Pros:

- Definitely a difficult one
- Long campaign
- Improved FPS
- Hordes number
- Based on a real park
- Large area with some details
- Easy to find the way
- Well designed final
- Texture 
- BGM

Cons:

- Lots repetitive scenes in level three and four
- Some open areas need more details and changes
- FPS is still an issue 
- Get bored at level three and four

Conclusion:

I believe i have played this campaign for over ten times and i really like it. The huge hordes are really challenging. Besides this, some parts of level three and four are difficult, because basically i can not find enough places to hold the hordes. Since there are lots of wide open areas, teammates are easy to be seperated and be surrounded by hordes. However,sometimes i can start to get really bored and frustrated at level three or level four, not only because they are hard but also because most scenes need more details and intereting elements. I mean without some changes, it's just running through trees and getting ambushed by SI and surrounded by hordes. 
Generally speaking, level one, two, some parts in level three and four, also the final are really great. With improved FPS, i can add more custom elements to it. However, if you got some fresh and interesting ideas for level three and four, then the campaign would be perfect. Anyway, thanks for updating the campaign and trying to improve the fps issue. Please keep your good work up.

Pros:

- Solid gameplay 
- Some areas are pretty good
- Another awesome dead center, even better than dead before dawn
- Four levels, four different scenes and smooth transitions between them
- Smooth FPS
- Nice final, find some really good places to hold
- Challenging, especially for the first level
- Plain area with hordes and SIs coming from every direction
- Good amount of the cars with alarms
- Tanks and witches
- Tunnels in final with unlimited tanks, nice idea 
- Adorable campaign length 
- Reasonable amount of supplies

Cons:

- Few textures are a little weak
- FPS is already great but can be improved
- Need more events in the third level, the mall
- Can be a little bored at some areas
- Can get lost in level two and three the first time playing it
- Some plain areas need more interesting elements
- Some repetitive scenes here and there

Conclusion:

The campaign is challenging and due to that reason, most time i don't feel bored at all. FPS is acceptable according to large amount of outdoor areas. However, some areas need more interesting elements like the mall and the square from level two. Anyway, i'm a sick person who enjoys Absolute Zero and Mars base, so maybe this one is not for everyone. But in my place, i enjoy it a lot, nice work and keep your good work up.

Pros:

- Detailed but not complicated
- EOtech 
- Silencer
- Arby26's m16 animation
- Laser in the right place
- Texture

Cons:

- Grip handle, although it doesn't bother me too much

Conclusion:

I really like this one, especially after you updated it. It would be perfect if you could remove that grip handle though. Thanks for this nice mod :)

Pros:

- This should and must be done
- A real reborn for the default pistol
- Arby26's s&w animation is the only and the best pistol animation (IMO)

Cons:

- Nothing

Conclusion:

It's a simple work but is just perfect. I believe this should be done long time ago. Thanks :)

Pros:

- It works good in low FOV
- WWII weapons
- Simple and clean in good way

Cons:

- Texture is poor 
- Lots of details are not good

Conclusion:

It's a classic WWII weapon. It's definitely new in l4d2. It's an interesting one. Many details are not perfect but they don't bother me so much. With a low FOV, those flaws are hidden and i can really assume i'm using an actual WWII weapon. Thanks for ALL your WWII weapons :)

Pros:

- Long barrel revolver
- Textures 
- Animation is better than those old revolvers

Cons:

- Nothing

Conclusion:

Perfect revolver. Best one i have ever used. However i believe you can port more nice revolvers. Thanks :)

Pros:

- Nice port
- Beautiful weapon (all the good details)
- Realistic texture
- Nice animation, really fits

Cons:

- Texture 
- Maybe a silencer version :)

Conclusion:

A nice port. Something new in l4d2. Add a silencer version will be perfect.

