Pros:

- nicely done recreation of the real Disneyland, lots of new models
- fun and well executed ideas like a usable ride
- interesting finale

Cons:

- no challenge at all, rather boring gameplay
- visual quality is often lacking
- finding your way around the maps can be difficult at times

Conclusion:

This campaign is hard to rate. If you've ever been to Disneyland when you were a child the nostalgic feelings alone will probably be enough to give it a 10. Personally I've never been there (I'm from Europe so it would take a lot of effort to get there), but I googled pictures of the real Disneyland and the author obviously put a lot of effort into recreating as many of the buildings and attractions as possible. But that's not the only thing that is good about this campaign, there are also fun ideas like a ride you can actually use and a finale that is not just a copy of the original L4D2 finales. 

Unfortunately there are also bad things to say about the campaign. First of all there is the lack of challenge. You can walk through the map, shoot a few zombies left and right and you'll never get hurt since there aren't enough zombies. Additionally there are only very few horde events (and no random horde events as far as I could see) and even those are very easy to master. This is by far the easiest map I've ever played for sure, the only difficulty setting worth playing is expert, which is similar to normal in other campaigns. Then there is the graphics quality. The overall attention to detail is great, but the textures and models often look flat and blocky. Don't get me wrong, it is still quite the achievement to create so many models that look close to their original counterparts. But the quality often isn't the best, even by L4D2 standards. Finally it can be quite difficult to find the correct path to proceed. The maps are pretty large and often you have to enter a small door that is hard to spot to exit an area when there are lots of attractions with huge entrances around you (which would be the more obvious path, but almost always turn out to be dead ends).

It's definitely worth a playthrough, and certainly a no-brainer if you've been to the real Disneyland already. But in its current state the gameplay of the campaign is quite boring and I wouldn't want to play it very often (and only on expert difficulty). I will come back and give the campaign a better rating if the author improves the gameplay.

Pros:

- fantastic gameplay
- great ideas
- very polished
- perfect length

Cons:

- visuals are nice (they fit with the theme), but could be a bit more detailed
- bots tend to kill themselves in some areas

Conclusion:

What a fantastic campaign! I've played it several times now and it is still a lot of fun. Perfectly balanced, fun ideas, simply fun to play and quite different from any of the regular campaigns. Much better than the first campaign (Questionable Ethics) as well, which was great already, but felt a bit rough around the edges to me. Only the rather simple visuals (which fit, but could still use some more details imo) and the hope for a third, even better campaign make me rate this 9.9 instead of 10. Thanks!

Pros:

- nice, professionally done visuals
 - great implementation of the car repair system
 - balanced difficulty

Cons:

- some car parts are very hard to find
- building defenses is not as necessary as it should be

Conclusion:

A high quality map that deserves a higher rating imo. The car repair system was really well implemented and the map looks like it could have been in the original game. Building defenses is not as necessary as it should be in a 'let's build' map though. Personally I didn't manage to find all the car parts, there was one small part left that I missed. I tried for 15+ minutes to find it, then I was too annoyed by the constant zombie attacks and quit.

After playing the map with someone who knew where all the parts are (on advanced) I must say it was a lot of fun. So I had to increase the rating from 9 to 9.5 (as I still think finding all the parts could be a bit easier even for first time players). 

Pros:

- finale was quite nice
- layout was ok
- some areas looked relatively nice

Cons:

- parts of map 1 are lacking detail and look unfinished
- maze in map 2 has no detail at all and gets repetitive and boring quickly
- tank spawned below elevator, getting stuck when we landed on it
- elevators can be used without all players inside, effectively killing those left behind
- finale area is too small, lots of obstacles you can get stuck on

Conclusion:

The campaign felt a little unfinished and rushed. Most areas were lacking detail, especially on map 2 - the rather boring maze was as basic as it can get (floor, ceiling and walls, nothing else). There were also some bugs, like a tank that spawned below an elevator or players getting stuck during the finale. The campaign was still ok for a single playthrough due to the relatively nice layout (mediocre, but not bad at least), but I wouldn't want to play it again. I don't like writing 'negative' reviews, but imo anything more than a rating of 5 would be unfair if you compare this campaign to the best custom campaigns for L4D2.

Still thank you for your effort!

Pros:

- the school has a really scary atmosphere
- good layout

Cons:

- some areas are lacking detail
- finale is more or less impossible in single player if played on harder difficulty and still annoying on easy/normal

Conclusion:

Despite its short length I really enjoyed this map. I love the slow pace in the school level, the atmosphere is really creepy. For a long time nothing happens and often you only hear the 'knock door' sound of the zombies and the screams of the special infected lurking somewhere. Probably the most scary atmosphere in any L4D map I've played so far. On the other hand the school level is quite easy to beat, the map is short (which is not a bad thing per se) and the finale is annoying if played with bots due to the long distance you need to carry the four cans (something bots can't do). Some areas have rather low detail and could be improved. 

If played online with human players this map is certainly a lot of fun though and I can only recommend it.

Pros:

- good overall quality
- no bugs I could find
- good length
- nicely balanced finale

Cons:

- some areas felt rather dull and were lacking detail (-0.5)

Conclusion:

A very enjoyable map I could play through without problems (both single and multiplayer). Some of the locations felt a bit empty and bland though. I liked the finale, when I played it mp we had a hard time surviving, but it wasn't impossible and not a thousand times harder than the rest of the campaign, like it is the case in many other campaigns (even some official ones). Turning the helipad lights on to make the chopper land sooner was a nice idea and added some flavor to the battle against the zombie horde.

Pros:

- unique atmosphere
- funny, 'scary' scripted sequences
- no bugs I could find
- good length
- nice layout

Cons:

- some of the models/textures look a bit cheap (-0.8)
- it's more a funny, have-a-good-time Halloween map and not really scary (no points removed since it's a matter of taste whether you like that or not)
- finale was a bit overkill and too long for what it is (zombies, more zombies, even more zombies, tank, millions of zombies, billions of zombies, argh!, -0.2)
- some ladders are extremely hard to see (no points removed since it's a minor issue that is only a problem during the first playthrough)

Conclusion:

A very entertaining and polished map with funny ideas. The visual quality is lacking in some parts though, the funny B-horror movie atmosphere may not be everyone's taste (I liked it though, generally a fan of not so serious maps and mods). The finale was a bit too much for my taste, the Parish bridge is a joke compared to the sea of zombies you'll be facing here. But overall highly recommended.

Pros:

- amazing visuals
- unique, Japanese themed atmosphere
- good length

Cons:

- some minor bugs (first safe room door opens with metal bar still in place, area in level 4 blocked by an invisible barrier and some other things)
- after repairing the cable car generator I didn't know I had to go to the safe room, especially since the cable car door was still lit up as if it was your target objective
- finale could be prepared (collecting cans before calling for rescue) and was too easy in that case

Conclusion:

Possibly the most unique quality map I've played so far. Really great visuals and atmosphere with a lot of attention to detail. Only the few small bugs, the exploitable finale and the confusion during the 2nd cable car part (where I thought the bots got bugged since they didn't follow me into the cable car) make me give it 9.9 instead of 10. Thanks!