Pros:

Brilliant Looking and play!
Custom textures/models.
Loads of doorways nooks and crannies off the main route to hide in/explore (tho more supplies in them).
I loved the safe room at the end of map 1.

Cons:

No swords!
No Lasers!
Bit laggy at times ( probs my pc tho)

Conclusion:

I really loved this one, but I only give it 99/100, No swords! No Lasers! (that I found) Otherwise this map wud have 100! Personaly this is one of the best i have played(also the author found and used some textures i used in my own Tokyo map for SFTDM in ut99) I love the lay out of the maps, and the cable car etc, just brilliant!
I could have spent longer in the first map, maybe 2 parts upper an lower, I really wanted to get into the underground mall!!!!

Cant wait for the final version. Brilliant!

Pros:

Looks very nice.

Love the lay out.

Love that you can go explore before starting

great bit of the real mall.

Cons:

Why havent Valve picked this one up for a dlc!

Maybe a Gun store out side?

Other wise non worth mentioning!

Conclusion:

100/100! Fantasticle! Loved it. It was perfect, the only things missing or that you could ask for from this map, those are just things you'd like to see, nothing thats needed (for instance going back into the main mall for supplies, ormore gas cans or what ever). 
Or a campaign starting here via re-gas of the car. Maybe fill in the gap to dark carnival. What happened on the way there, a stop per map. ( I gotta get mappin)

Very Well worth a DL!

Pros:

Great stuff.

Extra flash glowing bile.

Half price!

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

Very nice little mod this. Looks great and makes it easier to find. Love this tuff.

Pros:

Great Skin.

Works Fine

Well worth a DL.

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

Another great custom skin, goes well with other custom skins. 100/100 great job Sir!

Pros:

Looks great.

Works great.

Well worth a dl.

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

Works and looks great. Goes well with other custom player skins. 

Pros:

Swat Team of sweetness.

4 great looking skins.

Well worth a dl

Cons:

None worth mentioning. No fp arms, in nick for sure!

Conclusion:

Fantastic, swat team in L4D2, swizzing bossness of brilliance! Mr Lanky, thank you sir! 100/100!

Pros:

Great stuff here, chrome pistols of awesome.

Really nice models.

Looks great in game!

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

Great work with these pistols. It would be good to have one black and one chrome pistol. 100/100 for these babies.

Pros:

It's Zoey.

Replaces Rochelle.

It's just like old times!

:o)

Cons:

Needs her voice, hud etc.

Conclusion:

Great replacment for Rochelle, and it's Zoey from L4D1, how awesometastic is that? Well its super awesometastic is what it is! Thank you sir!

Pros:

It's Zoey!

Great looking model.

Replaces Rochelle.

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

In conclusion its  great skin, its Zoey from L4D1, in L4D2, fantastic! great new outfit for her to! Zazaammm!

Pros:

Looks great.

New player skins add new feel to game.

cant fault him

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

Great replacment for Nick. Goes well with my other dled army player skins. who ever he is, it doesnt matter about the description. Its great skin.

Pros:

Very nice chrome SMG.

Well worth a download.

Good replacment for standard SMG.

Cons:

Non, perfect!

Conclusion:

Great looking gun. It would be cool if we could have both blaxk and chrome smgs.

Pros:

A chrometastic shotgun.
Great looking shot gun.
Good replacment for standard shotty.

Cons:

Non.

Conclusion:

Cant fault it. Looks great in game! 100/100.

Pros:

OH EM GEE. Its Golden eye.
Great design, looks just like it should.
New decor looks great.
Plays well.

Cons:

Non worth mentioning.

Conclusion:

Awesome scoresome. many hours were had at the hands of a N64 pad, 4 player killage fun times. Now for L4D2, amaze.
If you played on this back in the day, you will love it. Well worth a download.

Pros:

First off, It's the mall from dawn of the dead, how FRICKIN AWESOME is that?
Brilliant campaign.
some great twists and original ideas and objectives
new objectives are tuff but good.
visuals are great.

Cons:

It could have been longer.
Nothing worth mentioning.

Conclusion:

Waited for this one for TIME, watched it online for years then finally for L4D1,much JOY was had. Great to see it make it to L4D2, more JOY was had. IMO it could have been even longer, almost like an addon side game to L4D. If a few more of these very talented mappers could all work together on something like this, add to it, build on it, it could be a fantastic round the world adventure. Awesome campaign one of the very best.

Pros:

Even better than it was for L4D1.
Fantastic visuals.
Great to explore and lots to see.
really nice map

Cons:

Non worth mentioning.

Conclusion:

Fantastic map. Well worth a download just to walk around it and check it out, even if you dont play scavenge or survival like i dont, but i did with this.

Pros:

Very well done.
smooth play.
awesome visuals.
replay value.

Cons:

None worth mentioning.

Conclusion:

Really enjoyed this one. Another fantastic campaign, worthy of a community user dlc map pack, if valve had the time to make one for us!!?!??!??!!!!??? all of these really good campaigns just add more and more playtime in L4D2.

Pros:

Very nice detail.
very nice design and flow.
very nice to play, visuals brill.
some twists are awesome.

Cons:

None excpet maybe the odd bug here an there, getting stuck or lost or the like, but over all awesome CAMPAIGN

Conclusion:

Such a good campaign imo, and very happy to see a map by another games design team. Really fun to play, defo going in my personalmappack rotation. Download you will not be disappointed, unless you dont like mountians, then, er....

Pros:

Very cool puzzles
is lots of fun to play
is lots of fun to play x2 and so on.

Cons:

some parts could do with more scencery, pipes and steam blinking lights basic decoration.

like a couple have said not enuff curves or the like.

other than that nothing.

Conclusion:

Very fun map with plenty of replay value.

value for money campaign. loved it.