Pros:

- Good amount of throwables/health items.
- Thats about it

Cons:

- Almost nonstop hordes
- Too easy to get turned around
- Stretched textures
- Everything about the finale
- Everything else in general
- Too many panic events
- Survivors often made comments about things that didn't have anything to do with the current objective.

Conclusion:

This has to be one of the authors first campaigns, and if it isn't, Ill be checking his others to make sure I dont accidentally download it.  The concept was a good idea but overall it was a horrible experience.

There was way too many green things/panic events, not to mention almost non-stop hordes which lead to very little exploration, which is a major deal for me and my group.

By map 3 we were just trying to rush to finish the campaign.  Oh yeah, the finale...since you painted everything else in the campaign with a green glow why didnt you make virgils boat green?  Would have been nice since we were looking around for our next green objective.

Pros:

- Plenty of supplies on most maps
- Lots of detail

Cons:

- Some area scaled horribly, came across a residential door that was 10 feet high
- Unnecessary Intro map, 2nd map loaded and I was at 28 health from a tank that insta spawned while I was still loading.
- Severe lack of explorable areas...plenty of doors, none of them opens
- Map 3 had a severe lack of weapons, me and my friends were without weapons/ammo for over half the map.
- Floating railroad tracks on map 3
- Areas clipped with no barriers

Conclusion:

Not a bad campaign, Im more of an explorer then anything so the strictly linear path kinda got on my nerves, add some side rooms or something, the College has tons of side rooms but theyre all locked.

Pros:

- Well designed areas/high detail in most parts
- Car pushing was an annoying but new thing
- Had that "apocalypse" feel
- Map 1 had one of the most realistic apartments Ive ever seen.

Cons:

- Custom narrative was too low and too monotone, during a rescue attempt in a zombie apocalypse you'd be high on adrenaline.
- 2 tanks spawning right in your face on a crescendo is not fun, Im not a fan of restarting an entire map over stupid stuff.
- Some untextured walls
- Severe lack of explorable areas, many doors were just static when we should have been able to go through.
- Some oddball things, such as a flimsy table against the saferoom door, or sandbags deep in the sewers...who would have carried 20 sandbags that far?  Probably something no one would ever think about but it breaks immersion for me.

Conclusion:

Decent campaign, if it wasnt for the two tanks that spawned right in your face it would have received a much higher rating...the first tank I was somewhat expecting, the second one was a scripted spawn right in my friends face as he was entering the saferoom, insta-incap and had to restart a long and tedious map.

Pros:

- Interesting concept I guess

Cons:

- Everything, glitches out the butt.
- No direction whatsoever on what to do.

Conclusion:

This map is completely broken, Im not sure what the goal was here or how other people managed to get it working, but whatever it was it did not work.  Check my short gameplay in the Video section, this is a fresh install, Ive never played this map before.

It is Alpha so Ill re-submit my review after these bugs are fixed with a more appropriate score.

Pros:

-Great atmosphere
-Original finale
-Custom melees

Cons:

-Finale a bit too easy
-Kinda disappointed on the sacrifice, but nice touch, no points off
-Witches was a put-off last time I played it

Conclusion:

Revising my review from a 3 to a 9, finally finished it...6 months later haha, great campaign.

Pros:

- 'Noob mappers' as yourselves actually finishing a campaign, even if it is full of glitches
-Interesting use of clipping

Cons:

- Broken second map...if you die, it repawns you in the saferoom
- Broken finale, I fell out of the helicopter
- Crash Course vehicle glitching through the map
- A ton of other graphical glitches
- Tank in the elevator with no indication

Conclusion:

Considering youre a new mapper, a shouldnt be based on map design, but on your skill level...having only about 100 hours of mapping myself I know how hard mapping can actually be)unlike probably all these other reviewers).

I did have fun with the campaign...it was actually quite refreshing to play a campaign with some 'features' for once rather then a dead serious campaign that offers gauntlet after gauntlet(which is FAIL in my opinion)

Good job for your first campaign, it was actually more fun then a lot of other campaigns Ive played that had 8-9 ratings.

Pros:

- Lots of detail
- Compatibility for many gamemodes

Cons:

- You can really tell it was designed for versus
- Computer parts was completely ridiculous
- Repetitive game play
- Finale was bad
- Way too many gauntlets
- Intro sequence broken

Conclusion:

The biggest mistake a map creator can make is think 'MORE ZOMBIES = MORE FUN!' which is definitely not the case....a campaign must be immersive to be fun, and although this campaign had a LOT of detail, most of it was just overlooked by the ridiculous amount of zombies...I had almost as many general kills on the first map then I do regular expert campaigns on the end-of-game stats crawl.

Definitely wasnt fun, and definitely wont play again.

Pros:

- Very fun campaign
- All panic events are optional
- Does not rely on massive amounts of zombies
- Maps were perfect sizes

Cons:

- Bridge didnt turn all the way around...not a big deal to me really since we have sourcemod, but people playing co-op without SM may have this problem.

