Pros:

Good attention to detail.
Good Echoing Sound Effects.
Good use of displacements.
Visually stunning.
Good Color Correction.
Custom Models.
Custom Textures.
Our little friend has found himself some goggles!

Cons:

Too Small
Bad Finale Start Placement.
Shooting glass = spash effect = Horrible Looking.

Conclusion:

This is an excellent map, and I can tell you have spent alot of time on it. The map is visually amazing and plays like that of Chuck Norris in a game of checkers. The map is really quite small and tight and the radio placement had me running about like a headless chicken trying to find it. As for shooting through the glass, cover the tanks with func_detail_blocker's, that should fix this problem. Good map.

Pros:

Brilliant Atmosphere
Good blend between atmospheres
Great design
Some good suprises (wont spoil)
Good difficulty
Good detail
Supports versus! (which people are taking for granted I see)

Most of all, believable! (most of it)

Cons:

3 witches spawned on map 2, I don't know if you are aware of that glitch.

Conclusion:

Brilliant map, I can tell you have spent alot of time and effort on it (much to your partners dislike (presuming you have one of course)) and it has certainly paid off! 

Just unfortunete that 3 witches decided they were gonna team up on my ***. (They won) and although the versus may be quite hard at times, its there! and its very playable! unlike quite alot of the maps out there just now!

Overall a very good map, very worthy of the 97 that im giving you. A few minor bugs. And I do like the hypocrites that moan about them, if they dont like it, I cant WAIT to see them do better.

VALVE, look out for this one!

Can't wait to see your future projects!

                                                                                                                                                                     Signed: Fish