Pros:

Challenging 
Fun to play with Friends
All Custom Things
l4d 1 Survivors
No more trolling when we have to retreat
Events
That moment when you beat the map and you here the victory music(no points added)
Ability to turn off music
Weapons
Replay value

Cons:

Bots still can't get up the stairs
lag in the final rush
not enough bow and sword weapons for all four(No points taken)
FIX L4D 1 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Conclusion:

This map is really good, beautiful, and you can replay it over and over without getting bored. The only thing I think you should work on is finding a modder to make you a set of characters for the map so it actually fits the story.

Pros:

Memories
One of my favorite shows 

Cons:

Boring, Really fast, it seems all you did was put the candy shop, that is not accessible, even if your planning to do make accessible in the campaign.


Ambulance takes away any challenge this map had.

No where to go, nothing to do, Just a street you put with a closed candy shop. 

Conclusion:

This isn't really fun at all, and their isn't a challenge whatsoever. I'm excited about the campaign though! 

Pros:

Amazing
memories
Love it
works
Amazing
Did I say Amazing?

Cons:

It's godzilla what's not too like?

Conclusion:

Works, amazing if you liked the movie godzilla, where did you get that weapon sound pack from?

Pros:

FALLOUT
A perfect fit
Love it!
I love it!
Did I say I love it?

Cons:

Me no speak Con? <:>

Conclusion:

Awesome, a definite must if your a fan of fallout, and even if your not it still is a good idea to get this mod, as always, Splinks delivers the best.

Pros:

Camping spots but...
Large
Enough Detail to it
Skybox
Has so much potential

Cons:

No challenge whatsoever
Tank music playing? 
Poster
To many start buttons(Npto), I thought the Guitar was a melee. It wasn't.
No Melee's
no biles
So many building, some of them aren't really necessary. 
Bots get lost
The inside of the buildings are a little to...clean.
Outside is too clean
No Magnum

Conclusion:

Please update it soon so I change my score. Well, that's it, Great job though! I enjoyed it nonetheless.

Pros:

THIS IS AWESOME.
I can Kill him over and over, makes my American pride big.
If I download the military skin pack for the survivors, I feel so good killing him! lol
Great Detail
Love the Quality 

Cons:

None at all.
People get offended because they are twelve, Like Sakura.

Conclusion:

Perfect! Haters gonna Hate, Spliinks, Continue doing mods, since you are the MOD KING(of this site and probably game)

Pros:

It's FREDDY
Looks so much like freddy for a l4d 2.

Amazing,
Beautiful 

Cons:

The claws go through guns and other items.

Conclusion:

Really good, I'm going to keep it, Great job.

Pros:

Works
I love it
FIRE

Cons:

That ugly Jump suit, is there a version without it, It just doesn't fit for me.

Conclusion:

It works and is lovely, the only thing that is a turnoff is that ugly jump suit.

Pros:

Works
Funny
Love Family guy
Beautiful
Amazing

Cons:

None as of now
(it should have a vomit replacement, I've seen FG enough to know peter has a suitable vomit replacement.) No points taken

Conclusion:

Works, and is very beautiful if you love the peter griffin!

Pros:

TF2!
Beatiful
perfect 
Amazing

Cons:

none at all

Conclusion:

Love it, i love making it to the safe room, now. DOWNLOAD NOW NOW!

Pros:

Everything works
PORTAL 2
Really good no glitches or bugs

Cons:

No name change

Conclusion:

The name change is the onlyl con I Have, this would complete the pack.

Pros:

Everything works
COD

Cons:

who knows

Conclusion:

Nice, if you're a Cod fan, But I'm not, I just like the weapon sounds. :p

Pros:

HAHA, Love it
Orginal
Awesomely put together
sounds
The fish moves!
Replaces the PAN

Cons:

Bit wierd on the back
no new icon
Fish color

Conclusion:

Well, done, everyone should give it a try!

