Pros:

- Perfectly-designed maps.
- Like an alternate "Blood Harvest".
- Very good survivor dialogues (various and new).
- Original finale (escaping with a train, original compared to official campaigns).
- Great intro and outro cutscenes.
- No nav problem.
- Custom music.
- Custom graffitis.
- Custom weapons.

Cons:

- Seriously? I can't find any.

Conclusion:

Perfect campaign, really, it's just perfect. The cons from my previous review were fixed, and more awesome/custom stuff was added, so I can only give it a 99/100 :)

Why not 100/100? Maybe because of the not very original locations? Anyway, it's hard to complain about anything.

Pros:

- Original events are very well used (shooting in moving vehicles and scavenge, and the hero part was a wonderful idea).
- Big maps, well designed.
- Fifth survivor (the driver, even though he is never seen, only heard).
- No major Nav problem.

Cons:

- The maps lack details. It is not too bad, but it's not perfect at all.
- No survivor dialogue.
- Nav is also not perfect, but like the maps, good enough.

Conclusion:

This campaign is definetely worth the playing, but the author could fix a few details on the whole campaign, like adding more details or making Nav better. Don't worry, these two things certainly won't stop anyone from having fun.

Pros:

- Detailed and realistic maps. Incredible work on those.
- Custom events.
- Custom music.
- Survivor dialogues.
- Good nav.

Cons:

- The custom music just doesn't fit. It's good music, but it doesn't fit, especially in the  intro and saferooms.
- The survivor dialogues are too scarce and seem inapropriate too, much like the intro in Cold Stream: only a few random quotes put together.
- French graffitis... It's not important, and there's no problem for me since I speak French, but it may also seem unfitting.
- The finale may be too long, but I'm not sure about that.
- Missing textures in map 4. Gotta fix that ASAP.
- No storyline. It's not that important, but in every Valve campaign, the survivors go somewhere for a reason. Like in most custom campaigns and in this one, they just go because they have to and follow their path until they randomly find a rescue vehicle.
- The campaign seems to last a whole day, which is irrelevant.

Conclusion:

Great campaign, but I still can believe you can call it "complete". It certainly isn't. Unfortunately, there would be too much to change to make it "perfect", but it's still definetely worth playing, for the maps and events. This is one of the few campaigns I know that made me feel like I was playing a brand new official Valve campaign. Good job.

Pros:

(Updated review)

- Very well detailled.
- Realistic environment.
- Totally unique finale (police car, scavenge, etc.)
- This is a L4D1 campaign that uses a lot of models and materials from L4D2.
- Many custom textures (graffitis, posters, etc.)
- Daylight (too many L4D1 nighttime campaigns)
- Various and fitting survivor dialogues.
- Unique events.

Cons:

- Tanks.
- The finale is still not perfect, but I guess it's impossible to do better.

Conclusion:

So what's wrong with the Tanks? I didn't have that issue in the previous versions, so I guess something went wrong. During the 3 first chapters, I've fought at least 3 Tanks per map. And in the Finale, apart from the one hidden in the police station, none! It's weird, I don't know if that's my computer or something else.

Otherwise, a very well-made campaign. Try it as soon as you can.

Pros:

- Detailed and realistic maps.
- Original theme (Western of course)
- Nice intro.
- No Nav problem.

Cons:

- You should just add something to the bridge event to prevent players to get on while it's not completely down. First-time players generally manage to get across, while bots will follow and kill themselves.
- Only two chapters? Everybody here would like to see a longer campaign, even though second chapter isn't released yet.
- Survivor dialogues are to be added thoughout the map.

Conclusion:

This first chapter is almost in its final stage. Not much to say, but that bridge event needs what you know. Very promising campaign, it would be awesome if it had more chapters. I will be among the first ones to (try to) download this updated campaign.

Pros:

- Detailed and realistic maps.
- Many survivor dialogues.
- Original events.
- Traps.
- Easter eggs.

Cons:

- Less original than L4D1 version, because all the L4D2 elements are natural now.
- Still a bit hard.
- Dialogues are sometimes inappropriate (like Bill saying in the intro: "Sailboat, Francis. Sailboat."
- We have to wait 'till Cold Stream is released to hear some sounds.

Conclusion:

Still a very good campaign, but it seems less good than its L4D1 version because it lacks that wonderful idea to add L4D2 things to a L4D1 campaign. However it is definetely worth playing it, and I feel sorry that most people gave it a under-the-average rating. I'm looking forward to any other campaign this author, Keldorn, will release in the future.

Quick reminder: my rating for the L4D1 version was 95/100.

Pros:

 - Visually perfect.
 - Realistic maps.
 - Easter eggs.
 - Great ending cutscene.
 - A few original ideas.

Cons:

 - The weapon spawns are not always well balanced.
 - The maps may become a bit boring.
 - Sometimes easy to get lost.
 - Hard finale (not enough space).
 - Very few survivor dialogue.

Conclusion:

Very good campaign. It has a few cons, but you should try it, it's worth it.