Pros:

- Details
- Good idea to remove the launcher
- Silencer

Cons:

- Texture can be better

Conclusion:

A nice one. I put it on to arby26's m16 animation and it feels a little better. Thanks :)

Pros:

- Details, textures
- Animation
- Bug free
- Proper size in first person

Cons:

- Nothing yet

Conclusion:

Actually i'm not a fan of sg552, sg551 or whatever we call that, but with Funreal's texture i must give it a shot. It turns out this is a really nice one. Funreal does know how to find the beauty. Also it's a good thing that this one does not take too much space in first person view, so it's easy to take an accurate shot. Nice job! Please keep your good work up here and thanks for your effort for this game :)

Pros:

- hordes events and panic events have been properly set
- enough places for SI to attack efficiently (Hard Eight Mode)
- not annoying puzzle-solve part
- game length is good, every map is long and fun
- finale is great, very intense and not bored at all, even details are also good in finale
- some interesting traps, some sick jokes, interesting dialogue, funny storyline
- rock music, custom music, interesting SI music (get caught by SI, especially for jockey)
- the whole gaming atmosphere is not dull and depressed at all, a totally different way to play l4d2
- decent and enjoyable layout design, color rendering, music, storyline are perfectly united together
- high quality details and textures, definitely professional work,have fixed some annoying parts and bugs

Cons:

- except for the finale, other missions are not intense enough
- at two panic event points, one man has too hold the trigger for a long time, one time is on the roof another time is closing the door, a little annoying, i prefer more tanks or hordes than just stand there and pray my team mates protect me
- can be lost in the mall when you first play it

Conclusion:

it's really nice, leaves me great impression, definitely high quality work in every way, very creative, full of interesting ideas, traps and puzzle solving parts are also adorable, the atmosphere is also delightful, the sun is shinning, there is other survivors out there and give you instructions all the time, means that you are not alone, some jokes, custom music and the dialogues can also cheer me up, the map design is also in professional way, there are multiple elements here and joining together in a nice way, hordes and panic events are put in good way, not so intense though, playing in hard eight mode is enjoyable, strongly recommended 

Pros:

- it's not a too difficult campaign, great experience play it in Hard Eight mode, horde events and SI's survive points are properly done here, smokers can be really tricky, the infected are smart in most time, quite enjoyable journey
- visual field is not bad, set in a good way, wont complain, all kinds weapons can be useful , since there are long, middle, short distance areas , also there are broad and narrow areas besides these in mountain parts you have to look up and down all the time, so never get bored
- japanese style, best ever, atmosphere is perfect, lots of new scenes and elements (cable car, japanese style school, houses, red-light district, japanese mountain view, some japanese music, good color renderings ...)

Cons:

- some glitches
- finale is too easy, kind of hasty

Conclusion:

best japanese style map, solid gameplay, awesome atmosphere, many new elements, detailed map design, good storyline, acceptable length, proper game difficulty, never get bored, only a few bugs and finale is hasty

Pros:

- west theme !!!
- desert theme !!!
- "based on upcoming film Mary Doe" (the movie is never coming???)
- some interesting moments (the voice in the safe room, some dialogues)
- custom music which is really great (i mean the whole soundtrack)
- bright light, good visual field
- nice underground cave (dark, with underground stream)
- there are so many common infected standing everywhere (so you can not rush through the whole map easily)
- good view and great atmosphere (the sands, the sunlight, west-style houses)
- lots of good place to camp in the finale
- another nice research institute
- good place to use all kinds weapons
- not so difficult one but can be really attractive, awesome experience playing in Hard Eight mode, never get bored through out the whole journey
- no repetitive and many different elements
- guidence is good, never get lost (e.g. you can see the trigger point from a great distance)
- nearly no bug
- on some places, attacks from SI could be really threaten which is nice 

Cons:

- "85% completed" "beta" ????
- the whole journey is a little short
- need more horde events especially on finale, it's a so easy finale even playing in Hard Eight mode
- the custom postlude is too short

Conclusion:

awesome map, lots of interesting and creative ideas here, no repetitive with different elements, decent layout design and solid gameplay, never get bored, just a little easy for finale and a little short, maybe it's so great that i can never get too much of it, strong recommended

Pros:

- multiple paths provides multiple choices, good mapping
- decent layout design, nearly flawless
- tricky, SI can come from nowhere, the bushes, cliffs, even the indoor area is not so safe, not a easy job to play in hard eight mode
- nice atomsphere (forest, moonlight, mountains, rainy day, lake, cabins)

Cons:

