Pros:

-minecraft
-all the other mods that make this even better
-map design is fantastic
-story line

Cons:

-you have to download all the mods, but thats no problem ;)

Conclusion:

EPIC :D

Pros:

- large map
- bosses
- secret gnome!
- riot shield!

Cons:

- very hard because there aren't safe rooms and you need to complete the whole map and if you die you need to do it all over again. --__--
- why isn't there a survival of this?

Conclusion:

this is a great map!

Pros:

new original idea
constructing things
research items and weapons
this map stays funny even if you play it 10 times.

Cons:

bots have only pistol and they grab nothing

Conclusion:

this map is awesome. you should make a survival of this.

Pros:

big map
many events
all survivors
original lotr sounds
its always fun playing this map
GANDALF AND GIMLI!!

Cons:

easy first 6 minutes
bots are not so smart

Conclusion:

its just perfect!!
want to survive minas tirith and attack mordor now!