Pros:

-Very loyal to the original silent hill
-Replay value
-Four ending's
-Bot nav is nice
-Atmosphere is great
-Scare's

Cons:

-Little amounts of ammo.
-Camera angle changes only effect one player.
-Almost to dark in some area's

Conclusion:

Very good map for anyone it's almost as good as getting the real silent hill, Maybe make a campaign for the other silent hill games?

Pros:

-Feels real
-Plenty of weapons
-Cluster gas tank from dead air
-Like holding out in a real house in a real apocalypse

Cons:

-Tanks get stuck in the window in the kitchen

Conclusion:

Great map could be bigger.

Pros:

-Boss fight was a challenge but fun
-Nice how some things change
-Scary in general
-The  poster was cool (See conclusion)
-Replay value

Cons:

-Not big enough (Expand maybe?)
-Boss was not easy (We were playing normal)
-Just put most of the buildings in (The church ETC)

Conclusion:

Boss fight
Very challenging (Even on normal) Im not giving out our tactics to beat him im sure you will figure out a way to beat him without cheating.
The town
Small (Im sure that was the plan) If you blow up the gas station some of the parts just float in midair
The Witch
Scary. She pops out of nowhere (More scary scenes) I remember my first time it was like this 
Go over there see what happens. Ok. WOAH! What was that!.The witch.Creepy
The poster
Cool. Was that a witch in a cloak? I hope it is thats was i think it is...
The horror level.
First time 7/10
Second to last time
10/30

Pros:

-Like the real thing
-The finale fits in the indiana jones theme 
-Just enough zombies
-Custom sounds
-Indiana jones
-Ending clip after the finale was cool 

Cons:

-Over so soon? Aww....
-Finale can be confusing
-indiana jones has red skin?

Conclusion:

I found it alot of fun the scavenge event was interesting 
Some better indiana jones pictures might be cool (Red skin really?)
I got lost in the finale then later when playing with others they got lost maybe some directional signs?

You have got to make a full disneyland next

Pros:

-Gun shop was a nice touch
-Louis and bill

Cons:

-Was not fun (For me)
-Made the zombies look diffrent (Maybe it was the server)
-Small

Conclusion:

I conclude that tacos are the best food ever

Pros:

-Multible paths
-Nice lightning for the first three levels
-Original ideas
-Custom sounds are nice

Cons:

-Can get stuck on crashed helicopter
-Sometimes hard to telll how to start the crain in chapter 4
-Easy to get lost

Conclusion:

A very good campaign in my top five maybe a port to L4D2 and make it daytime?

Pros:

francis and zoey :D
gun shop!
looks nice

Cons:

none really

Conclusion:

a pretty nice map it would be cool if you could somehow make whitaker shoot 

Pros:

-gets the blood pumping
-awesome rescue
-scripted better then valve
-super scary
-storyline pwns
-BOOM!!!

Cons:

-to many boomers?
-easy to get lost
-first chapter is empy and confuseing (for me)

Conclusion:

AMAZEING!!! one of the best no the best campaign 

Pros:

-melee changes every round
-rain effect fits in well
-fun with tanks

Cons:

-you can glitch with the ladder
-bile bombs on the church are almost unlimited
-really really really dark

Conclusion:

good map easy in some ways i think it would look nice in the light :D