Pros:

Wow, the sun is amazing!
sniper
traps!
knife 
nam weapons
Love the screenshots
love the scenery.

Cons:

BGM has been drowned out 
I'm not going to lie it is short, but short maps are good too, I mean sometimes I just want a quick map.(No points taken)
not many shotguns
bots are wierd
Horde attacks before I even get weapons
custom skins(no points taken)
Finale unchallenging
Takes forever to find the final radio!
No story

Conclusion:

Sorry, for the 29 but it was actually my own computer's fault, it's been fixed, sorry. However, I don't like the custom skins b/c  it messed with my skins a little.  The Scenery was Awesome!I recommend to all, great map.

Pros:

WOW
Another Unique map
original
NOT EVEN  COMPLETE
Challenging
Plenty of weapons
Nice intro!

Cons:

Almost no challenge(no points taken)
eh, no biles

Conclusion:

OKAY, This might change when the map becomes Complete but for now it's amazing!

Pros:

Incredible
Love it 
I love the look
I AM NOW DEATH!

Cons:

(no points taken) I wish you could change the weapon image to a scythe, that would be the icing of the cake.

Conclusion:

Someone should totally make like a cloak figure skin or something! Works perfectly, great job!

Pros:

Comic book!
Love the poster
The Map lengths were alright
Custom Graffiti,
AWESOME FINALE
re-playable
Ceda 
Custom writing on walls(I guess this falls uner Custom Graffiti.)

Cons:

Ping drop on last two maps
last two maps are very rough for bots
First map at the end, nick got stuck on the  fallen shelves.
Nick also got stuck in the Cement so I wasn't able to finish the campaign, and I didn't replay it. D:
Too many Throwables
Too many explosive made the finale easy
Ceda run was very rough for bots and me, they were very slow and I had to restart because tank came out of nowwhere during my little ping drop which was  1-10 to 60-70. 
More Health packs in the  map 4 and 5.
Maybe some custom music or sounds(No points taken)
The radio didn't speak(no points taken because I don't know if it was intended or not)

Conclusion:

Loved it even though it needs some work, It is the first comic book theme I ever encountered in l4d 2, and it fits nicely with the cartoonish gun sounds!  It needs some more of the custom sounds, and a lot more work try not to drown us in throwables, Great job, definitely worth the Download.

Pros:

Everything, it was beautiful.
All that custom stuff!

Cons:

The finale was a little bit to dry for my tastes.
Too many death spots  in the mansion and railroad tracks.

Conclusion:

It beautiful, one of kind, and a must play. However, I'm ready to see if IHTMT will make something new.  I really not saying anything that the others haven't said.  GREAT JOB.

Pros:

THANK THE HEAVEN
Before, I was just using custom sound mods.
Does exactly what it says in the title

Cons:

Now, I need this for Rochelle, haha.

Conclusion:

Great job, it works and is perfect if you hate pulling out your chainsaw b/c of the noise.

Pros:

Exactly what the title says
I wish you could do this for all my other skins.

Cons:

none at all

Conclusion:

Does exactly what the title says, no more no less.

Pros:

It's chell
Ffps arms
ingame and lobby pic
holds everything correctly

Cons:

weapons mix into the healthpack
no facial or eye movement
Ponytail needs jigglebone
the incap pic is horrible on  lower video settings
Items hang away from body a little

Conclusion:

It's Chell, what is thier to say, maybe fix the cons but they arn't really important, good job.

Pros:

Fun
Gets me pumped
Rare
Something so simple can be so FUN!
Tanks
Plenty of supplies
Closets

Cons:

Impossible for bots

Conclusion:

It is very fun with friends and recommend with friends because with bots, you are screwed to hell! haha, great job, Maybe a jockey map or something of the sorts.

Pros:

awesome
Hate all her laughs but these are better

Cons:

none

Conclusion:

The title explains it all. It is a laugh replacement, and just because I don't like the person, this mod does it's job so 100/100. 

