Pros:

-The menu design is good
-Represents each concept very well

Cons:

-Rochelle looks like a monkey in the Versus picture(Which happened in the L4D1 styled hud of Rochelle as well)

Conclusion:

Try to focus on drawing Rochelle, until you get a more natural look.

Pros:

-Bots aren't incompetent anymore
-They're more aware of the situation than normal
-Diversified item grabbing, so not all AI grab a melee

Cons:

-When using a melee, and a Witch appears, AI programming conflicts and it runs up to the Witch to attempt to melee, which results in an incap or death in Realism
-They spread out too far, which makes it harder to be saved from a pinned situation

Conclusion:

This makes Realism an undesirable, especially in Hard Rain, because you'll lose two people simply because of conficting coding.

Pros:

-It has a better "helping hand" animation
-Arby's GL reanimation

Cons:

- It looks unsymmetrical
-Similar to Killing Floor GL (which makes me wonder if the model is original)

 

Conclusion:

I'll stay with the vanilla GL.

Pros:

-Great skin
-Still has phong and detailed materials

Cons:

-The muzzle is the killer

Conclusion:

To William who made a 1 point review;

Have you made a skin? A skin doesn't take "5 min" unless you rush over the gun with some random color.

A skin, at minimum, will take 3 hours to finish, with precise coloring and detailing.

Pros:

-Menu icons are good

Cons:

-Some characters look like they were put through a blender and then the result was this
-Low texture, quality

Conclusion:

This needs some cleaning up, rather than trying to ponify everything in 10 seconds flat.

Pros:

Cape animation
Facial animation
First person hands
No glitches with weapons clipping through hands

Cons:

No HUD icon for Lightning, incapacitated image, lobby image
Getting pounced by a Hunter could sometimes cause a game crash

Conclusion:

I believe you should post custom icons for Lightning in a updated version, and check if you could resolve the issue with game crashes when you get pounced. All in all, good job.