Pros:

- Unique and mesmerizing second part
- Yeti tank
- Sound/music work

Cons:

- Navigation
- Stairs fetish
- The whole radio dialogue is just silly but points for trying

Conclusion:

This is a particularly difficult mod to review because it was made in a rush for a contest, and the amount of work and dedication that went into it pretty much counters any criticism.

However, if you try to review it "objectively", it's still ambiguous.
The first part of the campain is rather bland: the environments seem to have been put together with little concern for fluid navigation or challenging gameplay (pretty much the same remarks as for Fort Noesis).

However when the building lights up, everything changes. I found myself completely immersed and staring in awe at the environments, skillfully completed by a haunting soundtrack (I didn't even mind the nav issues so much).

Some more work on lights and navigation/environment (making some paths more obvious, blocking some views) would be enough to make this map a truly unique and shining example.

Pros:

- Love the intro
- Custom stuff: tags, voice
- Exterior scenes are quite special

Cons:

- Not enough weapons
- Room-Corridor-Room syndrom
- Some environment issues confuse the bots
- No mood, choice of textures questionable

Conclusion:

There's a big discrepancy between the very nice exteriors and the boring interiors. The linear path in buildings gets old fast when the zombies keep running at you in a straight line and the special infected have no chance to surprise you. The finale is particularly boring as the zombies just all mass at choke points.
Overall the maps don't have much personality, and the artistic side of it all is questionable (bad texture choices, no lighting work) - to the exception of the opening and the "plaza" bit. The outdoors parts definitely stand out and have the most potential - I'd love to see them expanded.

Pros:

- Perfect environments, feel real (maybe even better than the official campains)
- Excellent variation of open and closed spaces
- Weapon & items placement variety

Cons:

- Too many deadends and useless areas
- Lighting on night mode could be better
- Navigation is too confusing.

Conclusion:

*review for Coop mode only*
There isn't much to say as this modder clearly knows what he's doing. Maybe even a bit too much, in the sense that too many areas serve no gameplay purpose and seem to only showcase the modder's skills.
The night mode was a disappointment lighting-wise, especially since the inside of the theater has such a great mood. Overall there is little to no indication of where to go, which is particularly problematic on the night map.
However the amazing level of detail and quality of the environment balances out the (small) shortcomings.
Bref, du très bon boulot :)

(was that people f***ing in the first building?)