Pros:

-Amazing feel
-Believable story (most custom campaigns sacrifice this for ingenuity)
-Ingenuity
-Hard, but not too hard
-Lots of replayability
-Fun with friends

Cons:

-None

Conclusion:

A truly excellent map. I played it a long time ago and didn't particularly like it, but now that I've run through it again... I'm speechless. This is a campaign you do NOT want to miss.

Pros:

Cool intro.
Custom music.
Well made maps.
Well done and interesting Finale.
Semi weapon scarcity.

Cons:

Questionable difficulty in single-player.
Easy to get lost in some places.
A bit too dark for my taste.

Conclusion:

A well done campaign, but a bit too confusing at some points (from mine to snow-capped peak? hmmmmm...). Either way, the benefits outstrip the problems by a good distance, and the campaign is a lot of fun.