Pros:

-Great atmosphere and lighting
-Insane amounts of detailing
-Great crescendo events
-Faultless AI
-Long campaign (45-60 min on normal)
-Varied locations
-Realistic environments
-Good flow
-Custom sounds, models, weapon and skin
-Special effects
-Best sound design I've ever seen

Cons:

-Sometimes a few lag hiccups
-Had weird looking fire one time (none the next time)
-Too few useful melee weapons (only pans and nightsticks)
-The rail yard crescendo arena is a bit small
-The train tunnel is a bit undetailed. Maybe supporting beams or something to spruce it up?
-None of the new items (golf club/M60/explosive barrel)
-Not enough people are playing this yet :(

Conclusion:

Let's start by saying this is the best custom campaign I've ever played. It's quality worthy of Valve.

First off, the campaign is long (45-60 min on normal), but due to the varied locations (from a sewer, to a hotel, to a football stadium all in a few minutes) it never gets boring. All these locations are incredibly detailed. Not just because it has a lot of props and decals to spruce it up, but also because you've gone to great lengths to make everything look realistic. Roads and alleys (like most other maps) don't start where the player enters and end where the player exits, but they go on in the opposite direction for a little while. This makes everything look more like real-life. Yet these alternate directions don't cause any real confusion as the direction signs and cues are very clear. Overall the game flow is pretty great. If you're meet little opposition you'll move through the level as if you were a Navy SEAL but once the opposition increases you have good defensive positions everywhere.

The atmosphere in this campaign is incredible. The already mentioned locations and details, but also the lighting, the special effects (the surprise explosion, the jets overhead) and the custom sounds and models/textures (the movie theatre statue :D) help to sell this campaign as something completly new (even though the gameplay is very familiar). The survivor speech is amazing. They have something appropriate to say about everything, even the things we've never seen before.

I'm giving you a 100/100 even though there are a few cons. I know you'll fix them and even with them it's already the best custom campaign I've ever played. You should've been the one to make the first official fan campaign for Valve. This campaign is the complete opposite of the unimaginative Cold Stream. That only had a few WOW moments. Suicide Blitz 2 is one big WOW!

Pros:

- Best atmosphere in a custom map I've ever seen. Everything works. The rain, the lighting. Perfect
- Great detailing. The suitcase with supplies, the games you need to play to start the round, etc.
- It's huge.
- Beautiful custom textures and models.

Cons:

- In the back of The Highball there's a door that opens to a closet of sorts. AI can't close that door andthus  get stuck there.
-The brightly colored building in the middle of the parking lot isn't open so you can't fight in it. Which is a shame.

Conclusion:

I want to visit this in real-life, that's how awesome this map is.

Pros:

- Great variety in level design
- Great variety in level design (different kinds of crescendos)
- Great custom models & sounds
- Good atmosphere

Cons:

- Some of the brushwork is too blocky (the custom sofas, mall fountain and the paths in the park)
- AI isn't too great
- No subtitling for the custom voices

Conclusion:

This is one of the greatest campaigns for L4D1 (hopefully L4D2 as well in the future *fingers crossed*). Great fun, even with bots! Kudos for the amount of work put into this.

Pros:

- 3/4 of EP1 + zombies = WIN
- The 'thing' that your replaced the gunship with is awesome
- Good work updating the EP1 world to look L4D2-ish. Except for the Eastern-European style architecture this could fit straight into the L4D universe

Cons:

- In the parking structure there should be a crescendo event where you have to open the gate with the wheel, like in EP1
- The finale could use some tweaking (ex. difficult to get out of the track on the left)
- Not for L4D2 :(

Conclusion:

One of the greatest campaigns out there. Well you had a little help from Valve but what you did is still a great accomplishment. Remake this for L4D2 please.

Pros:

- Authentic Doom look
- Decent gameplay

Cons:

- Lighting needs to be improved

Conclusion:

A good map. All we need is more of these maps.

Pros:

- A wide variety of places to make a stand and due to the map's size it's actually possible to move around between those places. Most survival maps are find-a-place-and-stay-there-or-you-die, which I don't like.

- The gameplay is wavier. Let me explain. Most survival maps are small. Which means that whatever zombies appear, they appear very near to you. Here you get waves of zombies and specials. Especially on the roof. This gives you a few brief moments to patch up  or resupply. The intensity of survival is kept but it's a bit easier to survive longer. As I said, I don't like 2 minute games. 10 minutes is much more fun.

- The design is top notch, both in looks and gameflow.

- The places to drop back into the cinema lobby are an excellent addition. Drop down and take damage or let my buddy down there potentially die?

Cons:

- The roof is not a friend of Survivor AI. Too  many AI fall off the ledges. Keep them off there. Let the players snipe on the ledges.

- Too few access points to the roof, both for survivors and infected.

- The ventilation shaft is exploitable.

Conclusion:

The best survival map for L4D2 at the moment. And I mean both official and fan-made. Looks great, plays great. I'm a big fan of sandbox survival maps. In that respect it's reminiscent of the Helm's Deep map for L4D1 only better in every way.

I had an idea once for a L4D2 map (nothing came of it, I'm not good enough yet for such a massive undertaking). It was set in a large mall. There were no ammo dumps only partially loaded weapons/items randomly spawning in the map. So players would have to move around the map, into shops, through service corridors, etc. to get new supplies. Mobile survival as you will. This map can easily be transformed into this kind of gamemode. Basic guns at spawn and random caches in places such as the weapon store or the roof, etc. Give it some thought, I think it would make this a one of a kind map. Ofcourse the standard survival map as it is now should also be kept as it's already pretty epic.