Pros:

AWESOME
it's silver 
reskin

Cons:

Low shader probs but I fixed it and it works like a charm!

Conclusion:

awesome reskin

Pros:

GREAT
Just like from batman aa
Replaces rochelle!
works perfectly

Cons:

No facial expression sadly
no fps arms

Conclusion:

Love it, if you are a die hard batman fan then this is the map for you!

Pros:

Unique
almost portally?(I made up a word)
Traps
all that good custom stuff
Slow motion 
Easy/medium/hard modes
the supplies are put in a very cool way
Barriers

Cons:

Bots don't follow when you go through the doors and only come when the map starts
Lags just a bit
could use just a little more stuff.

Conclusion:

It's a good map worth the download a fun survival/scavenge map to play with friends.  Like Moonstryder said below me it needs a update to fix the fpps issue. Otherwise, It's like portal, It's fun and it's awesome, great job.

Pros:

Works fine for me
SAW
Epic
Best mod ever

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Love it and it's great! Perfect if you're a big fan of saw. :D, Let's play a little game now!

Pros:

He's a cop
He doesn't hate cops anymore!
Now we have an excuse to why we are killing undead flesh addicts!
Or
Francis just being a bada criminal and stealing the suit from a cop.  He isn't the best cop but he sure is tough.

Cons:

Cop with tats?

Conclusion:

awesone skin, love it works great!

Pros:

GORDON FLIPPING FREEMAN
have a reason to get a crowbar!

Cons:

No firstperson view

Conclusion:

Great if you are a fan of half-life and great if you like customizing your character.

Pros:

Perfect life size models
Good map 
Survived twenty minutes outside

Cons:

Im small

Conclusion:

Good map, perfect for friends, After ten minutes maybe the door  and someway to get in should open!

Pros:

Awesome
replaces rochelle!
Love it

Cons:

(not taking points for this) Wish you could replace rochelle's voice

No lip movement
no fps  arms

Conclusion:

Great mod that replaces rochelle, worth dl.

Pros:

something to relax too
Pirates
models
choices on how you want to play
music
Epic easter egg
really good size for a map like this.
good nav

Cons:

Wha...?

Conclusion:

I use this map to relax after playing some other map where I get tired of zombies for a while. The easter egg was Perfect. Please make another map like this so I can relax to something new and I like riding with zombies too, this map is  worth the download!

Pros:

Amazing beginning!
awesome nav
Really interesting places
In MEXICO
CUSTOM ZOMBIES
The finale is awEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESome

Cons:

long
 and a little tedious
bots left me for die at map 2.

Conclusion:

Awesome map, Love it, Valve needs to hire a bunch of people here and their map making skills. You are one of them, sir, again love it.

Pros:

Fun! 
at a school!
plenty of supplies

Cons:

map 2 Kind of bland
invisble furniture
the school needs more props and more writing
a really easy finale

Conclusion:

It was fun and and easy(even on expert.) the high shchool needs more stuff, and more clustery feel. Invisble furniture needs attention. Good job, definitely worth the download.

Pros:

THE WHOLE MAP

Cons:

nothing

Conclusion:

The best survival map ever, along with Santa. I hope you make more maps because you can play this and never get bored!

Pros:

everything from the xmax list, to the slegh riding, adn crhistmas music!

Cons:

to minor to  mention it.

Conclusion:

one of the best survival maps i played of yet!

Pros:

-the way had us go get the supplies instead of just right there in teh saferoom.
-Well layed out
-Original panic moments
-Nice locations (particularly on 2nd map)
-Finale in train yard
-Fits with L4D story

Cons:

-eletric water
-sometime the bots
-Lighting. Whilst tense, sometimes it was simply too difficult to see anything.

- a lot of supplies, didn't feel very challenged.

Conclusion:

A great map, can't wait until it's finished.  The bots are sometime somewhat decent. Love how it fits in with the story line. The final could be more... Epic. but it's whatever, still a great map.