Pros:

-The mountain side is great
-Disallows long preparation, throws you right in
-Good weapon selection (love my Magnum)
-Forcing players to work for the decent weapons adds a nice new challenge

Cons:

-On survival an alert pops up for the generator, which confused me at first.
-At first one doesn't know where the level 2 weapons are

Conclusion:

I had a lot of fun playing this map, even by myself.  I think if you had a dialog box alerting players that the AK and Autoshotty were at the top of the hill and they needed to fight their way up the hill and through the horde it would be helpful.  I figured that out after a couple of playthroughs, though the other reviewer seems to have missed it.  This was one of my favorites from the winter competition, very very nice.

Pros:

-very pretty map
-variety, but with consistency
-good weapon selection
-nearly perfect

Cons:

-needs a few more items outside the church
-though super fun, it's not very challenging on survival

Conclusion:

I love this map.  Anyone who enjoys survival (I haven't used the scavenge yet) should get it, like Ice Breaker it is a must have.  There are some very minor suggestions from the Cons section above that merit explanation, however.  First, since there are only items in the church there is no other realistic spot to defend yourself.  This means you end up just staying inside the whole time.  Place some items elsewhere and players may be tempted to make their stand in the cemetery, or on one of the roofs, or in the kitchen.  This map has several nice spots outside of the church, and with a few items they would be defensible.  More places to hole up increases replay value quite a bit.  Also, the church is too easy to defend.  If you grab the AK and sit on the ammo you can neutralize the horde easily, and the tanks have to climb over the pews, which makes them easily avoidable.  I lasted 8:15 on my first play through with 3 bots, and I am not that good of a player.  Remove some pews to give the tank an easier time in the church, add some items outside, and this map will be perfect.  Great job, love this one and Ice Breaker.

Pros:

Neat take on the Hard Rain concept
Fully formed campaign
Good fire texture
Voice cues are well executed
Fun to play

Cons:

Just a bit too much fog
Elevator transition is broken, had to restart
Some walls missing early on
Bot nav issues

Conclusion:

Perhaps you could make a switch to flip to turn on the breakers.  There is no recognition that you have accomplished your task as there is in Hard Rain when you grab the diesel.  The Elevator safe room is a neat idea, but it needs to be fixed: you have to restart the level in the lobby and you lose anything you've picked up.  You have a good number of special infected, but there should be more tanks.  I only got 2 before the finale.  Great effort, I'll look forward to replaying the next version.