Conclusion:

Very fun campaign, great atmosphere and nice and clean large maps...but not too large you get bored. I'll def. be recommending this to others.

Ill be submitting an LP here in a few hours.

Pros:

+ Concept of the finale was good but the execution was horrible

+Starting under the bridge on Map 3 then ended up on top

Cons:

- Map 3 framerate issue
- Missing textures
- Finale was bad
- Hardly any detail, linear
- On map 1 garage button and radio served absolutely no purpose
- Untextured outtro picture
- Railroad textures on finale is uneven
- You can run ahead of the train and finish the finale without killing any zombies or tanks
- If a survivor gets incapped on the train it will glitch and 'run over' the survivor, killing him

Conclusion:

Has potential, needs a lot of work though.

Pros:

+ Looks soooo much better then Rochelle.
+ Lobby graphics
+ In-game/incap graphics
+ Fluid movement

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

The best Rochelle skin Ive seen, and distracting...in a good way.

Pros:

+ Comic relief when L4D2 glitches make you mad.

Cons:

- None, the animation glitches just adds to the comic relief, which is what this mod was intended to do.

Conclusion:

Great mod, get it to replace Rofail

Pros:

- Great skin
- Great effects and particles

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

This is possibly the best charger skin ever, I love it!

Pros:

- Creative
- Very unique

Cons:

- Very repetitive
- Glitchy in a lot of spots

Conclusion:

Didnt really enjoy it, backtracking is a lazy mans way of making a campaign longer, and its just annoying. Ended up quitting on the third map because it got so annoying.

Pros:

- Great campaign
- Immense amount of detail
- Smooth realistic flow of levels
- Cave system was AWESOME

Cons:

- Finale is a bit much for expert gameplay, but good nonetheless
- 2 instances of crashing-to-desktop on map 3, I know it wasnt your fault, but it was annoying, no points taken off for this
- Ellis was the only one that was able to flip the tractor switch for some reason
- I got caught on fire beside a train car on the....3rd or 4th map, and there was no fire anywhere around me...it was at the end of the area with the big fire pit

Conclusion:

In conclusion it was a great campaign, and a lot of new stuff I didnt see on the last update!

Pros:

- Funny watching kermit light infected up with an uzi
- Decent skin
- Decent model

Cons:

-Animations are a bit off, but makes it funny, no points taken off

Conclusion:

So much better then looking at Ellis, now if only we could change the Ellis stories...lol

Pros:

- Great attention to detail
- Looks amazing

Cons:

- Absolutely none

Conclusion:

A great change to a great gun, I love the SPAS, and Fluttershy is my favorite, so these 2 together means GREATEST GAMES EVER.

Pros:

-First few maps were decent size
-Great level of detail

Cons:

Keep in mind all of these are constructive and only serves as suggestions.

-Menu didnt have capitalized names(one did)...something like this I knew the campaign was going to have a bunch of bugs.
-Counter had transparent end player could see through
-Choppy clips
-Found unintended shortcuts throughout
-Crashed nonstop on map 3
-Panic event right out the saferoom on map 1
-Panic event on map 4 with no warning
-SEVERE FPS loss on last 2 maps, went from 45-55 down to 10...even dropping to minimum settings didnt help.
-Multiple missing textures
-Finale was too large for a scavenge, clearly made for versus, which is fail..no balance for co-op players.
-Gas falls into the water off of cliff
-You should never be insta-death-charged after starting the finale
-Saferoom music did not fit the campaign at all

Conclusion:

Started out great, then after map 3 it just started going down hill, me and the guys I play with has a combined time of over 3000 hours in expert gameplay and the finale was complete fail...campaigns that are built for versus are blatantly obvious and this is one of those campaigns.

I have absolutely no idea where this campaign deserves a 90 considering the amount of amateur mistakes that even a simple playthrough with a pen and paper could have fixed.

Pros:

-Puzzles were fun and challenging, and was not impossible to solve.
-The finale/ending scene was great.
-The gas can exchange system was very cool.
-Really achieved its goal of being a puzzle map.

Cons:

-Basically the same assortment of weapons throughout...it did have every weapon, but the campaign weighed heavily in the favor of  T1 shotguns
-Floating traincars being able to move caused serious glitches with survivors hanging on edges, eventually led to falling.

Conclusion:

The campaign was clearly built as a puzzle map, so scenery and such didnt need to be there, it was a well thought-out puzzle campaign that had me and my group laughing, making jokes, challenging each other to races(hanging train cars anyone?)

It was extremely easy to fall, but, that was the point, closets were always near-by afterwards, so the designer clearly planned and test played this campaign, unlike a lot of other Ive seen(Example: Cold Stream)

One of the best custom campaigns Ive ever played, I will keep this one in my addons.

Pros:

-Great port
-Scavenge was actually fun for once
-Plenty of gamemodes to play
-Extremely fun in versus with new SI

Cons:

-None that I experienced

Conclusion:

This is my favorite campaign on L4D1, and being able to play it on L4D2 is awesome! No errors or anything that I saw, flawless port, great job!