Pros:

Feels like a fitting replacement.

Includes a new replacement for the incapped GUI image (the one that usually sticks out the most).

Cons:

Doesn't add much.

Doesn't replace his face on the health GUI (I'm using the default menu).

Conclusion:

While this doesn't add much to him, it's a good example that simpler things can be better than larger projects. When you use it, you feel like Ellis has a new believable backstory, which doesn't change the game at all- but at least it feels realistic enough to make you believe he was a construction worker, rather than just replacing him in general... if you catch my drift.

Pros:

Functional replacement.

Cons:

The eyes can pose weird at times.

No custom GUI replacements.

Conclusion:

While it doesn't have any GUI content (did not subtract my score from this), the model is a great replacement. Of course there's the messed up arms, but in the group of friends that I play with, I'm never Rochelle - so it works.

If you're starring at the model up close, sometimes the eyes track off to the side; but this is usually avoided because you're worrying about everything else.

The only real thing that I'd have to nitpick, and it's probably out of your control - is that she's wearing high heels. I'd never expect to see someone running around in those when all hell is breaking out, but again: I didn't subtract my score for this.

Overall, you did a good job with the porting; as well as making the model functioning in the game. I'd rather have her in the original clothing, but this makes it feel more casual. Good work.

Pros:

High quality campaign; with some neat custom content during the finale. It's clear that some thought was put into it.

Cons:

For me, it became bland after the beginning. It feels like the atmosphere and design has been done already.

A bit lacking in health supplies throughout.

Conclusion:

While everything looks great, gameplay wise it doesn't feel as refined like the official maps that it competes with. That doesn't make it bad, I'm sure that other people have enjoyed this - but to me, it overall feels weak: starting off nicely, and slowly becoming the same.

This map should be played at least once by any Left4Dead2 player (or the first Suicide Blitz if you only have the original game), because it proves that there are some excellent third-party campaigns, and this is one of them. Personally, I just found it to be a little uninspired- even though it looks good.

Pros:

Fits with the game, has custom sounds that advances the story without relying too much on re-used character dialogue.

Cons:

Not a smooth experience on Expert, and the finale is a bit confusing on where to go.

Conclusion:

If you're going to play this campaign, I suggest taking care of anything you need to do beforehand since this is a long one. Doesn't mean that it's bad; but if you aren't swift at completing it, it can eventually get fustrating.

Besides that, Dead Before Dawn DC is a pretty awesome campaign that feels complete; but I don't think it was tested with the Expert difficulty before release; some parts feel only completable with vast team work, so it's best played with a group of friends.

Pros:

Interesting blend between survival and tower defense elements.

Cons:

Bots are not very functional, and there isn't any strategy.

There is no finale music, and the stats always result in zeroes.

Weapon tiers should be organized into their own category starting from the pistol (rifles can be linked from both shotgun and automatic).

Conclusion:

This is best played with a full house; it can get extremely intense. However, it can be easy to beat since all you have to do is spam biles. Perhaps if there was a longer cool down between uses (but resets slowly) then it could be more engaging.

The walls should be destructible, and the survivors could be required to either repair it or need to rebuild them if they're destroyed. It would be more fun for in the end if the field was covered with fence building spots, and the survivors were required to build a linear pathway. Tanks and Chargers could be able to instantly destroy walls.

Bottom line, it's a little underdeveloped; but very exciting. I hope that you finish V2 some day.