Pros:

+ Fawesome
+ Movie soundtrack plays!!!
+ The map isn't built exactly like the movie's set, but it works perfectly for the gameplay!
+ Little things like distinct corpse placements and recognizable props help increase the nostalgia factor!

Cons:

- No Tarman!?

Conclusion:

It's Return of the Living Dead, the best zombie movie ever made, turned into a map for one of the best zombie games ever made. Yes!

Pros:

- Cool splitting up the team in the beginning.
- Love the multiple paths and backtracking. Playing through a map twice can yield very different results.
- Has a dark eerie tone to it.
- Interesting and creative crescendo events.
- Maps are filled with detail and can seem lengthy, but in the best way.
- Awesome finale but...

Cons:

Finale Cons
---------------

-The jump from dark, danky maps to a bright, snow-covered, windy mountain seemed too much. Maybe foreshadowing that you're going to a snow covered mountain or having a little snow in the earlier maps would help make the transition easier.
- WAY TOO MANY Special Infected. I played the map MANY times (because of death :P) and the Special Infected were constantly spawning in threes, with hardly 5-10 seconds between. That coupled with your huge hordes made regrouping almost impossible to do, which is not good when you have to cover so much ground.
- I feel that giving the player more of a chance to explore the map before spawning tanks and hordes would be nice. Right out of the elevator you're attacked, all the way to the top. When you don't give people a chance to explore, it makes surviving MUCH harder. The first couple times I didn't know where any ammo, health, or guns were, so I died very quickly.
- The sacrifice finale was an odd choice. Upon fixing the generator pulley thingy, we had to wait for the lift to rise. When it did come up, Zoey (a bot) walked into it and everyone else was instantly downed and marked in the credits as dead. I don't understand why we all died, and I don't understand why we needed two or more people to survive the finale. Please fix this issue, if nothing else, because it just seems illogical.


And some general cons:
- The map's name, and ESPECIALLY it's slogan, don't fit. The slogan doesn't even make sense, I don't know what 'Less Harder They Fall' is supposed to mean. Does that mean 'Less Taller They Are'? Are you calling Francis or the mountain short :P?
- The second map's train crescendo was odd. The navigator told me to shoot the box that's making the sound, but it took MULTIPLE CLIPS from an assault rifle just to break it. I thought I was doing something wrong because it said to shoot it but it just wouldn't break. I was very hesitant to keep shooting because I was in the middle of a zombie horde and it seemed like a bad time to 'waste' ammo.
- On the second map, while exploring for where to go, I ran into several invisible walls that broke immersion. Try to make the river impossible to cross and cars unable to be climbed, otherwise these invisible walls will be evident.

Conclusion:

As weird as the finale is, the campaign as a whole is fantastic. It stands out from the rest and should be enjoyed my everyone who loves custom campaigns. Great work, and I can't wait for the final release!

Pros:

- 4 maps were long and detailed
- loved finding fuses in the first map. Gives the player an excuse to explore.
- first map also reminded me of Dead Rising 1's mall
- lots of zombies to kill. Lots.
- very gritty and dark feel to the map. Great scary vibe!
- you can tell that a lot of time went into making these maps, just by the variety in layout alone.

Cons:

- on the third and forth maps, I had spawning issues. On the third one I spawned inside a wall that was between the saferoom and the stock room. On the fourth map three members of our team started off OUTSIDE the first wall that need to be blown up.
- on the fourth map it wasn't entirely clear that you were supposed to use the explosives on the walls. There was no white outline or explanation.
- on the first and some of the second maps, there are a lot of metal detectors. It's not practical to have METAL detectors in every store, since stores don't actually have metal detectors. I would change it so that there is one set of metal detectors or one trip of an alarm that doesn't stop until you find the fuses. That way you have a constant (but not ridiculous) horde that puts the pressure on. Metal detectors are in airports, not malls.
- the ending is HORRIBLE. My team gets through the door and we're running to escape, and the screen just blacks out with no sign of IF we escaped, HOW we escaped, and WHERE the escape was. Fix this, if nothing else!

Conclusion:

This is a fantastic campaign, but it's too buggy to receive a 9 and the ending is pitiful. Fix it up and you have a very memorable and iconic campaign!

Pros:

+ Cool environment. Cabin in the woods is creepy and the swamp adds danger to navigating the forest.
+ Lots of Special Infected, which sounds like a minus but is actually really fun. Smokers are scary as hell in the forest.
+ Map is big enough, it doesn't waste space just for the sake of wasting space. You won't get lost easily which is good for a survival map.
+ Actually room to breathe every once in a while.
+ Lots of throwables.

