Pros:

- good level design
- very good level layout
- very good item placement
- very good atmosphere
- very good Ai
- 6 maps and not one is boring 

Cons:

- framerate goes below 20 fps sometimes

Conclusion:

 I really enjoyed playing this campaign. I can highly recommend it. From my point of view it's one of five best custom campaigns I'ever played in l4d. 

Pros:

good gameplay
awesome leveldesign
never gets boring
nice details
good map ideas

Cons:

no cons so far

Conclusion:

very good custom campaign, highly recommended

Pros:

I'm not a Silet Hill fans. From my point of view, there are no pros.

Cons:

Boring, to long, no weapons, no healthpack. I guess this ist just a campaign for Silent Hill fans.

Conclusion:

If you like the game Silent Hill you may like it.

Pros:

very good gameplay, nice design... this map is as good as a stock campaign. It is definitely one of the best custom l4d campaigns I've ever played !!

Cons:

From my point of view there are no cons.

Conclusion:

overall good map. It's definitely worth to give it a try..

Pros:

It has been released, it could be tested

Cons:

buggy map, crap textures, crap gameplay

Conclusion:

play it once...and never ever again

Pros:

very nice map... !! good gameplay, overall good

Cons:

only 4 maps, nothing more to moan at

Conclusion:

give it a try, it's worth it