- m1 is short and a little bored, just normal forest area, a little repetitive in my opinion
- m2 is too short and a little hasty, the length is even shorter than m1 and much shorter than the rest 3 missions, nearly no actual content except for the interesting idea (rescue plane crashed), i mean the mansion is well designed, but no revive point for SI in there, few infected there too
- hard to find a really good place to camp in the finale, also have to face the ammo shortage problem
- nothing is so special, feel a little bored everytime i play it, maybe i just dont like the mountains 

Conclusion:

i have to say i had so many expectations the first time i played it, but to be honest, im a little disappointed after i finished the first 2 missions
it's a good map, perhaps it's the best map for forest theme, acceptable length, some interesting ideas, nice m3,m4, solid layout design, the details are also good, atmosphere is brilliant, a little hard to play, but not in my favoured way, i mean the whole point for this map is camp, rush, camp, rush again, especially in hard eight mode, at some point i feel repetitive and bored
still recommended, but dont expect too much from it

Pros:

- super creative, full of interesting ideas, use grenade launcher to shoot the mark, climb all the way up on shaking pipes with things falling down, use the gascan to get the weapon, random password at the finale, interesting and sick way to leave the safe room..... i will say every minute is a surprise and i can never list all of them

- awesome atmosphere, really really depressive and sick, the color of the wall, the large and plain area, the abyss, narrow path ... all these things make me feel like being an experimental subject locked in box and monitored all the way, would say it's not a good place for people who have claustrophobia or fragile nerves, actually it feels so real that i never be more desperate to get away from one place like this one

- really technical, in hard eight mode i have to focus on it every seconds, chargers and smokers can be really dangerous, the holes above where the SI fall down, hordes appear from nowhere, so many unexpected events, actually no place is genuinely safe in the whole map, we have to reloaded over fourty times to finish it

- the best finale, i mean you have to fight your way from the beginning to the end, no lame survive mode for the finale, also you never see you actually get rescued or released, you only see the sunlight above you from the elevator, it's like so many horror movie's ending, really hope there is Questionable Ethics III

Cons:

like the score i give i can find no place need to change, everything is just perfect
only one thing, if i was the map maker i would make the square plates dynamic in the 4th map, i'm talking about that big place with so many square plates you can jump on them all the way though the water area, making the plates can up and down all the time will be more tricky and interesting, without that i think it's a little easy and bored and less creative 

Conclusion:

it's the best map i have ever played, very intense and exciting, a really tricky one, needs much patience and good companion, everything in it is just perfect, really hope there is Questionable Ethics III, IV, V... and then the story can get a detailed ending

Pros:

- nice atmosphere (sewer, indoor area, forest)
- multiple elements (combined in a nice way)
- not bad mapping
- quite technical (especially in hard eight mode)
- decent layout design except for few places

Cons:

- in finale, besides the bug point i find no good place to camp 
- i can hardly say it's a creative map, hard to find interesting place, nearly no personality here

Conclusion:

it's not a bad map with several elements properly combined, the layout is well designed, the sewer part and tunnel area leave me strong impression
it's not a easy one, in hard eight mode we got failed too many times even in level four which is the shortest map of the five, maybe it's the only reason i would keep it in my collection
however i can not find unique place in this map, easy to get bored 

Pros:

- super fire effects
- perfect icy setting
- smoke blinds survivors' sight, interesting idea
- great place to use sniper
- not hard to find the way, the guidence is good 
- unique and complete storyline
- neat layout
- the place to fight the hordes in finale is really well designed, even better than c8m5 (IMO)
- fix the bugs

Cons:

- some repetitions (the long "tunnel area"; lots of offices with iron pillars)
- a little short for such a great map
- a little easy for survivors (see conclusion)
- some missions can be merged
- could be more hordes

Conclusion:

it's the best arctic theme map, there are lots of well-designed details, the flowing fire, ice pillars with waterfall, the atmosphere is not dark but is filled with smoke which can blind the sight, in level 3 i believe at some point there is a strong sunlight which is really impressive

since there are so many long tunnel areas, it's a good place to use sniper, but not a good place for special infects to camp, with so many iron pillars, hunter and charger are not threaten, in this case i believe more hordes can be used, and more ladders for chargers to camp, more holes and traps for survivors to drop, then this will be a difficult and skilled map 

btw a little short for such a super map, single missions usually are a little short which can be merged
anyway very creative and full of interesting ideas, solid layout design
thanks for such an amazing map