Pros:

++ Reloading animation is just great
++ Sounds are amazing
+ It doesn't fill your view as many other pistol mods do
+ Flashlight on the left? Just cool!

Cons:

No one

Conclusion:

Absolutely one of my fav mods.

A must have.

Pros:

- Great idea
- Great model
- Great texturing
- It fits very well the visual style of the game
- It replaces Nick :)
- Name is not replaced (so dialogues are not ***** up)

Cons:

Can't find any cons

Conclusion:

One of my top favorite characters mod and I cannot give less than 10.

Pros:

- SWAT!
- It fits the L4D2 look and style
- They just look realistic and cool

Cons:

- It would be nice to have a sort of way to recognize characters (maybe a number on front and rear of the jackets?)
- They could be a little more detailed...
- ...especially hands in first person
- Medikits sunk into the armors

Conclusion:

A good model pack ruined by the hands in first person. They are too low poly to live with. They look like a game from the early 2000!

Having the hand fixed it could become one of my favorite mods.

Pros:

- Very big maps that make you struggle to survive
- Challenging but not too frustrating
- Immersive: you really feel alone here
- Hordes are placed carefully to fit the length of the maps
- Good gameflow and situation variety
- Dark as hell
- Black Mesa feeling...
- ... with a smart platform jump session
- Funny finale

Cons:

- Fake doors everywhere
- A few more supplies would be needed to play higher difficulty settings
- At higher difficulty settings can turn to be too frustrating
- The last map is not as good as the first two ones
- Environment could be more detailed

Conclusion:

If you like large maps and to crawl in the darkness, this campaign is just perfect.

Pros:

- It succeeds in being funny to (re)play.
- Naif and unbalanced difficulty peaks that are just challenging
- Every time you play the distribution of the enemies vary a lot, making this campaing deliciously unpredictable 

Cons:

- Sometime the levels would need more attention on the details
- It's really fast to reach the end
- I had (and freinds of mine too) some missing skyboxes 

Conclusion:

There is little to say. This campaign is just funny without being pretentious.

Give it a try, it wont miss give you some fun.

Pros:

- The most graphically appealing campaign ever
- Great variety of situations
- A real cinematic experience

Cons:

- Gameflow is slow paced
- Level design is uninspired on the gameplay side
- Most of the deaths are caused by unforgiving level design (example: the fight in the cinema or the chargers on the roofs)
- Most of the time you fight in small spaces, stuffed of tons of details that hinder you in any possibile way
- Comments hidden around? mmhhh....
- A lot of dead end paths (expecially at the beginning)

Conclusion:

This campaign is a masterpiace on the visual dep. but it lacks of what is really important to me in a campaign: the subtle ability to keep you playing no matter the difficulties.

I think the author put a most of the attention in making everything pleasent to see, instead on focus on what is funny to play.

The thing that most I missed here is a balance between situations where you really struggle to survive and situations where you make your way straight. Most of the time is just a dull avarage, with no peaks and breaks.

Anyway, everyone should play this campaign. Expecially maps creators.