Pros:

- Atmospheric
- Great detail (wish there were slightly more paintings, maybe on the bottom floor?)
- Lots of places to hold out and none of them feel like they're better or worse than the other
- Level design somewhat encourages constant movement but doesn't force it on those who like to just hold out on one spot
- Good placement of supplies/weapons
- Unique setting

Cons:

- One of the tanks died a few seconds after he spawned, assuming one of the spawns are glitched (saw his arm sticking out of some wall on the far left corner of where the survivors are first facing)
- Smoke effect doesn't look very good or make sense in some areas
- Don't like how some of the rooms are mirrored (I can make an exception for the bathrooms but for the rooms surrounding it, not so much)

Minor Cons/Nitpicks: Camera intro is a bit unnecessary if you don't plan on making it more interesting.

Conclusion:

Overall a really solid map. All it needs is more polish and it could be even better than it already is.

Pros:

- Great atmosphere
- Lots of places to hold out
- Very detailed
- Balanced amount of supplies/weapons
- Item/weapon placement

Cons:

- Bots had some issues with windows
- A little too tank friendly sometimes, your only real option is to jump out a window if you're in a 2nd floor room when he comes around
- Although the house design is very realistic and well done, it does feel very cramped

Minor Cons/Nitpicks: Don't personally like it when map editors make pools since there's no swimming mechanic and you can hold your breath forever, it ends up breaking immersion.

It's a bit predictable where the infected are going to come in from.

I'm also getting some random graphical bugs showing combine nexus doors on windows, I took screenshots but I forgot you can't put urls in here. I guess it's a problem on my side because no one else here has mentioned it but I felt I should say it anyway.

Conclusion:

Overall I really like it. It's not the most original idea for a map but the amount of thought put into the detail, atmosphere, and general level design is admirable.

Pros:

- Perfect for versus mode.
- Extremely unique and well done level design.
- Lots of effort made into detail.
- Very long (maybe a little too long but I'd rather it be long than short).
- Love the rescue "vehicle".

Cons:

- The finale area still seems unbalanced for survivors, tank gets half his health down before he even enters the lighthouse.
- Would've liked to see change in time of day.
- Very little items on the ship level.
- Falling car on ship level is a bit unexpected and unfair.

Conclusion:

One of my personal favorites, hope to see more!

Pros:

- Great level layout
- Unique Design
- Challenging
- Epic Finale

Cons:

- Not much room for strategy in the finale
- Awkward ending
- Could use more dialogue or events that don't necessarily trigger the horde

Conclusion:

Great campaign that can easily be tuned up to perfection, quite possibly the best I've seen for l4d2 so far. Looking forward to more work from this mapper.