Pros:

Great events
Creepy Atmosphere that gets scarier
Great pacing
Map is big but we never got completely lost

Cons:

Too long (spare 2-3 hours to play this)

Conclusion:

The map looks great. The design is great. On the server we played more SI spawned but maybe that's true for vanilla too. If it's not play it on Advanced and the map will really start to scare you.

Pros:

Resident evil
non linear maps
funny moments
custom pistols

Cons:

sound keeps screeching
very long (bad for some good if you have friends that will play this with you)

Conclusion:

Great campaign. It has some very quirky moments like the boat breaking the barricade, the dogs showing up, the witch music, a bunch of tanks in the end, pianos, and more. Good reason why PC gaming rocks.

Pros:

-original campaign that makes it feel like a different game
-great visuals
-adding of sound and skin mods is a plus
-hordes do not appear every 5 seconds like in Death Mountain (a bad thing since it requires puzzle solving and backtracking)
-cut-scenes!

Cons:

-no indication that you got a key (lots of times we tried the door without knowing we got a key)
-second to last map should've been split in two
-the difficulty goes from really hard to very easy after the sewers chapter

Conclusion:

This campaign shows why modding can bring something completely different to a game you already have. Although it did take a while to complete the campaign i found myself saying "wow that's creepy" and "what went on here?" The only thing holding it back is that there is no indication that you got a key like in Kokiri Forest. Great Visuals, great sound, great immersion, subtle storytelling