Pros:

- Absolutely terrifying.

- Puts a whole new spin on the jockey.

- I can honestly say this is my favorite jockey skin.

- Amazing detail which you can see in all sorts of environments.  

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

Exemplary. Simply top-notch.

Pros:

1.) Visuals are amazing.

2.) Great placement of tanks and witches.

3.) Horde spawns make up for the impatience of rushers and their complaints of shortness.

4.) Nostalgia!

Cons:

1.) it's too short!1! - LOL, just kidding.

2.) Teleportation is wacky but fun stuff.

3.) Damn train kept killing my bots.

4.) Even with the texture pack downloaded, I still saw some purple textures.

Conclusion:

I don't know why people comment on the game-play being too short. The author clearly states "Short 30 minute gameplay!" If you think something's too quickly over with, add dynamic game changes, such as modifications to specials, tank hp, common infected health or even just play it on hard eight! There ya go, now the short campaign is nice and much more lengthier.

Regardless of people's abilities to fully read something, I have to say this campaign was truly a pleasure to play. I host a modified hard eight server with highly shortened timers and constant tank spawns and every map was constantly brutal and fun! The narrowness of the hallways combined with small rooms created intense battle sessions. The hatred smokers and jockeys bring with their combined abilities made backtracking something common but the nostalgia, the scenery, and the length, with no game-play errors for myself, make this a favorite on my server. 

Pros:

1.) Absolute Chaos on Hard Eight. Almost next to impossible without four people but even with four players, it gets nuts. The Lava Ledge run is brutal and absolutely unforgiving. 

2) Broken up into sections for preparation.

3) Without four players on anything with 6+ specials, it's next to impossible. Doable but tons of pressure from all sides and the slightest mishap kills ya. 

Cons:

1. ) Should be two parts of the map for those who up the difficulty into double the fun! -1

2.) The Lava Ledges are extremely difficult with multiple smokers and jockeys but, regardless, it is extremely intense. 

Conclusion:

A very enjoyable map with a lot of death spots. Chargers and tanks aren't too much of a problem here as much are the deadliness of a smoker and the chaos a jockey can bring. I would like to see your Rending Halls map; a suggestion! If you broke it up into two maps, as a death map, it'd become a group favorite.