Pros:

- Very fun and nerve-wracking!
- Creative ideas for traps and panic events
- Makes teamwork and communication important
- Lots of supplies along the way

Cons:

- Some of the levels seem a little too long
- Not detailed, but with the idea of the map, it really didn't matter

Conclusion:

This was one of the best campaigns I've ever played in L4D2. It was fun, made us work as a team, and actually required thought and planning. It was very reminiscent of a Zombie Master map, and we all loved that. I'm sure we'll be playing this a WHOLE lot in the future, keep up the awesome work!

Pros:

- College campus idea is a cool idea, that's what made me download the map.
- The first breaking floor thing was unexpected and a nice touch.
- Details on the buildings are good.

Cons:

- The breaking walls look very cheap.
- Too many hordes, and they can spawn right on top of you.
- No direction to the finale trigger.
- Cut scenes were annoying, unnecessary, and made people crash often.
- Too many tanks.
- The map just isn't long enough to be a campaign. The only way to win is to rush.
- First area is too open, and most of the detail work just isn't done yet.

Conclusion:

As a TF2 mapper who's never dared to touch L4D2 authoring tools, I can say that you're well on your way to making some good maps in the future. We didn't like this one, but that was mostly because it obviously isn't finished yet. I'd suggest, given its length, that you go the direction of Helm's Deep, a staged survival map. That would work great with this layout. Keep at it, I can't wait to see this map in the future!

Pros:

- Nice variety of indoor and outdoor areas
- The desert textures, custom overlays, cliffs, and large indoor rooms with tanks were nice touches
- Having to climb over obstacles added to the realism
- The ending was unexpected and the color flashes were fun and quite disorienting

Cons:

- Lack of supplies made the game much less enjoyable, though it didn't add to the difficulty much
- Custom overlays could have been done better
- Some doorways were easy to get stuck in
- The ending didn't make sense, didn't have enough supplies or room to move around, and didn't make sense
- We would have liked it if the color flashes continued throughout the whole finale

Conclusion:

It was a fun campaign and a nice change, but the crescendo events didn't take advantage of the atmosphere as much as they could have. A good campaign, but we won't be playing this one much more.