Pros:

- Nice location
- Nice intro
- Wonderful mapping
- Wonderful Detailing

Cons:

- Saw several map glitches like in the lighthouse, and down around the wind mills, and other places.
- Tanks die easily.

Conclusion:

Make this into a campaign, please. It's an awesome map, but first the minor mapping glitches and fix the Tanks. I only killed 1 Tank in 7 minutes, the rest died after spawning.

Pros:

- Nice atmosphere
- Custom Sounds
- Custom Skybox
- Good texture utilization

Cons:

- Finale was too hard (-4 points)
- Missing Texture on one of the fireplaces (-1 point)
- Can be disorienting or confusing at time (-3 points)
- Broken navs, mainly a cabin in the 2nd level (-3 points)
- Lack of instructor hints (-3 points)

Conclusion:

Overall: 86/100, very stunning campaign, I look forward to playing the full/completed version, this was good for a beta. Keep at it.

Pros:

L4D1 Campaign
Interesting new Routes
The third level crescendo

Cons:

2nd and 3rd map have an ugly blue fog
Melee weapons are very bugged in the third map

Conclusion:

Very well made, fix the bugs and it'll be good.