Pros:

Nice level design
Nice events
Good NAV
Possible to escape on finale

Cons:

Author should add some props on places, where survivors can't go due to invisible walls
Should add some hints all around the maps (especially, map 2, where you should go through a wagon and burn cans)
Add more melee weapons on 1st map
Remake rocks in water (1st map), because they're unwalkable (you're inside them)

Conclusion:

Nicely done campaign, I love it. You've made my day, Sir!

Pros:

NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE NICE

Cons:

Are you kidding me??

Conclusion:

I'm such a lover of campaigns by famous level designers like You, Kev! And again, You've made my day! 10/10

Pros:

Health counters
IDLE icon, when teammate is afk
Your nickname under health bar

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Now you don't need to ask your teammate, how many health he has. Done perfectly, thanks

Pros:

Posters now looks way better, than Valve's
HD pictures
Backgrounds for pictures are awesome choosen (for example, Death Toll's black/grey wall looks nice with this poster)

Cons:

Blood Harvest should be on white wall, where now is hanging Dark Carnival's poster (if you look carefuly, you can see, that behind DC poster's is a piece of BH poster)
Dead Air is behind the Dead Center poster's
Death Toll is behind the Hard Rain poster's

Conclusion:

As you can see, there is 3 cons, but really I don't care. Your work deserves 10/10 and these 3 posters are placed nice. Thanks

Pros:

Nice skin
Very detailed
HD quality
Looks interesting

Cons:

HUD icon is standart (magnum) (-0.2)
Very fast reloading, so it looks not so natural (-0.2)
Standart Sound (-0.1)

Conclusion:

Nice mod. Something new in the game (not standart uninteresting magnum). 9.5/10

Pros:

Nice design
Interesting walktrough
Events, which are placed all around the campaign (better weapon event for example)

Cons:

A lack of weapons on 1st map at the start (-1)
Argh! The finale. It was a little bit boring (but something new to the all finales that i've seen before) (-0.5)
Too much chargers and spitters in small rooms, tunels etc (-0.5)

Conclusion:

This campaign is good, but not IDEAL. Thanks for author's work. Respect

Pros:

HD Textures
Nice design
Nice colour
Not too bright, like original Valve's pills

Cons:

None at all

Conclusion:

Grabbing pills.

Pros:

HD Textures
Original colour

Cons:

Vomit is too colorful so it looks like acid

Conclusion:

Great reskin of bile jar. I like it

Pros:

Nice skin
Looks realistic

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Good idea to replace uninteresting valve's molotov with a bottle of Heineken. Nice job, m8.

Pros:

Nice skin
Realy similar with original guitar
Awesome colour
Looks great on the "Dark Carnival's" finale

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Great work, so thank you very much! It's more better, than the valve's guitar.

Pros:

Awesome custom music
Awesome level design
Great atmosphere
Nice events
Animal presence (I've never heard an animal at other campaigns)

Cons:

Too many witches at the first level
Planks, that are real problem for bots

Conclusion:

I think this campaign deserves only 10/10. Respect

Pros:

Horror atmosphere
Easter Egg
Nice tank skin
Very big campaign
Great finale

Cons:

Hmm.... i think i don't have them :)

Conclusion:

One of the awesomest campaigns i ever played. Even better, than some Valve campaigns. Respect

Pros:

Great enviroment
Nice tank skin
Interesting walktrough
Nice poster

Cons:

Bots sometimes stuck at the second map on a ladder

Conclusion:

This map is awesome! If someone haven't played this map before, download it now!