Pros:

sounds like a lightsaber
looks like a light saber
no extra lag
grat over all

Cons:

removes Katana(-1pt)
i have to disable all of my add-ons so i cant play it on all ,y favorite maps (-25pts)

Conclusion:

overe all i like it but i would bee better if you found a way so peaple could use it with other maps.

Pros:

Its Lotr
Its Helms Deep
ammazing graphics
great feal
hard 
great for a geek like me
3/4 of the original survivors help you
billscorpse is there when the wall goes BOOOOOOM!

Cons:

small comapred to the movies
Bots Can't climb the stairs(<- might have change wrighting this while downloading the new one)
bothing making me move on so i can stay at the gate

Conclusion:

make it easy for the bots to get up the stairs to the top tower and it's a 100 score from me
make it a little bigger in scale and have it force me to the next area that i cant leave and its godlly
note:when i say nothing to force me forword all i have to do to get to the first wall is when the gate brakes run through and back to the wall

Pros:

great map
lots of zombies
fun to play
perfect amountof light in the dark areas so your not screwed by a jocky
hidden tanks
new map
great music selection
first gate closes 10x faster
2nd gate closes itself
new intro
new start point
you now get worned of the helecpoter blade(it has killed me befor in the normal.

Cons:

error messages where all the tables should be level 1 had to many jockys
the tank that trough the rock at the hlecopter you didnt get the chance to kill
only melee when you start

Conclusion:

all in all great campain better then the normal fix the tables and add a tank on the opposite side of the coppter and it will be fantastic