Pros:

- Excellent outdoor urban settings.  Lots of eye candy and feels very realistic.
- Pathways are a bit confusing at first in some places, but after you play the campaign more than once, they're much more obvious.  The paths are actually linear but they don't feel that way, which is not easy to do.   There are some short multiple routes here and there which help.
- Having only two pistols at the start is a bit worrisome but it forces you to focus.
- "Surprise tank" in Map 2 is cool.
- The long narrow walkways around the building are well done.
- The antenna/roof event is a great effect.
- The recording studios are an interesting setting.
- The bridge event on Map 3 is well done and very intense.
- The finale is a good combination of scrounging gas cans and escaping.  It's tough to move the gas cans up to the generator, but if you're quick and systematic it can be done.

Cons:

- Having a few more melee weapons earlier on would be an improvement.  In fact, there could be more melee weapons available for the entire campaign.
- Map 2 had too many defibs as compared to health kits or pills/shots.  This might have been an exception, but at one point we carried four defibs and found another before any health.
- The "drop through the floors" to enter the witch house is an unavoidable death-trap if there is a jockey or smoker waiting at the bottom; bots will take too long to come to your aid, and a witch will kill someone for sure if those specials are there.
- Sometimes the bots have a really hard time navigating to the plane's loading ramp, even if there aren't any zombies to fight.  One time, a bot was stuck at the front of the plane out on the tarmac and I had to spend time shoving him to "free" him enough so he could move back to the ramp.

Conclusion:

(Just for clarity, I always play on Realism > Normal along with the "Gear Transfer" Sourcemod script, which lets bots carry things like grenades and hand them to you when you need one)

Overall, this is a great campaign and I've played it about five times so far.  I enjoy urban settings and this has great examples and a lot of variety.  There is a very good balance of the numbers of commons and specials; you don't feel unfairly overwhelmed but you're always on edge.  The play on the "Home Depot" name makes me laugh every time. You might want to check one the problem with the bot navigation to the plane escape, because it's unfortunate if you die after all that work because they can't find their way up the ramp. In summary, this is one of my new favorite customs.  Thanks for the great work and well done!

Pros:

Unique set of chapters; each one has its own distinct character.
Great use of "elevation changes" in each chapter.  Flat terrain in campaigns can get repetitious but there really is none of that here.
Event where car drops out of the shipping container is a nice creative touch.
The ghost ship is especially creative.  The listing of the ship makes navigating it a real challenge, and requires the player to really pay attention to where he's going.

Cons:

The only one I can think of is that the finale may have a few too many tanks, which makes it really difficult to manage the narrow stairs from the lighthouse down to the docks.

Conclusion:

Just to clarify, I always play campaigns on Realism > Normal, using the "Gear Transfer" add-on script (allows the bots to carry items such as grenades, and then will hand them to you when you don't have one).

A really fun campaign all around.  It never seems to take itself too seriously but is still intense, which is a difficult balance to strike.  So many campaigns try to be "spooky" which actually can get repetitious.  This one has a high entertainment factor.  Each chapter has its own character, and each is memorable.  Also, I enjoy daytime campaigns.

I've played this campaign probably five times, and I just realized that it reminds me of some of the better levels in Doom and Doom 2...which is a real complement imo.

Some say that the finale escape in the balloon is silly, but I laugh every time I see that balloon come floating in. It's very creative.

This has become my favorite custom campaign.  Very well done, and thanks for the great work!

Pros:

Really easy to tell when teammates' health is dropping rapidly, due to the decreasing numbers.
Doesn't cover up any of the other icons for nades, etc.
Can make faster decisions about who needs health.

Cons:

None at all.

Conclusion:

A simple but valuable addition. Knowing the status of whatever is going on (in this case, health) faster and more easily is always a good thing. Good job, and thanks!

Pros:

Overall, the layout, design, atmosphere, etc. are really well done.  As good as any stock or custom campaign I've played.

Cons:

* Do we really need to have two gas cans together, every 100 meters or so?  I've never seen more gas cans in any campaign, anywhere.  It's really overkill.  I kept saying, "oh look, more gas cans.  What a surprise."  Along with that, there are too many propane tanks (which are useless, imo).  You could reduce the number of gas cans and propane in half and still have plenty available.  Playing with the bots, I could have spent the entire campaign carrying and then shooting one gas can after another, with no break in between.

* Pills, and especially shots, are almost nowhere to be found, and I looked pretty hard for them.  Decrease the number of explosives and increase the number of shots/pills.

Conclusion:

I had to knock some points off because of the "weariness" of way too many explosives.  A very well done campaign that needs a couple tweaks to make it a classic.  Thanks!