Pros:

Atmosphere
Random Navigation
Good Layout and Design
Challenging

Cons:

Intro still appears to be broken on some servers

Conclusion:

Enjoyed the campaign and the randomness. Layout and Level design looks good, and navigation is fine with me. So you have to explore a little until you learn the campaign, no big deal. The one thing that I do continue to have a problem with is the intro. Right now I can only seem to run it on the one 8 man server running using minimum mods.( multislots, tankbuster, simple supply, common infected regulator, vote manager, gore, admin respawn, weapon unlock, SG552 fix, afk fix ) While the intro isn't bad, it could be done away with for more playability IMO. In order for us to make it work we had to load in and leave one at a time to spawn in properly. Screen was black and stuck on Castorjudo Presents. Also missed the gas station event. Was that just random or did you feel you had to dumb it down for the players who couldn't make it through? Overall really enjoyable.

Pros:

Well done level design
Great details
Custom Melee
New content

Cons:

See below.

Conclusion:

Loved this campaign from the first time that I played it and have always felt it was one of the best customs out there. That said, I was a bit sad with some of the updated content. The awesome hazmat chargers are gone. Really sad to see those not in game. Don't understand WHY they were removed. Also missed the electricity buzzing over the water where you used to be able to get shocked. I did like the addition of the parts you added including the talking "survivor" when you approach the safe room. One thing that seemed a bit undone was the guy who asked you for help when the z' are trying to break in the door. Custom melee weapons rock, though. Did enjoy the new finale, although it seemed a bit confusing, but I think the first experience is usually one of discovering what you are supposed to do anyway so I wouldn't change a thing there. We did experience some major lag on the level where you are in the lab. I don't know if that was due to my custom server or what, will comment again if I see it another time. I am hoping you will add the removed stuff back in, though. Really, really liked those funky chargers.

Pros:

Well done layout
Great Textures
Decent supplies

Cons:

Invisible walls.

Conclusion:

Really enjoyed the campaign. Nice finale surprise at the end... Loved the little tent city where we pick up supplies before heading to the hold out area. No nav problems when we played. Hated that there were invisible walls in place of obstacles as we try to walk/jump on everything. Would like it better if we actually had something blocking our path like a barrel or a crate or a tree branch. Will play again-this is a keeper

Pros:

Don't know as we couldn't even get passed the first map.

Cons:

Horrible, horrible textures and poor texture job on the plants. You can see part of the plant at the top so your offset has gone terribly wrong. The horde was ridiculous. Server crashed and we said forget it. 

Conclusion:

Was hoping that this would be a fun campaign and wanted to try it as we are always  looking for challenging campaigns, but this was a bit ridiculous. I appreciate the time it takes to make a campaign and applaud you for undertaking this endeavor, but some better textures would go a long way improving things. The endless horde with not so good places to hole up was bad, too. If you are looking to improve, there are enough suggestions found in other reviews as well.

Pros:

Custom Music
Custom Models
Challenging Game Play
Atmosphere
Concept
Open area for exploration
Custom Melee! (very cool)

Cons:

Tunnels are a bit too flat in some areas. Finale was a bit confusing.

Conclusion:

Really, really loved the campaign overall. I am a huge fan of Sherlock Holmes so I caught on to "The Hound of the Baskervilles" straight away. 

The critiques above are minor in my opinion. The flat-ish tunnels may have had to be done that way for a reason, IDK, but I thought that given the outstanding look of everything else it appeared a bit weak and unfinished. At the very least some different textures may have given them a bit more depth and rockier look. Overall a fun and challenging campaign.

I don't want to give away the finale, but we were unsure how to proceed after we went to the door. I expected to see something highlighted to indicate what the next step was, but there wasn't anything. 

Many things to ooh and ahh over and a nice tank surprise, too.  Will definitely play again and again.

Pros:

Funny as hell! Perfectly done and well made mod. 

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Would make my pants tight.... if I was a guy. :)