Pros:

• Cool loading poster (+0.5 bonus)
• Music (+0.2 env)
• Fantastic idea and environment (+3.0 env)
• Good size for a survival map with plenty of supplies(+1.0 gameplay)
• Not much problems with navigation file (+3.9 gameplay)
• Fantastic layout and bridge structure (+2.0 env)
• Good soundscape (+0.5 env)

Cons:

• When doing a local server without even starting the survival , my ping was around 200... (-0,since it can be my fault)
• Sometimes bots can get stuck on some places; on a washer prop , crouching under a bus at the broken part of the bridge (-0.4)

Conclusion:

A fantastic map with lots of space to survive and cool features. very good 3D skybox. The bridge's structure is awesome , including the broken part. I really enjoyed this map. Looks like i need a new way of making a review , because this map got over 10 points in my opinion...

• Environment: 5.7 - 0.0 = 5.7 /Nice environment , has a very realistic feeling and awesome layout. Did not see any negative points.
• Gameplay: 4.9 - 0.4 = 4.5 /Good and fun gameplay. In some occasions , bots can get stuck but it surely is not prohibiting the gameplay. Zombie behavior was fine and no problems detected.
• Bonus: 0.5 /Bonus are good points that can't be taken away by anything because they have nothing to do with the environment or gameplay about the map.

Pros:

• Resource system , you have to collect resource to buy something (+3.0 gameplay)
• Interesting mechanics (+1.5 gameplay)
• The environment is a nice idea (+1.5 env)
• Not endless hordes

Cons:

• FPS Lagg. Had to turn down settings for just this map. (-0.4 gameplay)
• Fog color is weird comparing with the skybox and 3D skybox. (-0.2 env)
• SI sometimes are stuck in the window of the burger tank (-0.2 gameplay)
• for some reason i had no music when a tank came (-0.2 env)

Conclusion:

Was a bit confusing at the start , but i found it out.
In my opinion , the most thing that bothers me in this map was that it's totally boring. You are locked off from everything else , and you just have a simple relative big square you can play in. You only have to research some resources , buy some vehicles for items and weapons and the escaping train , which was interesting. Overall , a simple map with fun gameplay.

Gameplay: 4.5 - 0.6 = 3.9 / Interesting system and gameplay , lots of features.
Environment: 1.5 - 0.4 = 1.1 / No visual fun , just an simple environment with some interesting features such as the smoke. 

Pros:

• A nice and fitting idea for an campaign edit. (+5.0)
• New objects and small areas. (+2.5)
• A new waypoint on map 4. (+2.5)

Cons:

• original loading poster from the parish (-0 , Doesn't breaks down environment and gameplay)

Conclusion:

This is a very interesting campaign edit. Would recommend to everyone who likes playing the original parish.
The cons and pros are based on what's edited and not on what's from the original parish.

Pros:

+Nice beginning , saferoom , survivors talking , ect
+Very nice atmosphere , personally i don't play much dark maps but i really enjoyed this one.
+Not too much zombies , not too less zombies. 
+ Nice way on building the car and searching the parts for it

Cons:

-personally , i would like some generators that give light and maybe turn off after a certain amount of time. Then you have to restart the generator. Because the place where you build the car is a bit very dark. (-0 since something personal)
-The map was very fun untill the ending music suddenly started and we got swarmed by tanks (-0.5)

Conclusion:

This map was one of the best LB maps i have played yet , and sure was fun with bots. However , the whole game was ruined because of tanks coming non-stop and the ending music starting. (going to play again later to see if this is fixed , will update review)

Anyway , i thought of a new way to review maps ...
Environment/Atmosphere... 5.0 : Really dark , nice environment , looks official to me
Gameplay... 4.5 : Let's Build map where you can and have to move around much , the car build thing looks good , good layout and idea on how to collect parts for the car , can loot dead bodys

Pros:

+Custom musics
+Nice environment
+Button to turn of music if people want to turn it off
+Great idea on the map
+Cool ways on opening new areas
+SI are good on this map
+Fixed the crashing for me
+Has Versus

Cons:

-What... Bots just jumped and killed theirselves :O except for 1 bot
-still laggy when i was looking down , turned off my shader which fixed most of the lagg.
-Killing a tank is difficult with only having a pistol, but the custom music was fitting the deadly event.
-No idea what to do besides researching weapons. I assume turn those wheels? (explenation came after i died in the map)
-bots teleport near the tech-tree and have trouble getting on the raised grounds. they also get stuck getting in front of the tech-tree and receive massive damage.
-Once that gate opened (kinda forgot how i did it) the techtree was gone. I turned the wheel inside there , i knew an new area came available. Just did not knew what area and where it was.
-Too difficult on easy with bots , i died soo much times after the first 10 minutes.

Conclusion:

I never managed to finish this map at all on easy with bots. It was possible on the original LBAR map.
This has a very nice environment and gameplay , full of ideas and new stuff.
Main thing that is annoying on this map , is not knowing of what to do. I had to restart a couple times to find out what to do next because i kept dieng. After the third time i got a bit bored and quit. 
also , the bots are a bit annoying. (getting stuck near the tech-tree , not moving and getting swarmed by the zombies)
Personally , i'd rather give some hints... Such as turning a wheel near the tech-tree in start which gives a glow to one of those 3 wheels for 5-10 Seconds.
Didn't made much reviews and such , but this map looks awesome and has nice ideas and features in it.

Pros:

==map1 (coast)==
+ liked the environment
+ good size for a survival map
+ have to watch your step in darkness so you won't fall to your death
Rate: 7.0

==map 2 (docks)==
+ the docks where you spawn looks nice
+ nice idea on how to start the survival
+ fairly large and different spots to hold out (streets,garage,docks)
Rate: 7.5

==map 3 (pool)==
+ we won't actually die from touching the water whit our feet
+ nice idea on starting the survival
+ broken part where only zombies can get trough
Rate:7.5

Cons:

==map1 (coast)==
- not much supplies
- should've have more ways to spawn zombies around

==map2 (docks)==
- not much detail
- the fog in 3d skybox (or the towers far away) doesn't really fit
- searching the start button took longer than surviving <_> (but found it)

==map3 (pool)==
- Not much detail
- kinda small , but good
~ bots jumped in the pool , drowning and didn't feel like going out of it , kinda funny lol

Conclusion:

(this has been my first review yet, sorry if it ate a bit of ur scrollbar)
conclusion map1: Rated 7.0
I liked the map, the darkness also fitted. size is good , had fun playing this.

conclusion map2: Rated 7.5
 i also liked this map , alltough took a while to actually be able to start the survival. 
glad to have played this map , just preferred more detail. (but thats just me)

conclusion map3: Rated 7.5
liked this map. most favorite in the survival pack , only kinda small.

full conclusion:
I had fun playing these 3 maps , alltought hey didnt had much detail. didn't had much guns either , but there were enough. Sad i couldn't play it whit other people , but bots are... uhm, ... "nearly" the same...