. Only twice I have faced the Tanks. The first one in the third map, and the second one in the finale. And both were far too easy. Maybe a few more Tanks across the maps and the Tanks in the finale spawning a bit closer to the survivors would make it better.

Nevertheless, a completely recommended add-on. Great job, Bloue, congratulations for this great campaign, and thank you!

Pros:

-Long maps
-Nice settings
-Well-designed
-Last finale

Cons:

-A bit bland sometimes, specially in map 2 (-0.2)
-Few weapons and supplies, more annoying than challenging
-Lot of hordes, which keeping in mind the complain above (-1.5)
-Tanks in the last finale spawn far away (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Pretty good map, although not amongst my MUST HAVE collection. Still, very interesting to play, and that finale...

Maybe some more (and better) weapons should be placed in the first two maps, also,some more supplies, maybe some pipe/molotov or some pills. Definitely not both, though, that would make it too easy.

Great work overall, pretty good map, but it needs some tweaks imo. As it is now, it doesn't look like it will stay in my collection. 

Pros:

-Very detailed map.
-Five long and well-designed maps
-Finales
-Lots of fun
-Diversity of settings
-Very addictive

Cons:

-The skybox in alcatraz is a bit bland (-0.1)
-The last map finale is quite easy compared to others in the same campaign (-0.5)

Conclusion:

Incredibly good campaing. I was amazed at the amount of work put into this. Definitely staying in my game and will be played once and once again. I strongly encourage everyone to download and see. 

On the other hand, maybe it could still use some minor tweaks, but overall a MUST HAVE. Congratulations to DannBo, you've done an awesome mod! Thanks a lot!