Cons:

- I only saw the auto-shotgun and auto-sniper, pistols, and an axe as weapons. While it's not realistic to have any more than that, it is unfortunate you can't get an assault rifle.
- One of my bots got stuck at the helicopter crash. Just wouldn't move.

Conclusion:

Overall this is a pretty cool map. It's a solid survival map which gives an eerie vibe and the foilage and swamp adds extra danger to the mix. There's nothing wrong with it, but it didn't knock my socks off with detail either.  My critique would be to add an assault rifle somewhere and maybe add another area besides the cabin and heli-crash. Great job!

Pros:

+ Awesome attention to detail and varied environments
+ Maps are long enough to create a challenge but not too long
+ Some areas have so much atmosphere, like the railroad lined with mutilated bodies or the school hallway with 2 witches.
+ You guys are so cool for putting those awesome posters in the theater! ROTLD FTW!!!
+ You're panic events where varied and fit the maps. I especially liked the theater event and the supply truck event.
+ Ammo and supplies seemed to be well placed.
+ Multiple paths to reach your objectives.

Cons:

- World models on guns were custom but first person models are fixed to valve's? I like to have the option to have addons.
- My bots (while using Improved Bots mod) would get stuck at the supply truck event because they would teleport ahead of the truck instead of waiting inside it? No points taken for this.
- The finale seemed very easy for me on normal. Gathering the samples was simple enough and then I just waited near the field goal post till rescue.
- Why is there C4 in a theater?
- Theater event was slightly confusing with the axe being used twice. I got a rather brutal beating even on normal trying to get through the horde in that small area.

Conclusion:

Overall, this is a terrific campaign well worth the wait. It's atmosphere and level design are well thought out, and I'll be playing this fora long time. My cons aren't going to keep me from enjoying this campaign, but if you get around to fixing some that'd be appreciated. As for infini-hordes, I'm not sure I noticed this as much as other people. Then again I played on normal so it's easy not to care when you're practically invincible. Great job on the campaign and I hope to see more work from you guys.

Pros:

+ Direct continuation of the first campaign.
+ Detail put into all the maps is ridiculous. You must have spent hours on all the small details!
+ The maps are very well paced, and the third level in particular put me in awe with the scale of the level.
+ You included the l4d2 characters and even some tf2 characters. Very cool.
+ Good amount of tanks and witches, supplies were well placed and not to plentiful.

Cons:

- I was missing some sort of effect texture on the fourth level at the gate just before the end. It read "Start the Generator! Stand the Horde! Wait for Text Button!" It just appeared as a large cube of the black and purple texture.
- Ending was depressing lol 

Conclusion:

The cons I gave are honestly meaningless to me because you've managed to make one of the best custom campaigns for left 4 dead 2, ever. Congrats and I hope to see more from you. I'll be waiting!

Pros:

- Very detailed environments, specifically the city streets
- A solid challenge but still fun
- Atmosphere is very eerie (screams l4d1)

Cons:

- finale is a little bland and long
- l4d2 survivors don't feel natural in this campaign

Conclusion:

One of my favorite campaigns of all time. Should be an official campaign imo. Really wish that you would have used the l4d1 survivors though, but that is a minor gripe. Good job!

Pros:

-Numerous surroundings keep the campaign fresh throughout
-Tank, ammo, health, etc. placements were well thought out and helped the experience
-Overall detail of the maps are simply outstanding! Valve is jealous!
-Maps were challenging and long, but are certainly possible to beat on hard difficulties. 

Cons:

-Sometimes the bots seemed to not know where to go. AT one point they couldn't proceed through the map without spawning.
-Evac vehicle doesn't like the bots either :(
-Lack of direction in the finale made figuring out what to do difficult
-Missing textures and error signs (?)

Conclusion:

I give you a 95 despite these cons simply for the OUTSTANDING vivid detail and BRILLIANT charting of the maps! Every map is fun and a joy to play, and they all provide a perfect balance of difficulty. The bots are a slight problem. At the end of the 4th level my bots refused to enter a cabin used to get to the safe room. After about 5 minutes of turning a blind eye they finally spawned inside. Also, I'm not sure if this is because I installed custom content or it's your maps, but I am missing textures and see ERROR objects all over the final level.

 PLEASE, if anyone is looking for a FUN and AWESOME campaign, CLICK DOWNLOAD NOW.