Pros:

-good model
-nice animations
-nice sounds
-the sights are extremely accurate
-really fun to use

Cons:

-maybe create one for the M16 slot too?

Conclusion:

Awesome.

Pros:

-more recoil
-fully automatic Scar!
-realistic clip sizes

Cons:

-the Magnum should kill. Especially in realism. (-1)
-M16 shooting in 3rd bursts is CALL OF DUTY LOGIC. It's a full automatic weapon, damnit! (-1)
-I'm not sure if the SPAS can shoot slugs? (shoot me if I'm wrong but I thought it could only shoot buckshots)
Either way it would be better if the R870's shoot slugs, since they are more actual hunting shotguns. (-0.5)
-not at all original, these changes are in many other mods (-2)

Conclusion:

If you had called this ''balanced weapons pack'' you would have gotten a good review, but you called it realistic, and this is far from realistic. This mod has potential, but please improve on the points that I mentioned in the Cons!

Pros:

-real entertaining
-GREAT design
-Moria is exactly like it is in LOTR
-great detail
-great custom sounds
-doesn't get boring at all
-extremely original

Cons:

Bugs:
-the bots don't take the medkits in the first map
-the fourth map has floating guns bugs and when you fall in a trap, there is NO way out (not even by committing suicide!)

Design:
-the graphics are slightly outdated (the ghosts are 2D, etc..) but after all it's an old game so no points lost here.

Conclusion:

One of the best and most original campaigns for L4D2. Playing through the Haunted House feels like an actual Disney ride and the map design is magnificent. This is one of the few campaigns that would be fun even without zombies. The reason I gave this a 9 is because I had to quit and restart from level 4 after falling in a trap, which was pretty annoying.

Pros:

1. very original:
- different ways to go through each map
- a new escape vehicle
- ''unexpected'' plot twist

2. good environment design

3. very large maps

Cons:

1. too many supplies make the campagin very easy

2. sometimes confusing map design (which is also a pro)

Conclusion:

Simply amazing. Better than any of the default campaigns and definitely one of the best addon campaigns. Good job.