Pros:

-good directions
-5 maps, I have always liked the 5 map format on campaigns
-posters OK , but could use wall behind it.
-really nice subway looks sweet.
-liked the underground areas .
-loved the fact of being able to walk over a man hole and see the next safe room.

Cons:

-missing soundscapes for example ,map 1, no soundscape inside so by walking out onto the balcony right at the beginning you can hear the wind and outside sound all through the level.
-no survivor dialogue on intro
-intro terribly laggy and glitchy.
not enough details IE dirty areas especially on map 1.Empty corridors and clean walls.
.Boring events, every single one is just flip the switch and a door opens.Needs more originality.
HUGR glitch where you can skip the train part by jumping over it.
-on the map with the bridge need allot of details added to the underneath part of the bridge .
-same map no sound on the opening of the gate.
-no sound in the moving train.
-Can't remember if its map 1 or 2 but the maps are too long.
-empty areas need filling up in the subway.

Conclusion:

Overall good potential on this campaign but allot of work is needed we found playing it.
If all the issues are fixed and maybe shorter maps this would be a top 10-15 for me.
Appreciate all campaigns like this with good work put into it.
Obvious it needs versus mode too.

Pros:

-i have always liked the swamp feeling
-original crescendos but honestly didnt make much sense i'll come back to that in the conclusion
-liked the sugar field area

Cons:

-very empty room
-too much open spaced areads
-too empty
-no outro animation
-the fog looks really bad on the bridge cant remeber the map

Conclusion:

This is promising but like a lot of custom campaigns the mappers prefers (for some unknown reason)to make long empty levels like run to the hills instead of smaller levels with more details and more fun.
There are no flaws no crashes and no big issues and thats a good thing well done.
Obviously inspired by 2evileyes (a good thing)but what makes 2evileyes so popular is that the maps are smaller,much more fun and each map is different,here the maps are quite a like.

This is a very good first shot and i think if you add a lot of details,models/props this will be very good.

The thing i wanted to say about the crecendos is first of all they are all good ideas but with a bit of a polish it ll make them unique =opening a small wooded door that makes a very small "sweeeeak"does not wake up x2 mad zombie hordes.

anyways good job keep it up and it ll be certainly a solid campaign after updates. 

Pros:

-nice to have a snow campaign
-no gamebreakers 
-no item issues for me
-some good areas

Cons:

-intro is far too long 
-voice over is very very bad
-as said horribly empty
-10 times too long
-very bad use of boxing out the maps (the out skirts)

Conclusion:

So first of all i was happy to see a snow campaign for l4d2 and the work put into this is a good thing.
Im very dissapointed that the cons totally killed it for me and the friends i played with i will explain=

ON coop & versys=
*********

An ok piece of work ,nothing amazing just very empty and huge open spaces that arent needed.
On versus the HUGE areas and when i mean HUGE i mean ridiculously ENOURMOUS kill the game totally ,most of the time we just looked at each other saying hmm ok well lets wait a bit before atacking cos u just cant.
Tbh you could make 3 campaigns with such sized maps.I played it with a few mappers and they think the same maybe drastically reduce the size and on the enourmous areas add things...A LOT of things.

So to help you out the things to change without a doubt are =
pathetic voice over
too long intro
the legth of this that is ridiculous
and make the huge areas either full of things or make them smaller
the out skirts are very ugly

I bet you can fix all these things to make this a solid campaign this is the first version so i bet lots of cool things are on their way.
Good luck

Pros:

very good mapping skills
good story good use of original events
i liked the flow
no game breakers

Cons:

a total l4d1 port with nothing added
useless on versus i will come back to that in my conclusion
too dark (personal maybe)

Conclusion:

Very solid campaign no flaws on coop and an overall very good piece of work.Now to what i didnt like ,we are aloud to say what we dont like right?i mean its not that if i dont rate this 100/100 im a total idiot?or a troll?

i played this on coop with 3 friends is was long and fun but its on versus that theres a problem
1/all the maps arent made (obvioulsy as this is a striaght l4d1 port)for spitters,chargers jockeys etc
2/the final maps points are broken ie you dont need to even fight the final and you get full points,as we had a tight game it killed the whole thing for both teams.
3/not enough melee weapons,throwables,no grande launchers basically not enough and i didnt say none,l4d2 items.

So my conclusion is as most l4d1 striaght ports,this is a l4d1 campaign and before its tweaked for l4d2 (which is a total different game)it wont be re played by us and probably many especially on versus i mean you cant play a versus game on 4/5 maps can you be honest.We were really looking foward to this on l4d2 but tbh maybe it would have been better to keep it on l4d1.Dont get me wrong haters,this is very well made,good on coop,no game breakers,very good detail and excellent scenary but for us gamers we prefer to have a fun exciting game on deathaboard ,2evileyes,detour ahead or something like that,they dont look as good true,but are far more fun.

Pros:

-a couple of areas look good
-good ammount of throwables
-quite a challenge

Cons:

-alot of copy paste (not appreciated)
-HUGE AND I MEAN HUGE fps issues
-far too many SI and hordes
-no custom content
-bad nav work
-confusing sometimes
-an obvious l4d1 port

Conclusion:

So ok first of all everyone please stop porting l4d1 maps omg!its not that there arent good or fun or challenging BUT l4d1 is or was a great game but l4d2 is really really different...its not the authors fault i mean mapping without chargers, spitters, jockeys, grenade launchers, boomer bile etc etc is something totally different.
No custom content what so ever was a shame and the copy pasted areas+the fps issues killed it for me.No i dont have a crappy pc what so ever.
This is abit of a shame tbh

ps=oh and with the authors experience over two games and two campaigns the optimisation and bot navigation is a disgrace.

Pros:

liked the flow of the 5 maps alot
no bugs on any mode
good items

Cons:

pathethic having all those lights from the l4d1 version (no need for them its day time!!)making my fps drop

charge someone off the final cliff and survivor dosent die

Conclusion:

A very neat campaign liked it and had fun.To make this better you need to remove all strong lights in the bright day light and tweak a few issues.
71/100