Pros:

Amazing colors, locales, architecture, and  geography.
Great sense of humor throughout.
Details, details, details.
The rhythm of the whole thing was spot-on.

Cons:

This thing needs to be like 8 maps long and take the better part of a day to finish. Was too short for me and my friends.

Conclusion:

Truly a thing of beauty, with all-encompassing details, refreshing variety, and a great mood. 
It's a shame that nobody plays vs. on custom maps, because this thing is a monster in coop. Can't imagine it in vs. 
Stellar job. Hats off.

Pros:

degree of detail and thoughtfulness was a delight.
all of the accompanying add-ons make it a complete experience.
lots of fun with friends who know minecraft.

Cons:

could be a little longer to complete the immersion.

Conclusion:

hell of a lot of fun, and some great laughs along the way. nice work